What to Compost: 75+ Everyday Items for Black Gold
Composting is one of the most satisfying rituals in a sustainable household: you take everyday leftovers and yard debris, and nature turns them into dark, crumbly compost that feeds soil like nothing else. The catch is that successful composting starts long before you turn the pile. It starts with knowing exactly what to compost, what to leave out, and how to combine materials so your bin breaks down efficiently instead of turning into a smelly, pest-friendly mess.
Whether you use a backyard pile, a tumble bin, a worm farm, or a curbside program, the same basic rule applies: microbes need the right mix of nitrogen, carbon, moisture, and oxygen. This guide breaks down the best compost ingredients by category, highlights common items that should stay out of your bin, and offers practical ways to keep your compost active, clean, and ready to use.
What to Compost: The Core Ingredients of a Healthy Pile
Compostable materials fall into two broad camps: greens and browns. Greens are fresh, moist, and rich in nitrogen; they feed the microorganisms that drive decomposition. Browns are dry, dead, and rich in carbon; they provide energy, soak up excess moisture, and create air pockets so the pile can breathe. A healthy compost pile is not a random dump of scraps but a deliberate mix of these two types.
A simple rule of thumb is to add roughly two to three parts browns for every one part greens by volume. If your pile smells sour, feels slimy, or attracts flies, you likely need more browns. If it sits dry and refuses to heat up, add greens and a splash of water. The goal is a texture like a wrung-out sponge and a size roughly three feet wide, three feet tall, and three feet deep for hot backyard composting.
Nitrogen-Rich Greens: The Energy Boost Your Compost Needs
Green materials are the fuel of the compost pile. They are typically fresh, colorful, and wet, and they break down quickly once mixed into the bin. Common greens include fruit and vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, tea leaves, fresh grass clippings, plant trimmings, and manure from herbivores such as rabbits, chickens, cows, and horses. These items supply the nitrogen that microbes need to multiply and generate heat.
To get the best results, chop large scraps into smaller pieces and mix greens into the center of the pile rather than leaving them on top. Coffee grounds can be added with paper filters if the filters are unbleached and chemical-free. Grass clippings should be spread in thin layers or mixed with leaves to prevent matting. A pile that is mostly greens will compact, smell, and turn anaerobic, so always pair them with a generous dose of browns.
Carbon-Rich Browns: The Structure and Airflow Makers
Brown materials are dry, fibrous, and high in carbon. They are the backbone of a balanced compost pile because they absorb moisture, add bulk, and keep the pile porous. Excellent browns include dry autumn leaves, straw, hay, shredded cardboard, newspaper, plain paper, paper towels, egg cartons, wood chips, sawdust, corn stalks, and pine needles. These materials decompose more slowly, which is exactly why they help maintain airflow over time.
Shred or tear cardboard and paper before adding them so they break down faster and do not mat into impermeable layers. Avoid glossy paper, colored ink, and receipts that may contain plastic coatings or chemicals. Pine needles and wood chips are acidic and slow to decompose, but they are fine in moderation when mixed with other browns. If your compost pile is too wet, browns are your first fix; if it is too dry, add greens and water.
What Not to Compost: Practical Guidelines for Home Composters
Even with a good greens-to-browns ratio, some materials are better suited to home composting than others. Kitchen scraps, yard waste, and paper products are the everyday staples, but certain items can attract rodents, create foul odors, or introduce pathogens and toxins. Knowing where to draw the line keeps your pile productive and your neighborhood happy.
Home composters can generally process a wide range of plant-based materials, but they should be cautious with cooked foods, greasy items, and anything that has been treated with synthetic chemicals. If you use a bokashi system or a commercial hot composter, you may be able to handle small amounts of meat, dairy, and oily food, but traditional backyard bins do best with fruit, vegetables, coffee, tea, leaves, grass, and paper.
Kitchen Scraps and Household Paper You Can Compost Safely
The kitchen is a goldmine for compost. Fruit and vegetable peels, cores, seeds, and wilted greens are all fair game. You can also add coffee grounds, loose tea, paper tea bags without plastic, crushed eggshells, stale bread, plain pasta, rice, oatmeal, and grains. Nut shells are acceptable in small amounts, though black walnut shells should be avoided because they contain juglone, which can harm some plants.
Paper and natural fiber products are valuable browns. Add newspaper, office paper, cardboard, paper towel rolls, egg cartons, paper plates without a plastic coating, napkins, and paper bags. Natural fiber textiles such as cotton, linen, wool, silk, and hemp can be composted if they are cut into small pieces and free of synthetic blends, dyes, and elastic. Dryer lint is acceptable only if your clothing is made from natural fibers and free of fabric softener residue.
Items That Attract Pests, Create Odors, or Contaminate Compost
Some items should never go into a traditional home compost pile. Meat, fish, bones, dairy products, grease, oils, and fatty foods decompose slowly and produce strong odors that attract raccoons, rats, and dogs. Pet waste from dogs and cats can carry harmful parasites and pathogens, and cat litter often contains clay, silica, or plastic that will not break down. Diseased plants, invasive weeds with seeds, and plants treated with persistent herbicides can survive composting and spread problems into your garden.
Synthetic and chemically treated materials are also off-limits. Avoid plastic, bioplastic that requires industrial composting, produce stickers, tea bags with plastic mesh, coffee pods, dryer sheets, vacuum bags, cigarette butts, glossy paper, receipts, charcoal ash, coal ash, pressure-treated wood, painted wood, and particleboard. These items either fail to decompose, introduce toxins, or contaminate the finished compost. When in doubt, leave it out; a clean pile is worth more than a fast one.
Start small by collecting fruit and vegetable scraps in a countertop pail, then layer them with dry leaves or shredded paper whenever you empty the container. Watch how the pile responds, adjust the mix, and let the process teach you what your system likes. A few weeks of mindful adding and turning can turn your daily waste into a steady supply of garden gold.