Roomba Reviews 2018: Top Picks, Pros & Cons, and Ultimate Buying Guide
The year 2018 turned out to be a turning point for robot vacuums, and Roomba reviews from that period read like a snapshot of a market maturing in real time. iRobot had spent years convincing skeptical shoppers that a disc-shaped machine could handle daily floor care, and by 2018 the conversation had shifted from "does it work?" to "which model is worth the money?" Reviewers were no longer grading on a curve, and the sheer number of Roomba variants on shelves meant buyers had to sort through a genuinely confusing ladder of features, prices, and capabilities.
What makes 2018-era Roomba coverage so useful, even years later, is how clearly it documents the split between random-navigation bargain bots and genuinely intelligent mapping machines. The launch of the Roomba i7 and i7+ with a self-emptying Clean Base dominated headlines, while older workhorses like the 690 and 890 kept selling on price alone. Reading those reviews side by side reveals exactly where the value lines were drawn.
The 2018 Roomba Lineup at a Glance
iRobot's 2018 catalog was crowded, spanning roughly five distinct tiers from budget to flagship. At the bottom sat the Roomba 690 and its retail-exclusive cousin, the 675. In the middle lived the 890 and 960, then the 980 near the top, with the newly released i7 and i7+ occupying the premium slot. Each step up the ladder added something concrete: better suction, smarter navigation, or a more sophisticated app experience.
Reviewers consistently noted that the gaps between tiers were not evenly spaced. The jump from a 690 to an 890 delivered a meaningful upgrade in brush design and cleaning power, while the leap from a 960 to a 980 was subtler and largely about navigation confidence and runtime. Understanding those distinctions was the single most important thing a shopper could do before clicking buy in 2018.
Entry-Level Models: Roomba 690 and 675
The 690 earned a reputation in 2018 as the model reviewers recommended to first-time buyers who wanted Wi-Fi control without paying flagship prices. It cleaned well on hard floors and low-pile carpet, worked with Alexa and the iRobot Home app, and routinely dropped to around $300 during sales events. Its weaknesses were equally well documented: random bounce navigation, no mapping, no room-specific cleaning, and a runtime of roughly an hour.
The 675 occupied an odd spot because it stripped out Wi-Fi entirely to hit a lower price at warehouse retailers. Reviews framed it as a perfectly capable vacuum for someone who simply wanted a button-press cleaning cycle and had no interest in app scheduling. For a small apartment with mostly hard flooring, both models were frequently described as more than adequate, provided the owner accepted a certain amount of wandering and repeated coverage.
Mid-Range Workhorses: Roomba 890 and 960
The 890 was widely treated as the sweet spot of the 2018 lineup. It inherited the tangle-resistant rubber extractors and stronger motor introduced on the 980, added Wi-Fi and app support, and typically sold for $450 to $500. Reviewers repeatedly praised its ability to keep up in homes with pets, since the dual rubber rollers were far less prone to hair wrap than traditional bristle brushes.
The 960 took a different path, trading raw suction bragging rights for camera-based navigation that let it map a room and clean in deliberate, overlapping passes. That made it faster and more systematic than the random-navigation models, though it still lacked the magnetic boundary and persistent map features that arrived with the i7. Multiple 2018 reviews concluded that if a household had a complicated layout with lots of obstacles, the 960's smarter pathing justified the premium over the 890.
What Reviewers Praised and Criticized
Across the major outlets, the praise for 2018 Roombas clustered around a few consistent themes: reliable daily debris pickup, genuinely useful app scheduling, and a build quality that felt durable. The criticisms were equally consistent and rarely varied by publication, which gave shoppers a fairly trustworthy consensus to work from rather than a pile of contradictory takes.
It is worth noting that most reviewers tested in real homes rather than on tidy showroom floors. That meant a lot of attention went to edge cases like pet hair, charging cable tangles, transitions between carpet and tile, and how often the dustbin needed emptying. Those practical observations were far more useful than spec sheets listing suction numbers.
