sarah charlesworth modern history

Sarah Charlesworth Modern History: Media, Memory, and the Power of Images

By Nicole Brown
AD

Sarah Charlesworth's Modern History is one of the quietest and most disruptive bodies of work to emerge from late-1970s American art. Between 1977 and 1979, Charlesworth gathered front pages of newspapers from around the world, rephotographed them, and then methodically removed nearly every word: headlines, subheads, bylines, captions, and columns of body text. What survived was the masthead, the date, and whatever photographs the editors had run that day. The result is a suite of roughly forty-five black-and-white prints that turns the daily news into something closer to a silent film still.

The series sits near the center of any serious conversation about the Pictures Generation, the loose constellation of artists who treated mass media as raw material rather than as background noise. Charlesworth's contribution was distinct, though. She was not merely appropriating an image; she was performing an act of subtraction. By stripping away the language that ordinarily explains a photograph, she exposed how much of a newspaper's authority depends on words most readers never consciously register.

Where the Modern History Series Came From

By the time she started the project, Charlesworth had already spent years inside the machinery of editorial decision-making. Born in East Orange, New Jersey, in 1947, she studied art history at Barnard College and later moved through the conceptual art circles of New York and Southern California. A stint as photo editor at Artforum gave her a firsthand view of how images are selected, cropped, sequenced, and captioned for publication. That vantage point matters: Modern History reads like the work of someone who understood exactly how much labor and ideology sit behind a single printed page.

AD
Sarah Charlesworth - Modern History - Exhibitions
Sarah Charlesworth - Modern History - Exhibitions
two paintings one with a bull and the other with a bird on it's head
two paintings one with a bull and the other with a bird on it's head
Sarah Charlesworth at Maccarone, New York
Sarah Charlesworth at Maccarone, New York

The production method was deliberately straightforward. Charlesworth rephotographed each front page with a large-format camera and printed the results at a consistent scale, so that papers as different as the International Herald Tribune and Le Monde could be compared side by side without one dominating the other. The uniformity of format is crucial. It converts a chaotic, daily ritual into a controlled typology, and it forces viewers to notice structure where they once saw only content.

Charlesworth and the Pictures Generation

Modern History arrived during a remarkable burst of appropriation-based work in New York. Sherrie Levine was rephotographing Walker Evans, Richard Prince was rephotographing advertisements, Cindy Sherman was constructing film stills that never belonged to any film, and Barbara Kruger was slicing text across found imagery. Charlesworth belonged to this milieu, and her work shares its central suspicion: that originality is a story the culture industry tells about itself.

Sarah Charlesworth. Movie-Television-News-History, June 21, 1979. 1979 | MoMA
Sarah Charlesworth. Movie-Television-News-History, June 21, 1979. 1979 | MoMA
At LACMA, Sarah Charlesworth Presents Doubleworld
At LACMA, Sarah Charlesworth Presents Doubleworld
a bunch of postcards with pictures and words on them, all in black and white
a bunch of postcards with pictures and words on them, all in black and white

What separated her was the edit. Many artists of the period emphasized the copy, the endless circulation of images, and the erosion of authorship. Charlesworth emphasized the gap. She left a hole where the news used to be, and that hole became the subject. The photographs in Modern History are not about what happened on a given day so much as about the apparatus that decides which days are worth remembering.

The Fox, Criticism, and Institutional Skepticism

In 1975, Charlesworth co-founded The Fox, a short-lived but influential journal produced with Joseph Bishop, Michael Corris, Preston Heller, Andrew Menard, Mel Ramsden, and Terry Smith. Across three issues published between 1975 and 1976, the group interrogated the art world as a system: its markets, its career structures, its claims to political neutrality. The writing was combative and self-questioning, and it reflected a broader anxiety among artists who felt that critique itself had become a marketable style.

AD

That editorial project shaped her visual practice in concrete ways. Modern History can be read as the same argument carried out in pictures rather than paragraphs. Instead of writing that the news is a constructed product, she simply removed the text and let the skeleton show. The series is a piece of criticism that never states its thesis, which is precisely why it continues to hold up.

X-TRA
X-TRA
Sarah Charlesworth
Sarah Charlesworth
two different colored images one with a man and the other with a woman's body
two different colored images one with a man and the other with a woman's body
Sarah Charlesworth at New Museum, New York
Sarah Charlesworth at New Museum, New York
a bull head mounted to the side of a wall next to a yellow piece of art
a bull head mounted to the side of a wall next to a yellow piece of art
Sarah Charlesworth: Doubleworld @New Museum | Collector Daily
Sarah Charlesworth: Doubleworld @New Museum | Collector Daily

Reading the Modern History Photographs

Encountering the series in a gallery is a strange experience. The first thing most viewers notice is the emptiness. A front page without headlines looks broken, almost censored, like a document that has been redacted by someone with a very precise blade. The masthead floats at the top with its familiar typography, the date sits in a corner, and images that were once illustrations for a story become orphaned pictures with no assigned meaning.

