vinyl siding reviews 2017

Vinyl Siding Reviews 2017: Top Brands, Costs & What Homeowners Said

By Amanda Allen
AD

Homeowners shopping for exterior upgrades in 2017 had more vinyl siding options than ever before, and the market responded with a wave of new textures, colors, and insulation-backed panels designed to mimic wood and stone. That year marked a turning point for the category, as manufacturers pushed premium product lines while budget-friendly builders' grades remained widely available. Understanding what real buyers, contractors, and industry experts said about vinyl siding in 2017 helps put today's choices in perspective, whether you're replacing a worn-out facade or planning a new build.

Vinyl siding reviews from 2017 reveal a category caught between its reputation as an affordable, low-maintenance workhorse and a growing demand for high-end aesthetics. Consumer reporting outlets, contractor forums, and manufacturer spec sheets all told a similar story: quality varied enormously by brand and product tier, installation mattered as much as the material itself, and homeowners who did their homework generally ended up satisfied. This article breaks down the key themes from that year's reviews so you can spot the lessons that still apply to any siding project today.

Top-Rated Vinyl Siding Brands and Product Lines in 2017

Brand reputation carried significant weight in 2017 reviews, largely because vinyl siding performance depends on formulation chemistry, panel thickness, and quality control. The names that appeared most often at the top of contractor and consumer lists included CertainTeed, Mastic (owned by Ply Gem), Royal Building Products, Alside, and Heartland. Each of these manufacturers offered multiple tiers, from entry-level panels sold through big-box retailers to premium insulated lines available mainly through professional dealers.

AD
64 Striking Siding Ideas to Transform Your Home’s Exterior with Style and Durability
64 Striking Siding Ideas to Transform Your Home’s Exterior with Style and Durability
the side of a house with grass and bushes
the side of a house with grass and bushes
the different colors of vinyl siding
the different colors of vinyl siding

Reviewers consistently noted that the gap between a builder's-grade panel and a top-tier insulated panel was enormous, often more noticeable than the gap between two competing premium brands. Thickness ratings, measured in mils, became a shorthand for quality in many 2017 discussions. Panels in the 0.040 to 0.046-inch range generally earned better marks for rigidity and wind resistance than thinner 0.035-inch products, though price climbed accordingly.

CertainTeed and Mastic Premium Lines

CertainTeed's CedarBoards and Monogram lines drew praise in 2017 for their realistic wood grain and consistent color matching across runs. Reviewers highlighted the brand's polymer formulation, which seemed to hold up well against fading in southern climates. Mastic's Structures and Quest lines earned similar respect, particularly for their insulated backing options that added an R-value of around 2.0 to 4.0 depending on the product.

24 Practical Green Houses With Vinyl Siding That Look Great Longer
24 Practical Green Houses With Vinyl Siding That Look Great Longer
40 Vinyl Siding Colors to Transform Your Home Exterior Style - PlusMood
40 Vinyl Siding Colors to Transform Your Home Exterior Style - PlusMood
Insulated Vinyl Siding: Pros/Cons, Reviews & Prices
Insulated Vinyl Siding: Pros/Cons, Reviews & Prices

Contractors who worked with both brands often pointed out that CertainTeed panels tended to feel stiffer out of the box, which made them slightly easier to handle on windy job sites. Mastic, meanwhile, was frequently cited for a broader selection of darker, richer colors that resisted the chalky appearance some cheaper vinyl developed after a few summers of sun exposure.

Mid-Range and Budget Options

For homeowners watching every dollar, brands like Alside, Royal, and Heartland dominated the value conversation in 2017. Alside's Charter Oak and Prodigy lines were common recommendations for rental properties and starter homes, thanks to reasonable durability at a lower price per square. Royal's Estate and Woodland Retreat collections sat slightly higher on the quality ladder and often appeared in mid-range remodeling projects.

AD

Budget reviews came with clear warnings, though. Very thin, low-cost panels sold at deep discounts frequently generated complaints about oil-canning, the wavy distortion that appears when panels are nailed too tightly or when cheap vinyl expands and contracts. The takeaway from 2017 was consistent: saving a few hundred dollars upfront on the thinnest available panels often meant paying for regret later.

Vinyl Siding Profiles, what each type and style looks like.
Vinyl Siding Profiles, what each type and style looks like.
15+ Stylish Vinyl Siding Ideas for Your Home - Garden.eco
15+ Stylish Vinyl Siding Ideas for Your Home - Garden.eco
the color chart for vinyl siding
the color chart for vinyl siding
Mastic Charleston Beaded
Mastic Charleston Beaded
A Buyer's Guide to Vinyl Siding | Beissel Window & Siding
A Buyer's Guide to Vinyl Siding | Beissel Window & Siding
a blue house with the words kaycan vinyl siding won't fade over time
a blue house with the words kaycan vinyl siding won't fade over time

Performance, Durability, and Real-World Feedback

Durability reviews in 2017 focused on a handful of recurring issues: fading, cracking, warping, and impact resistance. Modern vinyl formulations had largely solved the brittleness problems that plagued products from the 1980s and 1990s, but cheap panels still cracked in extreme cold. Homeowners in northern states reported that mid-grade and premium panels handled freeze-thaw cycles far better than bargain-bin alternatives.

