Undertale Mermaid: Dive Into the Best Mermaid AU Art, Stories, and Fan Creations
The phrase "Undertale mermaid" brings together two things that seemingly have nothing to do with each other: Toby Fox's 2015 indie RPG about monsters sealed beneath a mountain, and the timeless fantasy of merfolk who trade legs for tails. Search that phrase on any art platform and you will find reimagined versions of Undyne, Alphys, Frisk, and even Flowey, all swimming through coral-lit ruins instead of snowy forests. It is one of the most persistent and visually striking alternate universe (AU) trends the Undertale fandom has ever produced.
What makes it stick is that Undertale was already halfway to being a mermaid story. The game's third major area, Waterfall, is built around glowing blue water, echo flowers, and bioluminescent marshland, and its most famous resident, Undyne, is literally a fish monster with gills and fins. Fans did not have to stretch very far to imagine the whole Underground as an ocean floor. They just had to follow the current.
The Undertale Mermaid AU Explained
An AU, or alternate universe, is a fan-created reinterpretation that moves a story's characters into a new setting while keeping their personalities and relationships intact. The Undertale mermaid AU does exactly that: it replaces the mountain with the sea, the human-monster war with a surface-versus-deep conflict, and the player's journey with a dive into waters no human was meant to reach. Frisk becomes a swimmer who falls instead of climbs, and the monsters of the Underground become merfolk, sirens, and deep-sea creatures living in sunken ruins.
Unlike a simple costume swap, a well-built mermaid AU usually rewrites the world's rules. Water pressure replaces SOUL-trapping barriers. Air becomes a limited resource, which gives the "stay determined" theme an entirely new weight. A player who cannot breathe has a very literal reason to keep moving toward the surface, and that tension is what separates a lazy redraw from a genuinely thoughtful reinterpretation.
How the Merfolk Trend Started in the Fandom
The mermaid version of Undertale grew from several smaller waves rather than one viral post. Between 2016 and 2019, Undertale fan art dominated Tumblr, DeviantArt, and Twitter, and artists constantly looked for fresh ways to draw the same cast. Mermaid AUs were already popular in anime and cartoon fandoms, so the crossover was inevitable. The first wave focused almost entirely on Undyne, because a spear-wielding fish knight with a tail writes itself.
Once artists started posting those designs, the concept snowballed. Animators added looping underwater fight scenes set to "Spear of Justice" and "Battle Against a True Hero." Playlist creators built ocean-themed mixes for each character. By the time TikTok and YouTube Shorts became major hubs for Undertale content, the mermaid AU had already become a recognizable subgenre with its own visual shorthand, including kelp crowns, glowing freckles, and bioluminescent tattoos.
Canon Hints That Made Mermaids Feel Plausible
Undertale gives fans plenty of canon material to work with. Shyren, the humming monster you encounter in Waterfall, is essentially already a mermaid: a humanoid upper body fused to a fish tail, with a voice strong enough to call reinforcements. The game also features Aaron the seahorse, Woshua, Moldbygg, and the entire aquatic ecosystem of Waterfall, which functions like a reef community with its own social hierarchy.
Then there is Undyne herself. She lives in a house shaped like a fish, keeps a giant sword, and describes herself as a warrior who trained to the point of exhaustion. Her design leans on sharp teeth and gill-like markings, and her Undying form pushes those aquatic traits even further. When canon already frames a character as a predator of the deep, turning her into a full merfolk is less of a leap and more of a landing.
Designing Undertale Characters as Merfolk
The most successful mermaid AUs treat tail design the way the original game treats silhouettes: every character should be identifiable from across the room. Sans is usually drawn as a slow-moving, heavy-bodied creature like an anglerfish or a moray eel, which matches his lazy posture and hidden threat. Papyrus gets something tall, fast, and a little ridiculous, such as a long ribbon-like tail or a sailfish build that lets him bolt toward danger at absurd speed.
Flowey is the trickiest translation. Some artists turn him into a sea anemone with a deceptive lure. Others make him a parasitic isopod or a carnivorous barnacle that attaches to whatever it touches. The best versions keep his unsettling cheerfulness intact, because a smiling flower in a garden is creepy; a smiling anemone in a sunlit reef is worse.
