sherrie levine walker evans

Sherrie Levine Walker Evans: Exploring the Art of Appropriation

By Robert Miller
AD

Few works in postwar American art have generated as much argument per square inch as Sherrie Levine's After Walker Evans. In 1981, Levine photographed reproductions of Depression-era pictures made by Walker Evans, printed the results, and exhibited them under her own name. The images looked instantly familiar. The credit line did not. What followed was a debate about authorship, originality, and the ownership of pictures that has never really quieted down.

To understand the Sherrie Levine and Walker Evans connection is to understand two very different moments in American photography. Evans was the great documentary observer of the 1930s, a photographer who believed the camera could record the world with clarity and moral seriousness. Levine arrived half a century later, armed with skepticism rather than a documentary impulse, and used his pictures to ask whether any image can still be called original. The collision between those two positions is what makes the work so enduring.

The Origins of After Walker Evans

The series grew out of a specific moment in downtown New York, when a loose group of artists began treating mass media images as raw material rather than as something to compete with. Levine was part of that circle, and her early work moved quickly from collage and montage toward straight appropriation of existing photographs. By 1980 she had already rephotographed Edward Weston's famous nude of his son Neil, and the leap to Walker Evans was a logical next step.

AD
After… Walker Evans, Sherrie Levine, Michael Mandiberg: apropiacionismo en serie
After… Walker Evans, Sherrie Levine, Michael Mandiberg: apropiacionismo en serie
an old black and white photo of a man in overalls
an old black and white photo of a man in overalls
an old black and white photo of people standing in front of a house with two women
an old black and white photo of people standing in front of a house with two women

When the Walker Evans works were shown at Metro Pictures in 1981, they were not presented as copies in any apologetic sense. They were matted, framed, editioned, and priced like any other photographs in a commercial gallery. That framing was essential to the gesture. Levine was not sneaking anything past anyone; she was making the borrowing completely visible and then letting the art world decide what to do with it.

Sherrie Levine and the Pictures Generation

Levine was born in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, in 1947 and studied at the University of Wisconsin, where she earned both a bachelor's and a master's degree in fine art. She moved to New York in 1975, at a time when conceptual art, feminism, and media theory were colliding in studios and alternative spaces around the city. Her work was included in Douglas Crimp's influential 1977 exhibition Pictures at Artists Space, an early gathering of artists who would later be grouped under the Pictures Generation label.

two black and white photos of a woman's face in front of a wooden wall
two black and white photos of a woman's face in front of a wooden wall
two black and white photographs of a woman's face, one with wrinkles
two black and white photographs of a woman's face, one with wrinkles
black and white photograph of an old wooden building with a steeple on top, surrounded by pine trees
black and white photograph of an old wooden building with a steeple on top, surrounded by pine trees

That grouping included Robert Longo, Jack Goldstein, Troy Brauntuch, and Cindy Sherman, among others. What united them was less a shared style than a shared suspicion: they treated representation itself as the subject, asking how images construct meaning rather than simply recording it. Levine's contribution to that conversation was the most austere, because she removed almost every trace of her own hand from the finished object.

Walker Evans and the Documentary Photograph

Walker Evans was born in St. Louis in 1903 and died in New Haven in 1975, which means he never saw Levine's appropriation of his work. He came to photography after abandoning a career in writing, and he brought a literary sensibility to the medium. His book American Photographs, published in 1938 alongside an exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art, helped establish the idea that a sequence of photographs could function as a serious cultural argument.

AD

His best-known work was made in the mid-1930s, much of it while he was employed by the federal government's Resettlement Administration and later the Farm Security Administration. In the summer of 1936 he traveled through Alabama with the writer James Agee, and the resulting book, Let Us Now Praise Famous Men, published in 1941, became one of the most discussed collaborations in American letters. The tenant farmer portraits from that trip are the images most often associated with Levine's series.

an old church with two steeples on the roof
an old church with two steeples on the roof
an old black and white photo of children standing in front of a wooden building with their arms around each other
an old black and white photo of children standing in front of a wooden building with their arms around each other
an old photo of two women in front of a wooden wall and one woman with short hair
an old photo of two women in front of a wooden wall and one woman with short hair
an old black and white photo of a boy sitting on a chair in front of a cabinet
an old black and white photo of a boy sitting on a chair in front of a cabinet
an old photo of a table and chair in a room with wood floors, walls and doors
an old photo of a table and chair in a room with wood floors, walls and doors
Sherrie Levine - After Walker Evans: 12 - The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Sherrie Levine - After Walker Evans: 12 - The Metropolitan Museum of Art

What After Walker Evans Actually Does

The mechanics of the series are deceptively simple. Levine photographed existing reproductions of Evans's pictures, most of them drawn from widely circulated books and catalogues of his work, and printed the results as gelatin silver photographs. She did not crop, retouch, or dramatically alter the compositions. The intervention was conceptual rather than visual, which is precisely why so many viewers found it maddening.

