Reliance 606 Water Heater Element: Ultimate Replacement Guide & Buying Tips
If your Reliance 606 electric water heater has lost its ability to keep up with morning showers, the Reliance 606 water heater element is often the first component to inspect. These immersion-style elements sit directly inside the tank and convert electrical current into heat, so when one fails, you may notice lukewarm water, a tripped breaker, or a sudden drop in hot-water capacity. Replacing the element is one of the most common repairs for this water heater family, and with the right part and a careful approach, it is a job many homeowners can handle.
This guide explains how to identify the correct Reliance 606 element, how the upper and lower elements work together, and how to test and replace a failed element without damaging the tank. You will also learn which specifications matter most—voltage, wattage, thread type, and gasket style—so you can order the right replacement the first time.
Understanding the Reliance 606 Water Heater Element
The Reliance 606 is an electric water heater platform that uses two heating elements: an upper element and a lower element. Each element is a metal-sheathed immersion heater that screws into the tank through a threaded port. When the thermostat calls for heat, it sends power to the element, which warms the water around it. The upper element typically heats the top portion of the tank first, while the lower element handles the bulk of the recovery once the top is satisfied.
Because Reliance 606 units were produced in several configurations, there is no single element that fits every model. The most common replacement is a 4500-watt, 240-volt screw-in element with a 1-inch NPT thread and a flat gasket, but some versions use 3500-watt or 5500-watt elements. The rating plate on the side of the tank lists the original voltage and wattage, and that information should always be your final reference before buying parts.
How the Element Works Inside the Tank
Inside each element is a resistive wire surrounded by an insulating powder and a metal sheath. When 240 volts pass through the wire, resistance creates heat, which transfers through the sheath into the water. The thermostat acts as the switch, opening and closing the circuit to maintain the set temperature. If the element develops a break in the wire, it becomes an open circuit and stops heating entirely; if moisture reaches the internal wire, it can short to the tank and trip the breaker.
The upper and lower elements do not usually run at the same time. The upper thermostat gives priority to the upper element so you get hot water quickly at the tap. Once the upper section reaches temperature, power is sent to the lower thermostat and lower element to heat the rest of the tank. This is why a failed upper element often causes a fast loss of hot water, while a failed lower element may only reduce the total amount of hot water available.
Common Element Specifications for Reliance 606 Models
Most Reliance 606 water heater elements are screw-in style, not bolt-in. They have a hexagonal flange that accepts an element wrench and a threaded base that seals against the tank with a gasket. The 4500-watt, 240-volt version is the most widely used because it provides a good balance of recovery speed and electrical demand for a standard 30-amp double-pole breaker circuit. Lower-wattage elements are sometimes used in smaller tanks or in areas where the electrical service is limited.
Watt density also matters. A standard density element has a larger surface area and is more resistant to scale buildup, while a low-density or sandhog element is designed for hard water. If your Reliance 606 has a history of sediment problems, a low-density replacement can last longer. Always match the voltage and wattage to the original rating plate, and never install a higher-wattage element unless the wire gauge, breaker, and thermostat are rated for it.
Diagnosing and Replacing a Faulty Reliance 606 Element
Before you buy a new Reliance 606 water heater element, confirm that the element is actually the problem. Common symptoms include no hot water, hot water that runs out too quickly, a breaker that trips when the tank calls for heat, rust-colored water, and a faint hissing or popping sound from the tank. In some cases, the issue is a failed thermostat, a tripped high-limit switch, or a loose wire rather than the element itself. Testing with a multimeter takes only a few minutes and can save you the cost of unnecessary parts.
Safety is critical because electric water heaters use 240 volts, which can be lethal. Turn off power at the breaker, verify with a non-contact voltage tester, and shut off the cold-water supply before opening any access panel. If you are not comfortable working around electricity and water, hire a licensed plumber or electrician. The cost of a professional replacement is usually modest compared with the risk of shock, flooding, or a dry-fired element.
Step-by-Step Testing the Element
Start by removing the upper and lower access panels and the insulation pads. Test the thermostats first, because a thermostat that fails to close will prevent the element from receiving power. To test the element, disconnect the two wires from its terminals and set your multimeter to the ohms setting. A good 4500-watt, 240-volt element will typically read between 10 and 16 ohms. A reading of infinite resistance means the element is open and must be replaced, while a reading near zero means it is shorted.
Next, check for a ground fault. Place one probe on an element terminal and the other on the bare metal of the tank. The meter should show no continuity. If it shows continuity or a low resistance, the element is grounded and should be replaced immediately. While you have the meter out, inspect the element for heavy scale, cracks, or blisters. Severe scale can insulate the element and cause it to overheat, even if the resistance reading still looks normal.
Replacing the Element Safely
To replace the element, turn off the power and water, then drain the tank completely. Use a hose connected to the drain valve and open a hot-water faucet to speed the flow. Remove the access panel and insulation, disconnect the wires, and use an element wrench to unscrew the old element. Clean the threads in the tank port and remove any old gasket material. Install the new gasket and thread the replacement element in by hand, then tighten it snugly with the element wrench. Do not overtighten, as you can crack the tank fitting or deform the gasket.
Before restoring power, close the drain valve and refill the tank completely. Open a hot-water faucet and let it run until all air is purged and water flows steadily. Check the element area for leaks, then restore power and set the thermostat to a safe temperature, usually around 120°F. Never energize a new element in an empty or partially filled tank; dry firing can destroy it in seconds. After the tank heats up, verify that the breaker stays on and that you have consistent hot water at every fixture.
Replacing a Reliance 606 water heater element is a manageable repair when you take the time to identify the correct part and follow safe electrical and plumbing practices. Keep a photo of your rating plate and the old element on your phone so future replacements are quick and accurate. With a fresh element and a clean tank, your Reliance 606 can deliver reliable hot water for years to come.