that or which grammar

That or Which Grammar: The Ultimate Guide to Using Them Correctly

By Laura Lewis
AD

If you have ever rewritten a sentence three times because you could not decide between that and which, you are not alone. The that or which grammar question trips up students, professionals, and even seasoned writers because both words can introduce relative clauses, and both can point back to a noun. The difference is not random, though. It follows a clear logic based on whether the information in the clause is essential or extra.

Understanding that logic makes editing faster and more confident. Instead of guessing, you can ask a simple question: does the clause identify exactly what I am talking about, or does it simply add a detail? That single question guides most decisions in American English and explains why commas often appear with which but rarely with that.

That vs. Which: The Core Grammar Rule

Both that and which are relative pronouns, which means they connect a clause to a noun and give more information about it. The clause that follows can be restrictive or nonrestrictive. A restrictive clause is essential to the meaning of the sentence. A nonrestrictive clause is additional information that could be removed without changing the core message.

AD
the differences between that and which words are in different languages, including english or german
the differences between that and which words are in different languages, including english or german
Which vs That | English Grammar Made Easy
Which vs That | English Grammar Made Easy
a woman sitting at a table with her hands out to the side and text that reads, that or which who or whom?
a woman sitting at a table with her hands out to the side and text that reads, that or which who or whom?

In standard American English, the cleanest rule is this: use that for restrictive clauses and which for nonrestrictive clauses. This is not just a preference in many style guides; it is a clarity tool. When readers see a comma before which, they know the information is extra. When they see that without a comma, they know the clause defines the noun.

Restrictive Clauses: When to Use That

A restrictive clause narrows down the noun it modifies. It tells the reader which specific person, place, thing, or idea you mean. Because the clause is essential, it should not be separated from the rest of the sentence by commas. This is where that shines in American English. For example, "The phone that has a cracked screen is mine" identifies a specific phone among several.

Which vs. That: When to Use the Right Word + Quiz
Which vs. That: When to Use the Right Word + Quiz
Discreet vs. Discrete: What’s The Difference?
Discreet vs. Discrete: What’s The Difference?
the words which are in green and white on a green background with an arrow pointing to it
the words which are in green and white on a green background with an arrow pointing to it

If you remove the restrictive clause, the sentence becomes vague or changes meaning. "The phone is mine" suggests there is only one phone in context, while the original sentence distinguishes one phone from others. You can sometimes omit that when it introduces a restrictive clause that functions as the object, as in "The phone I bought is mine," but the restrictive meaning remains.

Nonrestrictive Clauses: When to Use Which

A nonrestrictive clause adds a bonus detail. It does not define the noun; it comments on it. In American English, which typically introduces this kind of clause, and commas surround it. "The phone, which has a cracked screen, is mine" assumes the reader already knows which phone you mean. The cracked screen is extra information, not the detail that identifies the phone.

AD

Removing a nonrestrictive clause leaves the core sentence intact: "The phone is mine." The meaning does not shift to a different phone. That is the test. If the clause can be lifted out without changing which noun you are discussing, use commas and choose which. If the clause is doing the identifying work, use that and keep the commas away.

Difference Between That vs Who vs Which: A Complete Guide with 100 Examples
Difference Between That vs Who vs Which: A Complete Guide with 100 Examples
That vs. Which: What’s the Difference?
That vs. Which: What’s the Difference?
Who vs That in English - Which Word Should You Use?
Who vs That in English - Which Word Should You Use?
a poster showing the differences between white and black people
a poster showing the differences between white and black people
Who vs That #advancesentences #sentences
Who vs That #advancesentences #sentences
an open notebook with writing on it that says which tip is best for each individual
an open notebook with writing on it that says which tip is best for each individual

Putting That and Which Into Practice

Real writing rarely feels as tidy as a grammar rule. You may have a sentence that sounds fine with either word, or you may be following British English conventions where which can introduce restrictive clauses without commas. Still, the restrictive versus nonrestrictive distinction remains the foundation. It tells you whether the clause is defining the noun or merely describing it.

Punctuation offers a strong clue, but it is not the whole story. A comma before which usually signals a nonrestrictive clause. No comma before that usually signals a restrictive clause. The tricky part is that which can appear in restrictive clauses in some styles, especially British English or after prepositions. In those cases, the comma is still the deciding signal.

AD

The Comma Test for That or Which

Try reading the sentence without the clause. If the sentence still makes sense and points to the same noun, the clause is nonrestrictive. Set it off with commas and use which. "The report, which was published in March, changed the debate" still works as "The report changed the debate." The publication date is helpful, but it is not what identifies the report.

WORKSHEET English
WORKSHEET English
🌸 Usage of “This” and “That”
🌸 Usage of “This” and “That”
an info poster with the words who, which and how to use it in english
an info poster with the words who, which and how to use it in english
Difference Between That vs Who vs Which: Grammar Rules with 100 Examples
Difference Between That vs Who vs Which: Grammar Rules with 100 Examples

If removing the clause makes the sentence confusing or alters the noun, the clause is restrictive. Use that in American English and avoid commas. "The report that was published in March changed the debate" implies there are other reports, and the March report is the one that mattered. The clause identifies the report, so it is essential.

Exceptions, British English, and Tricky Prepositions

British English is more flexible with which. A British writer might write "The house which Jack built is old" without commas, using which restrictively. American style guides often prefer "The house that Jack built is old." Neither sentence is nonsense, but the version with that follows the dominant American convention. If you are writing for a specific publication, check its style guide.

AD

Prepositions create another exception. When a preposition comes before the relative pronoun, which is usually required: "The policy under which we operate is outdated." You would not write "the policy under that we operate." You can often rephrase to use that and move the preposition: "The policy that we operate under is outdated." Both are correct, but the rhythm and formality differ.

The next time you are editing, do not memorize a list of random rules. Ask whether the clause identifies the noun or simply adds a detail. If it identifies, reach for that and leave out the commas. If it adds a detail, set it apart with commas and use which. With a little practice, that or which grammar becomes less of a stumble and more of a natural editing instinct.

AD