Because the source images were reproductions rather than original negatives, the resulting prints carry their own subtle losses in contrast and detail. Some critics have read those losses as meaningful, a kind of visible distance between the viewer and the historical moment the original photograph recorded. Others see them as incidental. Either way, the work refuses to let you look at an Evans photograph the same way twice.

AD

Rephotography as a Conceptual Strategy

Rephotography has a long history, but it usually serves documentation or nostalgia: photographers returning to a site to record how it has changed. Levine inverted that tradition by rephotographing images rather than places. The subject of her pictures was not a sharecropper's cabin in Alabama but the act of looking at a photograph of a sharecropper's cabin, an act she then invited the viewer to repeat.

Walker Evans | MoMA
Walker Evans | MoMA
black and white photograph of a woman sitting in front of a cabinet
black and white photograph of a woman sitting in front of a cabinet
La perceuse: Photo
La perceuse: Photo
Walker Evans in the 1930s
Walker Evans in the 1930s

This layered structure is what separates her work from simple copying. A forgery tries to pass as the original. Levine's prints announce their secondhand status openly, and the exhibition context supplies the rest. She used the same approach with Eugène Atget, Alexander Rodchenko, and Edward Weston, building a body of work in which the choice of source is itself the artistic decision.

Authorship, Originality, and the Death of the Author

Levine's practice arrived alongside a body of theory that made it legible to a certain audience. Roland Barthes had argued in 1967 that the author is a modern invention and that meaning is produced by readers rather than by a single originating genius. Walter Benjamin had argued decades earlier that mechanical reproduction strips art of its aura. Levine turned those arguments into objects you could hang on a wall.

AD

In a much-quoted 1982 statement, she wrote that the world is "filled to suffocating" and that every word and image is "leased and mortgaged." That line became something of a manifesto for appropriation art. The radical claim underneath it is uncomfortable but hard to dismiss: if all images borrow from earlier images, then the distinction between an original and a copy may be a matter of institutional power rather than aesthetic truth.

Reception, Controversy, and Lasting Influence

Reaction to the series split sharply along generational and disciplinary lines. Many photographers saw it as an insult to a craft built on patient observation, and some viewed it as a cynical shortcut dressed up in theory. Curators, critics, and artists working in conceptual traditions mostly saw something else: a precise diagnosis of how images circulate in a culture saturated with them.

The hostility was not purely aesthetic. It touched on money, credit, and professional territory. If a photograph can be rephotographed and re-signed, then what exactly is a photographer selling? The question made people in the commercial photography world nervous in a way that abstract painting never did, because it threatened the practical foundations of the market.

Critical Response and Copyright Questions

Copyright was an obvious flashpoint, though the legal terrain turned out to be more complicated than the outrage suggested. Many of Evans's Farm Security Administration negatives are in the public domain in the United States because they were produced as part of federal government work, while other images he made carry different statuses depending on when and under what arrangement they were created. Levine's sources were published reproductions, which adds another layer to the analysis.

Critics including Douglas Crimp and Rosalind Krauss defended the work as a serious theoretical intervention rather than a legal stunt. Douglas Eklund's 2009 exhibition The Pictures Generation, 1974–1984 at the Metropolitan Museum of Art placed Levine's appropriation squarely within a broader art-historical narrative, cementing its status as a canonical rather than merely provocative gesture.

Where to See the Work Today

Prints from After Walker Evans are held in major public collections, including the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, which also owns other Levine works such as her 1991 bronze Fountain (After Marcel Duchamp). Her broader practice has been surveyed in solo exhibitions including Sherrie Levine: Mayhem at the Whitney Museum of American Art in 2011, which traced her engagement with photography, painting, and sculpture across four decades.

For anyone encountering the series for the first time, the most useful approach is to look at the prints before reading the wall label. Notice how ordinary they appear. Notice how quickly your attention shifts from the image to the question of who made it and why that question matters. That shift is the work. Everything else is commentary.

The Sherrie Levine and Walker Evans pairing still reads as one of the clearest demonstrations of a simple and slightly unsettling idea: images belong to everyone and to no one. A photograph of a tenant farmer's family made in 1936 can be remade in 1981, and again on a screen today, without losing its power to move people even as its authorship dissolves. The next time you scroll past a photograph that has been shared, saved, cropped, and reposted a hundred times over, consider that you are watching Levine's argument play out in real time, and that she made it with a camera, a reproduction, and a great deal of nerve.

AD