sargon of akkad suit

Sargon of Akkad Suit: Everything You Need to Know

By Joseph Walker
AD

The phrase "Sargon of Akkad suit" refers to a high-profile defamation lawsuit brought by British YouTuber and political commentator Carl Benjamin, known online as Sargon of Akkad, against The Guardian newspaper. The case, heard in the High Court of England and Wales, became a landmark moment in the ongoing debate over online speech, media accountability, and the limits of defamation law. It pitted a controversial internet personality against a major news organization, drawing attention from legal experts, journalists, and digital creators alike.

At its core, the Sargon of Akkad suit centered on an opinion article published by The Guardian in April 2019, written by columnist Owen Jones. Benjamin claimed the piece falsely portrayed him as a rape apologist and a racist, damaging his reputation. The Guardian defended the article as substantially true and honest opinion. What followed was a rigorous legal battle that would test the boundaries of free expression and the cost of taking on a media giant.

Background of the Sargon of Akkad Suit

To understand the lawsuit, it is essential to know who Carl Benjamin is and how he became a polarizing figure in British politics and online culture. Benjamin rose to prominence through his YouTube channel, where he adopted the historical name Sargon of Akkad. His videos often criticized feminism, social justice activism, and what he termed "regressive left" ideology. By the late 2010s, he had amassed a substantial following, turning his online fame into political ambition.

AD
Sargon of Akkad (Mesopotamia, XXIV century BC)
Sargon of Akkad (Mesopotamia, XXIV century BC)
Sargon (@Sargon_of_Akkad)
Sargon (@Sargon_of_Akkad)
Sargon of Akkad
Sargon of Akkad

In 2019, Benjamin stood as a candidate for the UK Independence Party (UKIP) in the European Parliament elections. His candidacy thrust him into the mainstream spotlight, where his past statements and controversial tweets were scrutinized. Among them was a 2016 tweet directed at Labour MP Jess Phillips, which read, "I wouldn't even rape you #IWontEvenRapeYou." This tweet became a central exhibit in the subsequent defamation case, as it formed the basis for much of the media criticism against him.

Who Is Carl Benjamin?

Carl Benjamin launched his YouTube career in the early 2010s, initially focusing on gaming and atheism before pivoting to political commentary. Under the pseudonym Sargon of Akkad, he built a brand around anti-political correctness, often engaging in heated debates with feminists, journalists, and left-wing activists. His confrontational style earned him both a devoted fanbase and a long list of detractors.

Sargon of Akkad
Sargon of Akkad
Sargon of Akkad
Sargon of Akkad
a man with a beard wearing a crown and standing in front of an ancient city
a man with a beard wearing a crown and standing in front of an ancient city

Beyond YouTube, Benjamin co-founded the online forum "The Skeptic Community" and later joined UKIP, hoping to translate his digital influence into electoral success. His political journey was marked by controversy, including accusations of racism and sexism, which he consistently denied. These accusations would later become the crux of the Sargon of Akkad suit, as he sought to clear his name through the courts.

The Controversial Tweet and the Guardian Article

The tweet that sparked the legal battle was posted in 2016 in response to Jess Phillips' comments about rape and sexual violence. Benjamin later insisted it was a joke, not a threat, but critics argued it trivialized a serious issue. The tweet resurfaced in 2019 during his UKIP campaign, prompting widespread condemnation and media coverage. It was this context that led The Guardian to publish an opinion piece by Owen Jones titled "The UKIP candidate who jokes about rape is a symptom of a sick political culture."

AD

In the article, Jones described Benjamin as a "rape apologist" and stated that he had a history of making racist and sexist comments. Benjamin took exception to these characterizations, arguing that they were false and defamatory. He filed a lawsuit against The Guardian News and Media Ltd, claiming that the article had caused serious harm to his reputation and that it went beyond fair comment. The stage was set for a courtroom showdown that would examine the boundaries between opinion, truth, and defamation.

young Sargon of Akkad inside the royal palace of King Ur-Zababa in the ancient Sumerian city of Kish
young Sargon of Akkad inside the royal palace of King Ur-Zababa in the ancient Sumerian city of Kish
Sargon of Akkad: The First Emperor of History
Sargon of Akkad: The First Emperor of History
Sargão da Acádia
Sargão da Acádia
Sergon I of Akkad
Sergon I of Akkad
Sargon the Great and the Akkadian Empire
Sargon the Great and the Akkadian Empire
a man dressed in black and gold clothing
a man dressed in black and gold clothing

Legal Battle and Aftermath

The Sargon of Akkad suit was filed in the High Court of Justice in London, with Benjamin seeking damages and a retraction. The case was heard by Mr Justice Saini, who presided over a trial that delved into Benjamin's online history, his tweets, and his public statements. The Guardian mounted a robust defense, arguing that the article was substantially true and constituted honest opinion based on facts. The trial attracted significant media attention, as it raised questions about how far public figures can go in silencing critics through litigation.

The legal proceedings were costly and complex, involving extensive disclosure of Benjamin's social media activity. The court examined not only the tweet to Jess Phillips but also other statements Benjamin had made about race, gender, and sexual violence. The outcome would determine whether The Guardian's characterization of him was legally permissible or defamatory. For Benjamin, the stakes were high, both financially and reputationally.

AD

The Court Case and Verdict

In November 2020, the High Court delivered its judgment. Mr Justice Saini ruled that while the article was defamatory in its natural and ordinary meaning, The Guardian's defences of truth and honest opinion succeeded. The judge found that Benjamin had indeed made racist and sexist comments, and that the description of him as a "rape apologist" was an honest opinion supported by the facts. The court dismissed Benjamin's claim in its entirety.

Couple Selfies, Ancient Persian, Cute Couple Selfies, Beautiful Art, History
Couple Selfies, Ancient Persian, Cute Couple Selfies, Beautiful Art, History
Sargon Akkad
Sargon Akkad
an illustration of a man dressed in gold and wearing a crown, standing with his hand out
an illustration of a man dressed in gold and wearing a crown, standing with his hand out

As a result, Benjamin was ordered to pay The Guardian's legal costs, which were reported to be a substantial six-figure sum. The verdict was a decisive victory for the newspaper and a major setback for Benjamin, who had hoped to vindicate his reputation. The judgment underscored that in UK defamation law, the truth is an absolute defence, and that public figures face a high bar when suing media outlets for opinion pieces.

Impact on Defamation Law and Online Speech

The Sargon of Akkad suit reinforced key principles of English defamation law, particularly the importance of the truth defence and the protection of honest opinion. It demonstrated that claimants cannot succeed simply by proving that a statement was offensive or damaging; they must also prove that it was false. The case also highlighted the financial risks of libel litigation, as Benjamin's failed suit left him with a hefty costs bill.

AD

For online creators and public figures, the case served as a cautionary tale about the legal consequences of controversial statements. It sparked broader debates about free speech, platform accountability, and the line between satire and defamation. While some argued that the lawsuit was an attempt to intimidate critics, others saw it as a necessary test of media standards. Regardless of one's perspective, the Sargon of Akkad suit remains a defining moment in the intersection of digital culture and legal accountability.

The Sargon of Akkad suit offers a vivid illustration of how online words can carry real-world legal weight. As courts continue to grapple with the fast-evolving digital landscape, the case will likely be cited in future disputes over defamation, opinion, and public figure status. For creators and journalists alike, it is a reminder that the boundaries of acceptable discourse are not just social but also legal, and that navigating them requires both awareness and caution.

AD