Storm Door Reviews 2017: Top Picks, Ratings & Buying Guide
Storm door reviews 2017 might seem like old news, but they still tell a surprisingly useful story about which brands, materials, and mechanisms held up under real-world use. Homeowners writing those reviews were dealing with the same questions shoppers face now: Does the door rattle in the wind? Will the screen tear? Is the closer adjustable? Can I install it myself without ruining the door frame?
Back then, Larson, Andersen, EMCO, Pella, and a handful of regional manufacturers dominated the conversation. The best storm door reviews 2017 weren't just about star ratings; they were filled with details about installation headaches, winter drafts, pet scratches, and the annoying squeak of a cheap hinge. That feedback remains a solid starting point for anyone comparing storm doors today.
What Storm Door Reviews 2017 Revealed About Top Brands
When you dig through 2017 reviews, a few brand patterns emerge. Larson and Andersen generally earned praise for fit and finish, especially their aluminum frames and retractable screen systems. EMCO and Pella appeared frequently in big-box store reviews, where price and availability often mattered as much as long-term durability.
Reviewers also called out the little things: whether the closer was smooth, whether the handle felt solid, whether the screen rolled without binding, and whether the weatherstripping stayed put after a season. Those details separated a door that felt like a bargain from one that felt like a mistake.
Larson and Andersen Models That Earned Strong Feedback
Larson storm doors in 2017, particularly the Tradewinds, Signature, and Lakeview lines, were often described as sturdy and attractive. Reviewers liked the hidden closer options, self-storing screens, and the ability to choose glass or screen ventilation without wrestling with a full storm panel. Several noted that installation was manageable for a confident DIYer, though measuring the rough opening correctly was critical.
Andersen 3000 and 4000 Series doors also received solid marks in 2017 reviews. Owners praised the durable aluminum construction, color choices, and smooth operation. The most common complaints involved hinge adjustments and closers that needed tuning after installation. A few reviewers mentioned that custom sizes and specialty glass pushed the price higher than expected.
EMCO and Pella Storm Doors: Value and Reliability Notes
EMCO storm doors, especially the 100, 200, and 300 series, were popular in 2017 because they were easy to find at major retailers and relatively affordable. Reviewers appreciated the basic ventilation options and straightforward design. However, some complained about thinner frames, plastic components, and hardware that loosened over time.
Pella storm doors in 2017 drew praise for their architectural styles and low-E glass options. Homeowners who wanted a more polished look often chose Pella, and many reviews highlighted the secure locking system. On the downside, installation instructions sometimes felt vague, and custom sizing could add significant cost. A few reviewers said the door needed extra shimming to sit square.
Key Buying Factors Homeowners Discussed in 2017 Storm Door Reviews
The 2017 reviews weren't just brand loyalty contests. They were practical conversations about energy efficiency, security, maintenance, and curb appeal. Homeowners in cold climates cared about drafts and frost, while those in hot, humid areas focused on ventilation and rust resistance.
Another recurring theme was the trade-off between upfront cost and long-term performance. A cheap storm door might save money on day one, but 2017 reviewers frequently warned about warped frames, faded finishes, and replacement parts that were hard to find. Spending more often meant better hardware, smoother operation, and a longer warranty.
Energy Efficiency and Weather Sealing
Low-E glass, dual-pane options, and quality weatherstripping were major topics in 2017 storm door reviews. Homeowners reported that a well-sealed storm door reduced cold drafts around the entry door and helped protect the main door from sun and rain. In colder states, reviewers often mentioned that the storm door made their foyer feel noticeably warmer.
In hot climates, the conversation shifted to heat gain and ventilation. Reviewers liked doors with retractable screens and low-E glass because they could open the main door for airflow without letting in direct sun. Condensation between glass panes was a common complaint, usually traced to poor sealing or cheap spacers.
Security, Hardware, and Installation Challenges
Security was another big factor. Reviewers in 2017 looked at lock quality, deadbolt compatibility, and whether the door frame could withstand a firm push. Many praised reinforced strike plates and solid handles, while others warned that flimsy plastic latches and thin closers felt vulnerable. A storm door is not a primary security door, but it should still feel solid.
Installation challenges filled many 2017 reviews. Measuring the opening, checking for square, shimming hinges, and adjusting the closer were common struggles. Some DIYers completed the job in an afternoon, while others gave up and hired a handyman. Doors with pre-hung frames and clear templates generally received better installation feedback.
If you are shopping for a storm door now, treat the 2017 reviews as a field guide rather than a final verdict. Brands change models, hardware gets redesigned, and warranties vary by line. Use those older reviews to identify what matters most to you, then check current specifications and recent owner feedback before buying. A carefully chosen storm door can improve comfort, protect your entry door, and make your home look more polished for years to come.