Cleaning Performance and Pet Hair
The 800 and 900 series models with rubber extractors earned particular praise for handling pet hair without constant maintenance. Traditional bristle brushes on the cheaper 600 series required regular untangling, and reviewers were blunt about that chore becoming tiresome in multi-pet households. On bare floors, nearly every 2018 Roomba performed impressively, picking up cereal, sand, and fine dust in a single pass.
Deep carpet cleaning was where the hierarchy became obvious. The 980 and i7 pulled noticeably more embedded debris out of mid-pile carpet than the 690, and reviewers could demonstrate the difference by weighing collected dust. That said, most experts agreed that no 2018 robot completely replaced a full-size upright vacuum for thick carpet, and honest coverage said so plainly.
Smart Features, Mapping, and Connectivity
App quality became a genuine differentiator in 2018. The iRobot Home app let owners schedule cleanings, view a cleaning history, and, on mapping-capable models, see a floor plan of the home. Reviewers liked the ability to name rooms and send the robot to a specific one, though several noted that the feature worked best after a few mapping runs and could be finicky in homes with mirrored walls or glass doors.
Setup complaints showed up in a surprising number of reviews. Wi-Fi pairing occasionally failed on the first attempt, and a 2.4 GHz network was usually required, which frustrated anyone running a modern dual-band router. Once connected, however, most reviewers found the experience stable and appreciated voice control through Alexa and Google Assistant, which felt genuinely futuristic at the time.
How Roomba Stacked Up Against 2018 Competition
iRobot did not have the robot vacuum market to itself in 2018. Neato offered laser-based navigation on mid-priced models, Eufy undercut everyone on price, and Roborock delivered mapping and mopping at a fraction of flagship Roomba pricing. Reviewers were quick to point out that brand loyalty made less sense than matching specific features to a specific home.
The competitive pressure had a visible effect on iRobot's pricing, since several 2018 Roomba models saw frequent discounts that would have seemed unthinkable two years earlier. That environment made comparison shopping essential, and the best reviews of the era explicitly told readers when a cheaper rival was the smarter purchase.
Neato, Eufy, and Shark
Neato's Botvac line was the most direct rival for buyers who cared about navigation. Its laser mapping worked in the dark and handled no-go lines more elegantly than the camera-based 960, which needed light to navigate. Reviewers often recommended Neato for owners of open-plan homes and Roomba for those who valued app polish and a broad accessory ecosystem.
Eufy's RoboVac 11S became a budget darling, frequently selling for under $250 with no app and no mapping but solid suction and a slim profile that slipped under furniture. Shark's entry into the category brought aggressive pricing and a self-cleaning brush roll, though early software reviews were mixed. The takeaway from most comparisons was simple: cheap models cleaned fine, but smart navigation cost real money in 2018.
Value and Long-Term Ownership Costs
Purchase price was only part of the equation. Filters needed replacing every couple of months, side brushes wore down on carpet edges, and extractors eventually required swapping. Batteries typically lasted one to two years before runtime dropped noticeably, and replacements were not cheap. Reviewers who tracked these costs over a year found the total meaningful, though still lower than the price of a mid-range upright vacuum.
The i7+ complicated the math in an interesting way. Its Clean Base held roughly thirty bins worth of debris, meaning owners could go weeks without touching the robot. That convenience carried a premium price and required proprietary disposable bags, which added ongoing cost. Whether it was worth it depended entirely on how much someone valued never thinking about vacuuming, and reviewers on both sides made their cases convincingly.
If you are reading 2018 Roomba reviews today, the most valuable thing you can take from them is a framework rather than a specific verdict. Ask what your floors are actually made of, whether pet hair is a daily battle, and how much you care about the robot finding its own way rather than bouncing off walls. Answer those three questions honestly and the right model from that era, or its modern successor, becomes fairly obvious.