Color retention was another major theme. Early-generation vinyl had a reputation for fading to a pale, washed-out version of its original hue, but 2017-era products with darker colors and improved pigments held up noticeably better. That said, reviewers cautioned that no vinyl is entirely fade-proof, and darker colors absorb more heat, which can accelerate expansion and contraction.

AD

Wind Resistance and Impact Testing

Wind ratings became a selling point that manufacturers leaned into heavily in 2017. Premium insulated panels frequently carried ratings of 110 mph or higher when installed per manufacturer specs, and some lines were tested to 150 mph. Reviewers emphasized that these numbers only meant something when the installation followed the manufacturer's nailing pattern, used the correct starter strips, and accounted for proper clearance in the nail slots.

Ecofriendly Vinyl Siding: A Surprising Way to Go Green - Exterior DIY and Home Improvement
Ecofriendly Vinyl Siding: A Surprising Way to Go Green - Exterior DIY and Home Improvement
Vinyl siding prices, pros and cons
Vinyl siding prices, pros and cons
5 Reasons Homeowners Choose Vinyl Siding
5 Reasons Homeowners Choose Vinyl Siding

Impact resistance was more of a mixed bag. Hailstorms in the Midwest and Texas generated a steady stream of owner complaints about cracked or punctured panels, even on mid-grade products. Some premium lines with thicker walls and reinforced profiles fared better, but no vinyl siding is truly hail-proof, and 2017 reviews made that limitation clear.

Maintenance and Long-Term Appearance

One of vinyl's biggest selling points remained its low maintenance profile. A simple wash with a garden hose and mild detergent restored most panels to a like-new appearance, and unlike wood, vinyl never needed repainting or scraping. Reviewers in 2017 appreciated that this translated into decades of minimal upkeep, provided the original installation was done correctly.

AD

The catch, according to long-term owner reviews, was that vinyl could develop a dull, chalky film over time, especially on south- and west-facing walls. Periodic cleaning with the right products helped, but harsh solvents and abrasive brushes could scratch the surface and void warranties. Paintable vinyl also gained traction that year, giving homeowners a way to refresh color without replacing panels.

Cost, Installation, and What Reviews Got Right

Cost discussions dominated 2017 vinyl siding reviews because price is the category's biggest advantage. Typical installed costs ranged from roughly $3 to $5 per square foot for standard panels, while insulated or premium products pushed into the $6 to $9 range. By comparison, fiber cement and engineered wood commonly landed between $8 and $12 per square foot installed, making vinyl the clear budget leader.

Installation quality emerged as the single most important variable in homeowner satisfaction. Reviews from that year repeatedly showed that the same panel could perform beautifully or terribly depending on the crew. Improper nailing, missing flashing, and inadequate clearance around windows and doors caused the majority of problems that reviewers attributed to "bad siding."

Hidden Costs and Warranty Details

Warranties in 2017 looked generous on paper, with many manufacturers advertising lifetime coverage on materials. The fine print told a different story. Most warranties were prorated, transferable only once or not at all, and void if the siding was installed by an un certified contractor or over an inadequate substrate. Labor coverage was rare, meaning homeowners often paid out of pocket even when materials were replaced for free.

Additional costs also caught some buyers off guard. Removing old siding, replacing rotted sheathing, adding house wrap, and trimming out windows and doors could add thousands to a project. Reviews advised getting itemized quotes that separated material, labor, removal, and disposal so nothing was buried in a lump-sum figure.

Insulated Siding and Energy Claims

Insulated vinyl siding was one of the hottest topics in 2017 reviews. Panels with contoured foam backing promised added R-value, reduced noise, and a more rigid appearance that resisted denting. Homeowners who upgraded from thin, uninsulated panels often described the difference as night and day in terms of both looks and solidity underfoot.

Energy savings claims, however, deserved skepticism. The added R-value of most insulated siding fell between 2.0 and 4.0, which is modest compared to proper wall insulation upgrades. Reviewers concluded that insulated siding was worth the premium mainly for its appearance and durability benefits, with energy savings serving as a nice bonus rather than the primary justification.

Looking back at the vinyl siding landscape of 2017 offers a useful reality check for anyone weighing exterior options now. The technology has continued to improve, but the fundamentals from that year's reviews still hold: buy the thickest panel your budget allows, choose a reputable brand with solid color-matching, and above all, hire an installer who treats the manufacturer's instructions as non-negotiable. If you're planning a siding project, start by requesting quotes from at least three certified contractors, ask to see samples of the actual product in natural light, and confirm in writing exactly what the warranty covers before you sign anything.

AD