SodaStream Reviews 2018: Best Fizz Makers, Pros, Cons & Buying Guide
When people search for soda stream reviews 2018, they are usually trying to understand a specific moment in home carbonation. That year, SodaStream was no longer just a novelty for sparkling water fanatics; it had become a mainstream kitchen counter appliance, helped by a wider model lineup, better retail availability, and PepsiCo’s high-profile acquisition of the company. Reviews from Amazon, Walmart, Best Buy, YouTube, and independent blogs painted a detailed picture of what worked, what felt cheap, and which machines delivered the best value for daily use.
This guide pulls together the most useful SodaStream reviews 2018 insights without pretending every model was perfect. You will see how the Fizzi, Source, Power, Crystal, and Penguin compared, how CO2 refills affected long-term costs, which flavors earned praise, and why some buyers returned their machines while others became loyal users. If you are researching an older SodaStream or comparing it with newer options, these 2018 review themes still provide a practical baseline.
Top SodaStream Models Reviewed in 2018
In 2018, SodaStream’s catalog covered a wide range of budgets and lifestyles. Manual machines like the Fizzi and Source appealed to shoppers who wanted simple operation and no power cord, while electric models like the Power targeted people who carbonated multiple drinks per day. Premium glass-carafe machines like the Crystal and Penguin were positioned as design pieces for entertaining, not just utility appliances.
Reviewers did not treat all machines equally. Many praised the Fizzi as the best entry point, questioned whether the Source still made sense as newer models arrived, and debated whether the Power was worth its higher price. The Crystal and Penguin earned compliments for aesthetics and taste, but their cost and delicate carafes made them niche picks. Across the board, the most common evaluation points were carbonation strength, bottle compatibility, counter footprint, build quality, and the hassle of CO2 exchanges.
SodaStream Fizzi and Source Reviews
The SodaStream Fizzi was one of the most reviewed models in 2018 because it hit a sweet spot between price and simplicity. It used a snap-lock bottle mechanism and a push-button carbonation system, with no electricity required. Reviewers liked that it was lightweight, available in several colors, and easy enough for almost anyone to use after one or two attempts. The included 60-liter CO2 cylinder and reusable bottle made the starter kit feel complete, though the all-plastic body did not impress buyers who wanted a premium feel.
The SodaStream Source, by contrast, was an older design that still appeared in many 2018 reviews and retail listings. It featured a sleek body, a snap-lock bottle, and LED indicators that showed carbonation levels. Some reviewers preferred its visual design to the Fizzi, but others noted that the Source was being phased out in favor of newer machines. Durability complaints were more common with the Source, especially around the carbonation button and bottle seal. For most beginners, the Fizzi was the safer recommendation because it was cheaper, current, and easier to find.
SodaStream Power, Crystal, and Penguin Reviews
The SodaStream Power was the electric option that received serious attention in 2018 reviews. It carbonated at the touch of a button and offered three fizz levels, which made it convenient for households with different preferences. Reviewers loved the one-touch operation and the sleek, compact shape, but they also pointed out that it required an outlet and cost significantly more than manual models. For heavy seltzer drinkers, the Power’s speed and consistency often justified the price. For occasional users, it was overkill.
The SodaStream Crystal and Penguin were the premium glass-carafe machines. Both used stainless steel bodies and glass bottles, which reviewers said made the drinking experience feel more upscale and reduced concerns about plastic taste. The Crystal was often described as elegant and easy to clean, while the Penguin had a more sculptural, high-end presence. The trade-offs were clear: glass carafes were heavy, fragile, and not ideal for travel, and the machines themselves were expensive. Reviews suggested these models for entertaining, design-conscious kitchens, and users who mainly carbonated water at home rather than on the go.
CO2 Costs, Flavors, and Long-Term Value
No SodaStream review in 2018 was complete without discussing the CO2 cylinder. The initial purchase includes a cylinder, but owners must exchange or refill it regularly. Most standard cylinders were rated for 60 liters, though actual yield depended on how aggressively the user carbonated each bottle. Reviewers frequently calculated cost per liter and compared it with store-bought sparkling water, soda cans, and bottles. The upfront cost of the machine was only part of the story; the ongoing expense of gas and flavor syrups determined whether SodaStream truly saved money.
Flavor syrups were another major factor in long-term value. SodaStream offered cola, diet cola, lemon-lime, root beer, orange, grape, cranberry, energy drink, and various fruit drops. Reviewers appreciated the ability to control sweetness and strength, but they also warned that syrups could add up quickly. Some flavors tasted close to national brands, while others had a noticeable artificial aftertaste. For people who mainly wanted plain sparkling water, the value equation was much stronger because they could skip syrups entirely and use lemon, lime, or natural extracts.