Undyne, Alphys, and the Waterfall Cast
Undyne is the anchor of almost every Undertale mermaid piece. Artists typically give her a shark, barracuda, or orca tail, sharp fins along the forearms, and a patch of red-orange scales that echoes her original hair. Her eye patch, armor, and spear stay in place, often reforged from coral, bone, or shipwrecked metal. The goal is to preserve her intensity while making the water feel like her true home rather than a costume she is wearing.
Alphys works best as something unexpected rather than glamorous. An axolotl, an eel, or a reclusive deep-sea lizard all fit her anxious, brilliant, self-isolating personality. Placing her in a submerged laboratory lit by bioluminescent tanks creates an instant visual joke: the most science-driven character in the game finally has a workspace where the equipment has to be waterproof. Pairing her awkwardness with Undyne's boldness still carries the emotional weight of their relationship, tail fins and all.
Frisk, Sans, and the Rest of the Underground
Frisk is the audience surrogate, so most artists keep the design simple and readable. A small, neutral-toned tail, a striped shirt, and wide eyes do the job. The interesting variations come from the Pacifist and Genocide routes: in a Pacifist mermaid AU, Frisk might gently dispel a sea creature instead of killing it, while a Genocide version turns the ocean silent and empty, with echoes of what was lost.
Toriel reads naturally as a gentle manatee or a large soft-finned guardian, while Asgore becomes a lionfish or coelacanth with too much armor for his own good. Asriel is usually drawn small and hopeful, often contrasted against a colder, deeper setting. Mettaton is the wildcard, and artists lean into it: a robotic mermaid idol, a sequined starfish, or a glamorous performer in a bubble dome. Napstablook becomes something translucent and drifting, which suits a ghost who never quite fit anywhere.
Where Undertale Mermaid Content Lives Online
If you want to find mermaid versions of Undertale characters, the richest archives are on art and writing platforms rather than search engines. DeviantArt hosts thousands of still pieces, ranging from quick sketches to fully rendered character sheets. Tumblr remains the best place for multi-part AU worldbuilding, because creators can post long design notes, asks, and story threads in one scrolling blog.
YouTube and TikTok handle motion. Animatic creators use the game's soundtrack to build underwater chase scenes, while speedpaint channels walk viewers through the process of designing a tail that still reads as "Papyrus." Reddit's dedicated Undertale communities and Discord servers for AU roleplay are where the concept gets tested live, with writers improvising dialogue for a Frisk who cannot speak underwater.
Fan Art, Animation, and Cosplay
Cosplay is where the Undertale mermaid trend gets impressively physical. Builders create wearable tails with flexible spines, silicone fins, and hand-painted scales that match Undyne's red-orange palette. Mermaid pods at conventions have hosted Undertale group photos where five or six cosplayers pose together in coordinated tails, recreating the Waterfall chase in a hotel lobby fountain or a rented pool.
Digital artists, meanwhile, focus on lighting. Underwater scenes require a completely different approach to color, since red light disappears first as depth increases. Skilled illustrators push their palettes toward blue-green and rely on glowing accents for detail. That technical challenge is part of the appeal, and it is why so many mermaid AU pieces look noticeably more polished than a standard character redraw.
Fanfiction, Roleplay, and Music
On Archive of Our Own, mermaid AUs appear under tags for merfolk, alternate universe, and aquatic settings, often blending with soulmate or royalty tropes. Writers usually keep the core emotional beats of Undertale intact: a determined child, a guard who learns compassion, a scientist who regrets her choices. What changes is the pressure. Every conversation happens with limited breath, and every current can carry someone away from the people they love.
Music creators add another layer. Remixes of "Waterfall" and "Undyne" with aquatic reverb and low, rolling basslines are common, and some fans compose entirely original scores for their AU trailers. Roleplay communities take it further, running long-form stories on Discord where players describe currents, temperatures, and the strange creatures patrolling the dark below the Ruins.
Undertale has always been a story about who gets to be seen as a person, and the mermaid AU quietly extends that question into a world where the answer depends on how well you can swim. Whether you are drawing a shark-tailed Undyne, writing a deep-sea Alphys, or just scrolling through other people's worlds late at night, there is room in this current for you. Pick a character, sketch a fin, and see where the tide takes the story next.