why is katz deli not kosher

Why Katz Deli Isn't Kosher

By Andrew Lopez
AD

Katz's Delicatessen, a New York City institution since 1888, is renowned for its pastrami sandwiches and deli classics. However, one question often puzzles both first-time visitors and long-time patrons: why is Katz's not kosher? After all, pastrami is a traditional Jewish dish, and many delis began as kosher establishments.

To understand why Katz's isn't kosher, we must delve into the history, practices, and regulations surrounding kashrut, or Jewish dietary laws.

Kosher Standards and Observance

The laws of kashrut dictate which foods are kosher, how they are prepared, and how different foods are consumed together. Crucially, the laws also stipulate that meat cannot be cooked with dairy products, and that kosher-meat must be slaughtered and prepared according to specific rituals.

AD
a sign on the side of a building that says, katz's famous delicatessen known as the best
a sign on the side of a building that says, katz's famous delicatessen known as the best
a blue flyer with information on it for the ktz's delicacies
a blue flyer with information on it for the ktz's delicacies
Katz's Deli Will Make You A Passover Meal, But There's A Huge Catch - Tasting Table
Katz's Deli Will Make You A Passover Meal, But There's A Huge Catch - Tasting Table

Many delicatessens adhere to these laws, earning the kosher certification from the Orthodox Union or another recognized rabbinic authority. So, why doesn't Katz's, with its overtly Jewish menu, follow suit?

Historical Context

Katz's Delicatessen was founded by Hillel successive generations of the Katz family. While the original founders were Jewish, the current owners, including Jake Dell, are not. This change in ownership is one factor that contributed to the decision not to pursue kosher certification.

Katz's Delicatessen in New York: Is America's most famous Jewish deli worth a trip?
Katz's Delicatessen in New York: Is America's most famous Jewish deli worth a trip?
a man wearing a chef's hat standing in front of a group of people
a man wearing a chef's hat standing in front of a group of people
an old brick building with graffiti on the side and signs above it that read, katz's famous deli
an old brick building with graffiti on the side and signs above it that read, katz's famous deli

Additionally, over the years, Katz's has evolved from a neighborhood deli serving a predominantly Jewish community to a major tourist attraction serving a global customer base. This shift has led to a broader approach to menu offerings and increased focus on appealing to a wide range of customers.

Menu Adaptations

Another reason Katz's is not kosher is its inclusive approach to menu accommodations. For instance, Katz's offers turkey and other non-pork sandwiches for customers who do not consume pork. While these options adhere to the kosher laws, the deli also serves pastrami on rye, a sandwich that is not kosher due to the use of pork in the pastrami.

AD

Similarly, Katz's offers a variety of cheese and dairy products, leading to a menu that, while predominantly Jewish in flavor, does not strictly adhere to the laws of kashrut. This approach allows Katz's to cater to its diverse clientele, from Jewish diners to vegetarians and non-Jewish customers.

people are walking on the sidewalk in front of a theater sign at night with cars parked nearby
people are walking on the sidewalk in front of a theater sign at night with cars parked nearby
The King of Pastrami: Looking Back at Katz’s Deli - Tenement Museum
The King of Pastrami: Looking Back at Katz’s Deli - Tenement Museum
the logo for katz's delicatessen
the logo for katz's delicatessen
45 Things to See and Do in New York City
45 Things to See and Do in New York City
NYC's Katz's Delicatessen is now available for delivery across Canada | Daily Hive | Dished
NYC's Katz's Delicatessen is now available for delivery across Canada | Daily Hive | Dished
a man walking down the sidewalk in front of a store
a man walking down the sidewalk in front of a store

umina's Accommodations for Dietary Restrictions

Despite not being kosher-certified, Katz's endeavors to accommodate customers with various dietary restrictions. The deli offers options for vegetarians, vegans, and those with nut allergies. It also maintains separate prep and cooking areas for its dairy-free and non-dairy products, minimizing the risk of cross-contamination.

However, these accommodations do not make Katz's kosher, as they do not comply with the strict supervision and certification process required for kosher status.

AD

Consumer Preferences

Today, many consumers, not just Jews, enjoy traditional deli fare. According to a 2019 survey by the market research firm YouGov, 64% of Americans who have eaten at a deli said it was a positive experience. This consumer trend highlights the appeal of deli classics beyond the Jewish community, further incentivizing establishments like Katz's to cater to a broader audience.

In fact, Katz's diverse and inclusive approach has led it to become an integral part of New York City's cultural landscape, a gathering place for locals and tourists alike, regardless of their religious or dietary affiliations.

In conclusion, Katz's Delicatessen's decision not to pursue kosher certification is rooted in its evolution from a small, Jewish-owned deli to a bustling New York City institution catering to a diverse, global clientele. While it does not adhere to the strict standards of kashrut, Katz's remains committed to maintaining high-quality, authentic deli dishes and accommodating various dietary restrictions. So, whether you're a lifelong deli enthusiast or a first-timer, there's something for everyone at this iconic institution.

AD
AD