pit boss memphis ultimate grill reviews

Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate Grill Reviews: Honest Pros, Cons & Verdict

By Ashley Lopez
AD

Few backyard cookers generate as much curiosity as the Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4-in-1. It promises something that sounds almost too good on paper: a gas grill, a charcoal grill, a pellet smoker, and a side burner all built into one cart. That combination is exactly why searches for Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate reviews stay steady year after year, and it is also why the feedback you find online is so split. Some owners call it the most versatile grill they have ever owned. Others warn that any combo unit forces compromises, and they want to know precisely where those compromises show up before they spend their money.

This breakdown pulls together the themes that show up again and again in verified buyer reviews, owner forum threads, and long-term use reports. You will see how the unit actually cooks, what assembly and maintenance really demand, where the design shines, and where it frustrates people. If you are weighing the Memphis Ultimate against a dedicated pellet grill or a standalone gas rig, the details below should make that decision considerably easier.

What the Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4-in-1 Actually Delivers

The Memphis Ultimate is built around a single rolling cart that houses four distinct cooking zones. The pellet side uses a hopper, auger, and digital controller to feed hardwood pellets into a burn pot, giving you the low-and-slow smoking capability Pit Boss is known for. The gas side runs on propane with a multi-burner configuration, the charcoal section uses a grate and adjustable tray over briquettes or lump, and a side burner rounds out the package for pots, sauces, and side dishes. Pit Boss advertises roughly 2,200 square inches of total cooking area across those zones, which is a serious amount of real estate for a residential backyard.

AD
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4 in 1 Smoker Grill Combo Review
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4 in 1 Smoker Grill Combo Review
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4 in 1 Grill Review
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4 in 1 Grill Review
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate

The catch with any multi-fuel design is that each section has to justify its place on the cart. A gas grill that heats unevenly or a smoker that struggles to hold temperature turns a clever concept into an expensive piece of patio furniture. Reviews tend to focus on exactly that question, and the honest answer is that the Memphis Ultimate is stronger in some modes than others. Understanding which zones perform best, and which ones require a bit of patience, is the key to deciding whether this grill matches how you actually cook.

Build Quality and Footprint

Owners consistently describe the Memphis Ultimate as sturdy once assembled. The cart uses a powder-coated steel frame with porcelain-coated components, and the cooking grates are cast iron on the gas and charcoal sides while the pellet chamber typically uses a coated steel grate. The unit sits on four casters, two of which lock, and the sheer mass of the thing works in its favor on windy days. This is not a flimsy cart that shifts when you open the lid. It feels substantial, and most reviewers note that it looks more expensive than its price tag suggests.

Collections
Collections
The Ultimate BBQ Machine? Pit Boss 4-in-1 Smoker Grill Reviewed!
The Ultimate BBQ Machine? Pit Boss 4-in-1 Smoker Grill Reviewed!
13 BEST Gas Charcoal Combo Grills in 2024 [Guide & Reviews]
13 BEST Gas Charcoal Combo Grills in 2024 [Guide & Reviews]

That substance comes with a cost in practicality. The grill is heavy, and shipping weight lands well north of 200 pounds, so getting it from the driveway to the patio is a two-person job. Assembly is the most common complaint in early reviews, with owners reporting anywhere from two to four hours of work involving a lot of bolts, brackets, and careful attention to the instructions. Measure your space before ordering, too. Between the open lid height and the side shelf clearance, the Memphis Ultimate needs a generous corner of the yard rather than a narrow balcony.

The Pellet Smoker Side

The pellet zone is where the Memphis Ultimate earns most of its positive press. The digital control board lets you dial in a target temperature, and the auger feeds pellets automatically to maintain it. Owners report that after an initial warm-up and a short settling period, the controller holds steady temps well enough for pork butt, brisket, ribs, and whole chickens. Smoke flavor is milder than what you get from an offset stick burner, which is normal for pellet cooking, but it is unmistakably present and pairs well with poultry and pork.

AD

Where the pellet side falls short is aggressive high-heat searing. Pellet grills in general top out lower than charcoal or gas, and reviewers note that getting a hard crust on a steak means moving it to another zone. Long cooks also consume a meaningful amount of pellets, so budget for a couple of bags per brisket and store them somewhere dry. Owners who treat this section as a dedicated smoker rather than an all-purpose cooker tend to be far happier with the results.

Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4 in 1 Smoking Grill Review
Pit Boss Memphis Ultimate 4 in 1 Smoking Grill Review
6 Pit Boss Pellet Grills: Find the Best Model
6 Pit Boss Pellet Grills: Find the Best Model
Pit Boss 820D3 Review - Hey Grill, Hey
Pit Boss 820D3 Review - Hey Grill, Hey
a black bbq grill with the lid open
a black bbq grill with the lid open
Going All In: Pit Boss Austin XL Review
Going All In: Pit Boss Austin XL Review
PIT BOSS GRILLS
PIT BOSS GRILLS

Real-World Cooking Performance and Owner Feedback

Across hundreds of reviews, a few themes repeat. People love the flexibility of switching between fuels without owning three separate machines, and they appreciate being able to smoke a pork shoulder on Saturday and grill burgers on Tuesday without changing equipment. The complaints cluster around temperature consistency on the gas side, the amount of cleaning required to keep four zones in good shape, and the learning curve that comes with juggling different cooking styles on one cart.

