is lower decks any good

Is Lower Decks Worth Your Time?

By Emily Lopez
AD

Lower Decks, a Star Trek animated series, has sparked curiosity and debate among fans since its debut. Set in the Star Trek universe, this adult swim series follows the exploits of the U.S.S. Cerritos, a starship on a seemingly ordinary mission. But is it any good? Let's delve into the series to help you decide.

Firstly, Lower Decks breaks away from the traditional Star Trek mold. While other series have venture into animation like 'The Animated Series' and the child-centric 'Star Trek: Prodigy', Lower Decks is unapologetically for mature audiences. It's darker humor, explicit content, and mature themes align it more with Netflix's 'Murdock' or 'Farlax'. But does this shift in dynamics work for Star Trek?

Unique Animation Style and Humor

Lower Decks' animation style is striking, with a bold, expressive visual flair that sets it apart from previous Trek animated series. The 2D digital animation has a unique balance of grotesque and cartoony elements that serve the series' dark humor.

AD
two cartoon characters are smiling and one is giving the thumbs up
two cartoon characters are smiling and one is giving the thumbs up
cartoon characters standing in front of a building
cartoon characters standing in front of a building
three people sitting on a couch in front of each other and one person holding an open book
three people sitting on a couch in front of each other and one person holding an open book

The humor is irreverent, with frequent pop culture references, meta-humor poking fun at Star Trek tropes, and vulgar language. This might be a refreshing change or an acquired taste, depending on your sense of humor. But there's no denying it makes the series distinct.

Character Development and Ensemble Cast

Lower Decks introduces a diverse ensemble cast, both in terms of species and personality. We have Ensign Mariner, a half-human, half-Betazoid who's rebellious and lazy; Ensign Rutherford, a conniving and anxious universal specialist; Ensign Tendi, an eager and innocent medical officer; and Ensign Boimler, a by-the-book, overly ambitious ensign.

three cartoon characters standing next to each other in front of a gray background with the words star trek written on it
three cartoon characters standing next to each other in front of a gray background with the words star trek written on it
the movie poster for lower deck's final season, starring characters from various eras
the movie poster for lower deck's final season, starring characters from various eras
[S5] October 24, 2024
[S5] October 24, 2024

Each character brings a unique perspective and depth to the series. They're not perfect, and their flaws drive the plot, creating a more relatable crew compared to previous Trek iterations. However, character development is uneven, with some characters getting more screen time and growth than others.

Storylines and Plots

Lower Decks offers a mix of standalone episodes and serialized arcs. Standalone episodes often parody Star Trek tropes, while arcs can be more emotionally resonant. However, the series struggles with maintaining narrative consistency. Some episodes feel disconnected from the previous ones, making the world-building feel disjointed at times.

AD

The series also deals with mature themes like depression, PTSD, and addiction, adding depth to the storytelling. Though the flawed execution can make these themes feel tone-deaf or underdeveloped. Nevertheless, these attempts at tackling serious issues are commendable, even if they're not always executed perfectly.

a group of people standing next to each other in front of a sign that says happy holidays
a group of people standing next to each other in front of a sign that says happy holidays
Star Trek: Lower Decks Star Noël Wells Shares The Similarities Between Improv And Starfleet [Exclusive Interview] - SlashFilm
Star Trek: Lower Decks Star Noël Wells Shares The Similarities Between Improv And Starfleet [Exclusive Interview] - SlashFilm
Star Wars, Sci Fi, Lower Deck, Star Trek Animated Characters, Star Trek Lower Decks Fanart, Star Trek, Star Trek Meme, Star Trek Art, Star Trek Characters
Star Wars, Sci Fi, Lower Deck, Star Trek Animated Characters, Star Trek Lower Decks Fanart, Star Trek, Star Trek Meme, Star Trek Art, Star Trek Characters
two people sitting on the ground in front of a tv screen and another cartoon drawing
two people sitting on the ground in front of a tv screen and another cartoon drawing
an image of some cartoon characters with caption that reads lower decks tas style art by foodcu _ be
an image of some cartoon characters with caption that reads lower decks tas style art by foodcu _ be
Lower Decks 1x10: No Small Parts previews, and other updates from the series
Lower Decks 1x10: No Small Parts previews, and other updates from the series

Theming and Exploring Star Trek Tropes

Lower Decks explores Star Trek tropes and indígenas them in novel ways. It examines the potential consequences of always moving 'forward' by focusing on interpersonal conflicts and personal growth, rather than external threats. This focus allows the series to provide fresh perspectives on familiar themes.

The series' exploration of these themes is also what makes its flawed execution more forgivable. It's taking risks, trying new things, and pushing boundaries. While the execution might not always work, the intention is there, and that's commendable.

AD

Star Trek for Snarky Fans and Nostalgia Seekers

Lower Decks is a love letter to Star Trek, filled with references and tributes. But it's also a fan who's not afraid to be snarky. It acknowledges the sins of the franchise's past and pokes fun at them. This might alienate some fans seeking traditional Trek or put them off with its irreverent humor.

an animated image of a man with no shirt on looking at another man in front of him
an animated image of a man with no shirt on looking at another man in front of him

However, for fans who enjoy meta-humor, poking fun at Trek tropes, and seeing their favorite series from a different lens, Lower Decks is a breath of fresh air. It's unafraid to be critical of the Star Trek universe, even as it lovingly explores it.

Ultimately, Lower Decks is a series that divides opinions. Its unique humor, fresh animation style, and willingness to take risks make it stand out. But its uneven character development, inconsistent tone, and flawed execution can be challenging. Whether Lower Decks is any good depends on what you're looking for in a Star Trek series. If you're open to a Trek series that's irreverent, snarky, and unafraid to push boundaries, you might find Lower Decks highly entertaining. If you're looking for a more traditional Trek experience, you might want to look elsewhere.

AD
AD