CO2 Cylinder Exchange and Cost per Liter
In 2018, a standard 60-liter CO2 cylinder refill typically cost between $15 and $20, depending on the retailer and whether the customer used an in-store exchange or a mail-in program. That worked out to roughly 25 to 35 cents per liter of plain sparkling water, before any flavoring. When syrup was added, the cost per liter rose, but it often remained lower than premium canned sodas or single-serve sparkling water. Reviewers who did the math usually concluded that SodaStream saved money for frequent users, while occasional users might not notice a dramatic difference.
The bigger problem was convenience. Not every town had a retailer that participated in cylinder exchanges, and some buyers found the process confusing during their first refill. Mail-in exchange programs worked but added shipping time and sometimes extra fees. Reviewers advised new owners to locate a nearby exchange point before buying the machine. They also recommended keeping a spare cylinder on hand, because running out of CO2 in the middle of a gathering was one of the most common frustrations mentioned in 2018 reviews.
Flavor Syrups and Taste in 2018
SodaStream’s flavor selection in 2018 was broad enough to satisfy most households. Classic cola and diet cola were popular, but reviewers often said they did not perfectly replicate Pepsi or Coca-Cola. Lemon-lime, root beer, and orange received more consistent praise, especially when mixed at slightly lower strength. Fruit drops and water enhancers were favored by people who wanted lightly flavored sparkling water without sugar or heavy sweetness. The system’s real advantage was customization: users could make a drink as sweet, weak, or strong as they liked.
Taste tests in 2018 reviews frequently highlighted the difference between unsweetened sparkling water and full-sugar soda. Plain carbonated water tasted clean and crisp, and it avoided the sodium and sugar found in many commercial sodas. Diet syrups used artificial sweeteners, which some reviewers found bitter or chemically. Regular syrups delivered more familiar soda flavor but could be sticky and high in sugar. The consensus was that SodaStream excelled for sparkling water lovers, while soda purists might still prefer cans or bottles for exact brand taste.
What Buyers Praised and Criticized in 2018 Reviews
Aggregated customer sentiment from 2018 showed a clear split. Satisfied buyers loved the convenience of making fizzy drinks at home, the fun of experimenting with flavors, and the environmental benefit of reusing bottles. They often described the machines as easy to set up and satisfying to use daily. Families liked letting older children make their own drinks with supervision, and office users appreciated having sparkling water available without hauling cases from the grocery store.
Critical reviews focused on reliability and maintenance. Common complaints included plastic bottles cracking after repeated use, carbonation fading faster than expected, CO2 leaks, sticky buttons, and difficulty finding refills. Some buyers received defective units and had mixed experiences with customer service. Others simply realized that SodaStream did not replace their favorite branded sodas closely enough. The most balanced reviews recommended the system for sparkling water and customizable drinks, not as a perfect clone of every store-bought soda.
Most Common Praises
The most frequent praise in 2018 SodaStream reviews centered on instant gratification. There was no need to chill cases of sparkling water or carry heavy bottles from the store. Manual models like the Fizzi worked without batteries or cords, so they could be used during power outages or taken to a vacation home. The reusable bottles reduced household waste, and the ability to flavor each glass differently made the machines feel personal rather than one-size-fits-all.
Reviewers also highlighted savings for heavy seltzer drinkers. A household that consumed several liters of sparkling water per week could often justify the machine within a few months, especially if they used plain water and occasional citrus instead of expensive syrups. The Fizzi was repeatedly called the best value, while the Power earned praise from users who wanted one-touch convenience. The Crystal and Penguin were recommended for buyers who valued glass carafes and were willing to pay more for design and materials.
Most Common Complaints and Reliability Notes
The most common complaints involved plastic parts and bottles. Reusable bottles could develop cracks or seals that weakened over time, especially if they were dropped or washed in hot water. Carbonation sometimes felt inconsistent from bottle to bottle, and a few users reported that CO2 cylinders leaked or ran out faster than the rated 60 liters. Buttons on manual models occasionally stuck, and electric models had rare electronic failures. These issues were not universal, but they appeared often enough in 2018 reviews to matter.
Reviewers advised new buyers to follow the manual carefully, use cold water for better carbonation, and avoid overfilling the bottle. Registering the warranty and keeping the receipt was also recommended because replacement parts and customer service requests were easier to handle with proof of purchase. Before buying a used 2018 model, reviewers suggested checking the bottle seals, testing the carbonation button, and confirming that CO2 exchange is still available in the area. A low upfront price meant little if refills were difficult to find.
If you are considering a SodaStream today, the 2018 reviews remain useful because they reveal the strengths and weaknesses that still matter: carbonation control, bottle quality, CO2 access, and realistic long-term costs. A used Fizzi or Power can still be a solid find if the parts are in good shape and refills are convenient, while the Crystal and Penguin appeal to buyers who want a more polished countertop experience. Match the machine to your daily fizz habits, check the availability of cylinders and flavors, and you will get far more satisfaction than by chasing the lowest price alone.