the house next door is real story

The Neighbors' True Tale: Unveiling the House Next Door

By Christopher Robinson
AD

The house next door, a seemingly ordinary dwelling, holds secrets that ripple through time, touched by tragedy, love, and perhaps, the supernatural. This is not fiction; it is the real story of 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, now famously known as the 'Amityville Horror' house.

The events that unfolded there in 1974 have been immortalized in books, movies, and even board games, yet the reality of what transpired is fascinatingly complex. Let's delve into the story that transcends horror tropes and reveals a human drama wrapped in eerie mystery.

The Lutz Family's Disastrous Tenancy

In December 1975, George and Kathy Lutz, along with their three children, moved into 112 Ocean Avenue. They had purchased the house cheap, unaware of its sinister history. Little did they know, a year earlier, the home had been a crime scene of horrific proportions.

AD
The House Next Door
The House Next Door
the house next door is shown in red
the house next door is shown in red
Crime Time Podcast on X
Crime Time Podcast on X

Intriguingly, the Lutzes didn't intend to stay long; they planned to renovate and sell the house. Yet, within 28 days of moving in, they fled, claiming to have experienced terrifying paranormal events. Their account, published as "The Amityville Horror" by Jay Anson, launched a bestseller and a cultural phenomenon.

The 1974 murders

To understand the Lutzes' ordeal, we must rewind to November 1974. The DeFeo family lived at 112 Ocean Avenue. One fateful night, eldest son Ronald shot and killed his parents and four siblings in their beds, uttering the chilling phrase, "You're all going to die," before committing suicide.

#TheHouseNextDoorMeetTheBlacks2
#TheHouseNextDoorMeetTheBlacks2
an open door leading to another room in a house with stairs and railings on either side
an open door leading to another room in a house with stairs and railings on either side
The House Next Door (2017)
The House Next Door (2017)

The house stood empty for a year, until the Lutzes' arrival. Could the DeFeo murders have somehow imbued the house with an evil presence? Or was something else at play?

The Lutzes' experiences

The Lutzes' encounters were bizarre and grotesque. They included disembodied voices, green slime oozing from walls, a revolting odor, and sightings of demonic apparitions. The family was plagued by sleep paralysis and night terrors, with Kathy experiencing a possession-like episode.

AD

George Lutz later admitted that some incidents might have been exaggerated or fabricated, yet he stood by the core experiences. He attributed the terror to whatever caused the 1974 murders, suggesting a curse or evil force possessed the house.

the house next door by tom colman
the house next door by tom colman
the house next door by anne rivers siddons
the house next door by anne rivers siddons
this house has people in it
this house has people in it
an open door in the corner of a room with hardwood floors and walls, showing it's dark side
an open door in the corner of a room with hardwood floors and walls, showing it's dark side
two people sitting in front of a house at night with the door open and lights on
two people sitting in front of a house at night with the door open and lights on
The House Next Door
The House Next Door

The Skeptics and the Controversy

Not everyone buys into the Lutzes' story. Investigators, such as author Rihannon combi and paranormal researcher Stephen Karlan, point to inconsistencies and lies in their narrative. Many incidents closely mirror episodes from popular horror novels and films of the era.

Some believe the Lutzes perpetrated a hoax to sell their story. If true, their actions would be distasteful, capitalizing on tragedy and exploiting popular fears. Yet, even skeptics acknowledge strange occurrences at the house. So, what's really going on at 112 Ocean Avenue?

AD

The house itself

The house itself might hold clues. Built in 1928, it shares similarities with the notorious "Hell House" in Montauk, suggesting possible architectural influences. Its layout includes a window that aligns with the cruciform shape of a church, which could be architecturally significant or sheer coincidence.

Homeowner In An HOA In Florida Notices The House Next Door Has Constructed Illegal Additions To Their Home, So They’re Thinking About Reporting Them To The HOA
Homeowner In An HOA In Florida Notices The House Next Door Has Constructed Illegal Additions To Their Home, So They’re Thinking About Reporting Them To The HOA

Other peculiar factors include the house's unusual level of insulation – the Lutzes claimed they couldn't hear neighborhood noise – and its triple set of windows, which some interpret as symbolic of the trinity, a religious theme echoed in the Lutzes' narrative.

The DeFeo saga continues

Ronald DeFeo's brother, John, later recounted that his family had experienced strange occurrences in the house, including lights flickering and cold spots. He described the atmosphere as "heavy," echoing the Lutzes' feeling of being watched and oppressed.

AD

In 2010, a documentary, "My Amityville Horror," offered a different perspective. It featured Daniel Lutz, George and Kathy's adult son, who discussed his lasting trauma and shared chilling firsthand accounts. The film suggests that the family's experience was authentically horrifying, even if some details may have been embellished.

Today, the 'Amityville Horror' house is no longer known by its address but by its eerie notoriety. It sits quiet andbolt locked, its former inhabitants long gone, leaving behind a story woven with threads of reality, myth, and mystery. Is it truly haunted, or is the real horror the persistent unknown?

AD