Tankless Water Heater Reviews 2018: Top Rated Models & Expert Buying Guide
If you typed tankless water heater reviews 2018 into a search engine, you were probably trying to make sense of a market that was rapidly changing. That year was a pivotal one for the category: homeowners were tired of standby heat loss, utility costs were creeping upward, and manufacturers were releasing more compact units with better controls and longer warranties. Even now, those older reviews can still be useful if you are buying used equipment, comparing how today’s models evolved, or trying to understand which features actually matter.
The problem is that many 2018 reviews stopped at star ratings and rebate promises without explaining the trade-offs. A unit that earned praise in a Florida condo may disappoint in a Minnesota basement. A gas model with impressive flow rates might require expensive venting and a larger gas line. This guide revisits the most talked-about tankless water heater reviews from 2018 and breaks down what buyers learned then—and what still applies today.
What Buyers Expected from Tankless Water Heaters in 2018
By 2018, tankless water heaters had moved from niche luxury to mainstream upgrade. Homeowners expected endless hot water, lower energy bills, and a smaller footprint than a traditional tank. Reviewers on retail sites and plumbing forums often rewarded units that delivered steady temperatures and straightforward installation. They were equally quick to criticize noisy operation, weak customer support, and confusing error codes.
The most helpful reviews went beyond first-week impressions. They discussed long-term reliability, parts availability, and whether the unit could handle simultaneous showers and laundry. That practical focus is why 2018 reviews remain valuable for anyone trying to judge real-world performance rather than marketing claims.
Efficiency Ratings and Energy Savings
In 2018, efficiency was usually expressed as Energy Factor, or EF. Electric tankless models often had EF ratings near 0.99 because almost all the energy went into heating water. Gas tankless units ranged from about 0.82 for non-condensing models to 0.95 or higher for condensing units. Reviewers who tracked utility bills reported savings, but the amount depended heavily on hot water usage patterns.
A common theme in 2018 reviews was that tankless water heaters saved the most for households that used hot water in short, concentrated bursts. If a family ran the dishwasher, took showers, and did laundry throughout the day, the savings shrank. If they were away at work and then took evening showers, the absence of standby loss made a noticeable difference.
Sizing and Flow Rate Considerations
Flow rate, measured in gallons per minute, was the make-or-break spec in 2018. A tankless unit must raise incoming groundwater to the desired temperature at a specific flow rate. In cold climates, that temperature rise is larger, so the effective GPM drops. Many negative reviews came from buyers who chose a unit based on price instead of sizing calculations.
For example, a small electric unit rated at 3 GPM might work fine for a single bathroom in a warm climate, but it could struggle to fill a tub in January. Gas units like the Rinnai RL75iN offered higher flow rates, but they needed proper gas line sizing. The best 2018 reviews included details about home size, climate, and simultaneous fixture use, which made them far more useful than generic star ratings.
Standout Tankless Water Heater Models Reviewed in 2018
Several models dominated tankless water heater reviews in 2018. Electric contenders included the EcoSmart ECO 27 and Rheem RTEX-13, while gas favorites included the Rinnai RL75iN and Noritz NRC98-DV. Each had a loyal following, but each also had clear limitations that reviewers were quick to point out.
It is important to read those reviews with context. A model that earned four stars in 2018 may have been replaced by a newer version with better controls or a longer warranty. Still, the core engineering—heat exchanger design, modulation range, and venting requirements—often carried over. Understanding those fundamentals helps you judge whether an older review is still relevant.
Electric Models: EcoSmart ECO 27 and Rheem RTEX-13
The EcoSmart ECO 27 was a popular choice for larger homes with enough electrical capacity. It required multiple dedicated breakers and could draw up to 113 amps, so installation was not a DIY job for most people. Reviewers praised its digital temperature control and ability to handle two showers in warm climates. Complaints often centered on electrical upgrade costs and reduced performance in cold months.
The Rheem RTEX-13 was a smaller electric unit, typically suited for a single bathroom or a small apartment. It was easier to install because it needed fewer breakers, and many 2018 reviews highlighted its compact size and reliable temperature consistency. However, users who expected it to supply a whole house were disappointed. The lesson from both models is that electric tankless performance is tightly tied to available amperage and climate.
Gas Models: Rinnai RL75iN and Noritz NRC98-DV
The Rinnai RL75iN was one of the most reviewed gas tankless water heaters of 2018. It offered a maximum flow rate of 7.5 GPM and a solid reputation for durability. Reviewers liked its precise temperature control and the fact that it could be installed indoors or outdoors with the right venting. The main drawbacks were higher upfront cost and the need for a qualified gas fitter.
The Noritz NRC98-DV was another strong performer, especially for homes with higher hot water demand. It featured a condensing design, which captured heat from exhaust gases and improved efficiency. In 2018 reviews, owners often mentioned lower gas bills and consistent performance during cold weather. The trade-off was a higher price and more complex condensate management. Both models showed why gas tankless units remained the top choice for whole-house applications.
If you are using tankless water heater reviews 2018 as a research starting point, treat them as a time capsule rather than a final verdict. Check whether the model is still available, whether parts and service are easy to find, and whether your home’s electrical panel or gas line can support it. A quick conversation with a licensed plumber or electrician can save you from repeating the mistakes that frustrated buyers years ago. The right tankless system is not the one with the flashiest review—it is the one sized, installed, and maintained for your specific household.