is lower decks a good show

Is 'Lower Decks' Worth Watching?

By William Allen
AD

In the vast landscape of modern science fiction, one series has been a standout since 2015: "Star Trek: Discovery." Among its notable achievements is the launch of the animated series "Lower Decks," which debuted in 2020. Fans eager for fresh content within the Star Trek universe may find themselves wondering, "Is Lower Decks a good show?" The answer is complex, dancing on the line between entertaining fan service and creative innovation.

To fully understand where "Lower Decks" fits in the Star Trek landscape, one must trek back to the series' origins. The show is an animated comedy, a deviation from the typical live-action, drama-heavy format of its predecessors. This bold move challenges the norm, sparking curiosity among viewers yearning for something different within the Star Trek universe.

Nostalgia and Homage

"Lower Decks" is a love letter to Star Trek lore, invoking nostalgia in long-standing fans while providing essential context for new viewers. It masterfully weaves familiar characters and elements into a narrative that respects the universe's history while establishing its own distinct identity.

AD
[S5] October 24, 2024
[S5] October 24, 2024
Lower Decks - Season 4
Lower Decks - Season 4
the movie poster for lower deck's final season, starring characters from various eras
the movie poster for lower deck's final season, starring characters from various eras

The series' animation style is another nod to the past. It harkens back to early Trek animated series, but with a modern twist that appeals to contemporary audiences. This blended approach of respecting the past and embracing the future sets "Lower Decks" apart from other Trek series.

The Star Trek: The Next Generation Connection

"Lower Decks" is set in the 24th century, concurrently with "Star Trek: The Next Generation" (TNG). This shared timeline allows the show to crossover with TNG characters, creating exciting intersections between the animated and live-action worlds.

Lower Decks round-up: I, Excretus previews, and Where Pleasant Fountains Lie extra content
Lower Decks round-up: I, Excretus previews, and Where Pleasant Fountains Lie extra content
The Good, the Bad, and the Cross-References — Star Trek: Lower Decks Fifth Season Overview
The Good, the Bad, and the Cross-References — Star Trek: Lower Decks Fifth Season Overview
three people sitting on a couch in front of each other and one person holding an open book
three people sitting on a couch in front of each other and one person holding an open book

By playing in the same sandbox as TNG, "Lower Decks" is able to explore themes and storylines reminiscent of the live-action series. Yet, it carves its unique path through the universe, offering fresh perspectives on familiar themes.

The Animated Advantage

Animation allows "Lower Decks" to venture where live-action can't. It opens doors to incredible visual effects, creatively Bankai-slashing budget constraints, and enabling the exploration of weird and wonderful scenarios that would be impossible otherwise.

AD

Moreover, animation provides "Lower Decks" with the freedom to adopt a more lighthearted tone. It's able to balance moments of humor with the heart and depth that hallmark Star Trek storytelling, offering a unique viewing experience within the franchise.

an animated character holding a glowing ball in front of a poster that says, seek out new life
an animated character holding a glowing ball in front of a poster that says, seek out new life
two cartoon characters are smiling and one is giving the thumbs up
two cartoon characters are smiling and one is giving the thumbs up
Live-action Lower Deckers
Live-action Lower Deckers
an image of cartoon characters with captioning in the bottom right hand corner, which says
an image of cartoon characters with captioning in the bottom right hand corner, which says
Jack Quaid Teases His Favorite Boimler Arc In 'Star Trek: Lower Decks' Season 5
Jack Quaid Teases His Favorite Boimler Arc In 'Star Trek: Lower Decks' Season 5
Star Trek: Lower Decks Season 4 Premiere Review: Of Merges and Moves and Moopsies
Star Trek: Lower Decks Season 4 Premiere Review: Of Merges and Moves and Moopsies

Creativity and Innovation

While nostalgia is a significant draw for "Lower Decks," it's not just a retro gelding. The show pushes boundaries, introducing novel elements to the Star Trek universe while maintaining its core values.

It's a show that respects its origins while striving for originality, from its episodic storytelling structure to the diverse ensemble of characters. This balance of reverence and invention makes "Lower Decks" a thrilling addition to the Star Trek canon.

AD

Episodic Storytelling

"Lower Decks" embraces the episodic format, each episode telling a self-contained story. This approach allows "Lower Decks" to explore a wide range of themes and scenarios, from the personal and interpersonal to the cosmic and absurd.

Mike Bartel
Mike Bartel

The episodic nature also lets the show play with time and continuity in ways that would be impossible for a serialized series. It encourages binge-watching, providing a different viewing experience than traditional Trek series.

Diverse Representation

"Lower Decks" stands out in its commitment to diversity. It introduces characters from various species, backgrounds, and sexual orientations, reflecting the rich tapestry of the Star Trek universe.

AD

By centering a multi-layered ensemble, "Lower Decks" offers a more authentic representation of the future as envisioned by Trek. This inclusivity extends beyond the screen, with a writing team composed mostly of women and people of color.

"Lower Decks" is a bold departure from the typical Star Trek formula, but it's also a triumphant return to the franchise's roots. It's a show that appeals to nostalgic fans while also welcoming neophytes to the Trek fold. In an era of reboots and revivals, "Lower Decks" proves that there's still much to explore in the final frontier. So, is "Lower Decks" a good show? The answer, indeed, is a resonant "live long and prosper."

AD