Seen individually, each print is a puzzle. Seen together, the series becomes a kind of calendar, a visual record of two years in which world events passed through the same narrow aperture again and again. The repetition is the point. Disaster, politics, sports, and celebrity all arrive in the same frame, at the same size, with the same missing text, flattening hierarchies of importance that editors work hard to construct.

AD

The Politics of Erasure

Removing words from a newspaper is not a neutral act, and Charlesworth knew it. Headlines do enormous interpretive work. They tell readers what to feel before they have looked carefully at anything. They assign blame, imply consequence, and compress messy situations into a handful of verbs. When that scaffolding disappears, the photographs underneath become genuinely ambiguous, and the viewer is forced to generate meaning rather than receive it.

Benjamin Sutton
Benjamin Sutton
the silhouettes of men and women are shown in black and white
the silhouettes of men and women are shown in black and white
Sarah Charlesworth, Objects of Desire: 1983-1988 @Maccarone | Collector Daily
Sarah Charlesworth, Objects of Desire: 1983-1988 @Maccarone | Collector Daily

This is where the series becomes political without becoming didactic. A picture of a crowd, a burning building, or a politician waving might appear on any number of front pages for entirely different reasons. Without captions, those reasons vanish. What remains is the raw visual rhetoric of the press, and viewers are left to notice how much of their understanding of the world was borrowed from someone else's sentence.

Modern History as a Typology of the Press

The series also functions as a comparative study of design and national identity. Mastheads are among the most recognizable graphic marks in the world, and Charlesworth's consistent cropping turns them into specimens. The gothic lettering of one paper, the severe modernism of another, the density of a tabloid layout, the restrained grid of a broadsheet: all of it becomes legible as branding once the headlines stop competing for attention.

AD

The typological impulse links her to photographers such as Bernd and Hilla Becher, who catalogued industrial structures with the same cool consistency. But where the Bechers documented architecture, Charlesworth documented an information system. The comparison reveals how much the daily press resembles an assembly line, producing variation within an extremely rigid template, day after day, across every country on earth.

Legacy and Continuing Influence

Charlesworth continued to interrogate images for the rest of her life. She taught for years at the School of Visual Arts and held visiting positions elsewhere, and her work entered the collections of institutions including the Museum of Modern Art, the Whitney Museum of American Art, and the Art Institute of Chicago. In 2015, the New Museum in New York mounted Doubleworld, a major retrospective that reintroduced her practice to a generation of artists working with screenshots, feeds, and algorithmic imagery. She died in 2013.

Her influence is easy to trace in contemporary art, where the manipulation of found media is now standard practice. It is equally visible outside the art world, in the way designers, journalists, and critics talk about news imagery as a constructed object. Modern History anticipated a moment when the front page would be replaced by an infinite scroll, and the problem of deciding what an image means without context would become a daily condition rather than a gallery experience.

From Modern History to Stills and Objects of Desire

In 1980, Charlesworth followed Modern History with Stills, a series drawn from newspaper photographs of people falling or jumping from buildings. Here she enlarged and reprinted the original images, presenting figures suspended in midair in a grid that is both elegant and unbearable. The series extends the earlier project's logic: take an image that was published with an explanation, remove the explanation, and watch the meaning migrate.

Later work such as Objects of Desire pushed further into the mechanics of representation, cutting elements out of found images and replacing them with flat fields of color and gold leaf. Across four decades, her central question stayed consistent. How does an image acquire authority, and what happens when you take that authority apart piece by piece?

Why Sarah Charlesworth's Modern History Still Matters

Anyone scrolling through a social feed today is doing a version of what Charlesworth did in 1977. Images arrive detached from their sources, stripped of captions, reshared into contexts their makers never intended. The difference is that she performed this dismantling deliberately, in a studio, with a camera and a scalpel, and she did it slowly enough to see what was being lost.

That slowness is the series' lasting gift. It asks viewers to spend time with an image before assigning it a story, to notice the frame, the format, and the missing text. In an era when visual information moves faster than any of us can process, a body of work built around subtraction and attention feels less like a historical artifact and more like a set of instructions.

Spend an afternoon with Charlesworth's newspaper pages and the next headline you read will feel a little less inevitable. That shift in perception, small as it sounds, is exactly what she was after, and it is available to anyone willing to look at the world with the sound turned down.

AD