tips for building your first commander deck

Tips for Building Your First Commander Deck

By Kevin Taylor
AD

Embarking on your Commander journey? Building your first EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander, or Commander) deck can be an exciting and rewarding experience. Commander is a unique Magic: The Gathering format that emphasizes strategy, customization, and fun. Here are some tips to help you craft your inaugural Commander deck, perfect for both new and veteran players alike.

Before we dive into the details, let's briefly discuss the Commander rules. Each deck contains 100 cards, with a Singleton rule - allowing only one copy of any card (barring basic lands). The format revolves around one legendary creature - your 'Commander' - which you'll cast repeatedly throughout the game, making it a crucial focus.

Choosing Your Commander

Selecting your Commander is the first and most important decision. Your Commander should represent your deck's strategy, flavor, or colors. It doesn't necessarily have to be a powerful card; rather, choose one that appeals to you.

AD
How to Build a Commander Deck in MTG – Full Guide!
How to Build a Commander Deck in MTG – Full Guide!
Tezzeret Art, Mtg Huatli, Magic The Gathering Phyrexia, Magic The Gathering Crimson Vow, Mtg Phyrexian, Githzerai Vs Githyanki, Mtg Art Magic The Gathering, Magic The Gathering Riftwar Cycle, Ikoria World Magic The Gathering
Tezzeret Art, Mtg Huatli, Magic The Gathering Phyrexia, Magic The Gathering Crimson Vow, Mtg Phyrexian, Githzerai Vs Githyanki, Mtg Art Magic The Gathering, Magic The Gathering Riftwar Cycle, Ikoria World Magic The Gathering
Best Decks to Build on a Budget w/ The Commander’s Quarters I The Command Zone 293 I Magic MTG
Best Decks to Build on a Budget w/ The Commander’s Quarters I The Command Zone 293 I Magic MTG

For beginners, consider mono-colored Commanders like Tajic, Legion's Edge or Jeskai Ascendancy for a balance of power and simplicity. Once you're familiar with the format, explore multicolored or colorless Commanders, which often provide more complex interaction possibilities.

Understanding Commander Colors

Magic: The Gathering's five colors represent different attributes and playstyles. White represents a proactive, life-gaining strategy, while Black focuses on hurting your opponents. Blue controls the board with counterspells and draw effects, Green provides big, efficient creatures and disruption, Red offers quick damage and burn, and Colorless allows access to mana rocks and artifacts.

How to Choose Your First Commander (Easy MTG Flowchart)
How to Choose Your First Commander (Easy MTG Flowchart)
5 Reasons Your Commander Deck Isn't Winning Games - CK Blog
5 Reasons Your Commander Deck Isn't Winning Games - CK Blog
Card Games
Card Games

By understanding these color philosophies, you can create a coherent and synergistic deck. For instance, a Stompy or Aggro deck in Red-Green will focus on big creatures and immediate damage, while a control deck in Blue-Black will emphasize countermagic and removal.

Deck Construction Basics

Your Commander should dictate your deck's strategy and composition. A classic Commander deck includes 36-38 lands, 12-14 creatures, 18-20 spells (instant, sorcery, and enchantment), 12-15 "utility" cards (like tutors, removal, or draw spells), and 35-37 cards in the Commander zone (Bojuka Bog, known cards, ancient времяCards of note, etc.)

AD

When building your lands, consider both basics and utility lands. Fetchlands can assist in ramping and fixing mana, while dual and triple lands help smooth out your draws. Remember, Commander is a Singleton format, so you'll want access to all your colors consistently.

How to Convert Your MTG Arena Deck Between Bo1 and Bo3
How to Convert Your MTG Arena Deck Between Bo1 and Bo3
MTG EDH Deck Tech | Necron Dynasties Crossover with Warhammer 40K
MTG EDH Deck Tech | Necron Dynasties Crossover with Warhammer 40K
Building Handrails for a Wooden Deck - Today's Homeowner
Building Handrails for a Wooden Deck - Today's Homeowner
Magic The Gathering: The Top 5 Commander Deckbuilding Tools
Magic The Gathering: The Top 5 Commander Deckbuilding Tools
Commander Deck Building Checklist | EDH Deck Planner | MTG Printable | Magic the Gathering Digital Download
Commander Deck Building Checklist | EDH Deck Planner | MTG Printable | Magic the Gathering Digital Download
How To Build A Magic: The Gathering Deck?
How To Build A Magic: The Gathering Deck?

Testing and Refining Your Deck

Once you've assembled your initial list, play some games and see how your deck performs. Use websites like Archidekt or TappedOut to import and test your deck, track your games, and gather data on what works and what doesn't.

Remember, Commander is a learning experience. Don't be afraid to experiment with different cards and strategies. Listen to your play group's feedback, and don't take their suggestions personally. They can provide valuable insights into your deck's strengths and weaknesses.

AD

Tuning Your Mana Curve

Balance your mana curve by ensuring you have enough early-game threats, mid-game interaction, and late-game win conditions. Aim for a curve that allows you to have something relevant to play every turn. Typically, Commander decks should average around four mana per card.

Building Mono-Colored Commander Decks | MTG Cards - Card Kingdom
Building Mono-Colored Commander Decks | MTG Cards - Card Kingdom

Use tools like GatheringMagic's Mana Curve Analyzer to visualize your distribution. Adjust your cards accordingly, moving costly and redundant pieces out to make room for more impactful ones.

Playtesting and Iteration

In Commander, no deck is truly perfect. Playtesting and iteration are crucial steps in refining your deck. Track your wins and losses, identifying trends and problem areas. Don't hesitate to swap cards or entire strategies based on your findings.

AD

Consider playing alongside experienced Commander players, who can provide valuable perspective and advice. Join Commander forums and communities - like r/EDH or EDHRec - to discuss strategies, share decks, and learn from others' experiences.

As you progress through your Commander journey, you'll encounter countless memorable moments and exciting matches. Building and refining your decks is a continual, engaging process that evolves with you and your play group. Embrace the learning experience, and above all, have fun! Good luck, and may your Commander lead you to victory!

AD