Another recurring point is that the Memphis Ultimate rewards attentive cooks. It is not a set-and-forget appliance in every mode. The pellet controller does the heavy lifting, but the charcoal tray, gas burners, and side burner all respond to hands-on management. Owners who enjoy the process of cooking, rather than people who want to press a button and walk away, report the highest satisfaction with this grill.

AD

Gas and Charcoal Modes Compared

The gas section is the workhorse for quick meals. Multiple stainless burners deliver enough output for burgers, brats, vegetables, and chicken breasts, and the ignition system lights reliably when the grill is clean and the propane tank is full. Reviewers frequently note that the gas side reaches cooking temperature quickly, which makes it the default choice on weeknights when nobody wants to wait 30 minutes for coals or pellets.

Mastering the Flame: A Comprehensive Review of the Pit Boss 820 Competition Series Pellet Grill
Mastering the Flame: A Comprehensive Review of the Pit Boss 820 Competition Series Pellet Grill
At $697, the New Pit Boss Platinum 1250 Pellet Grill Delivers on Value - CookOut News | Grill Business News, Grill Reviews, Grill Releases
At $697, the New Pit Boss Platinum 1250 Pellet Grill Delivers on Value - CookOut News | Grill Business News, Grill Reviews, Grill Releases
Pit Boss Ultimate Griddle Review | How To Season Your Pit Boss Grills Ultimate Griddle
Pit Boss Ultimate Griddle Review | How To Season Your Pit Boss Grills Ultimate Griddle
Z Grills vs Pit Boss: The Ultimate Pellet Grill Showdown
Z Grills vs Pit Boss: The Ultimate Pellet Grill Showdown

The charcoal zone is where flavor purists gravitate. An adjustable charcoal tray lets you raise and lower the coals for different heat levels, and the cast iron grates produce excellent sear marks. The tradeoff is time and cleanup. You need to light coals, manage airflow, and deal with ash afterward. Owners who use both modes describe a natural division of labor: gas for speed, charcoal for steaks and anything that benefits from live-fire char.

Temperature Control, Hot Spots, and Cleaning

Temperature behavior varies by zone. The pellet smoker holds temps reasonably well once it stabilizes, though it can overshoot during warm-up or when you open the lid repeatedly. The gas side shows the hot spots common to most propane grills, with the center and rear typically running hotter than the edges. Charcoal is entirely on you, and the side burner behaves like a normal high-output outdoor burner with a concentrated flame.

AD

Cleaning is the least glamorous part of owning a four-in-one. You are maintaining grease trays, ash cleanup, pellet dust, and multiple sets of grates. Reviewers who stay ahead of it with a brush after every cook and a deeper clean every few sessions report far fewer problems than those who let residue build up. A fitted cover is essentially mandatory, since moisture is the main enemy of a grill this size and this expensive.

Is the Memphis Ultimate Worth Buying? Value, Drawbacks, and Who It Fits

Pricing on the Memphis Ultimate typically lands in the mid-range for a large combo grill, and it often goes on sale during seasonal promotions. Compare that to buying a decent pellet smoker, a solid gas grill, and a charcoal kettle separately, and the value proposition becomes genuinely compelling, especially if you have limited patio space. One cart, one cover, one footprint, and three fuel types is a lot of capability for the money.

The drawbacks are real, though. It is bulky, heavy, and demanding to maintain. The pellet side is not a high-heat searing machine, the gas side is competent rather than exceptional, and the whole unit requires more attention than a single-purpose grill. Buyers who expect a single appliance to perform like three dedicated professional cookers will be disappointed. Buyers who want range and convenience from one footprint usually are not.

Who Should Consider This Grill

This grill makes the most sense for backyard cooks who genuinely use more than one cooking method. If you smoke ribs on weekends, grill chicken on weeknights, and occasionally want a charcoal-seared steak, the Memphis Ultimate removes the need for three separate purchases. It also suits people with a fixed patio layout who want to avoid clutter and multiple propane tanks or bags of charcoal scattered around.

It is a strong fit for households that entertain, since the combined cooking area lets you run sides on the side burner while meat cooks elsewhere. Pit Boss also backs its grills with a multi-year limited warranty, though terms vary by model and region, so confirm the current coverage at the point of purchase. Registering the grill after assembly is a small step that saves headaches later.

Tips for Getting the Most From It

Start with a proper burn-in. Run each zone empty for a while to burn off manufacturing residue, then season the cast iron grates with a thin coat of high-heat oil. Buy a reliable instant-read thermometer and, ideally, a wireless probe for the smoker side. Learning where your particular unit runs hot takes two or three cooks, and that knowledge is what separates frustrating results from excellent ones.

Store pellets in sealed containers, keep a spare propane tank, and invest in a quality cover that fits the full cart rather than a generic tarp. Clean the burn pot and grease trays on a schedule instead of waiting for a problem. Pit Boss customer support gets mixed but generally reasonable marks in owner threads, and having your model number and receipt handy speeds up any parts request significantly.

If you have read this far, you probably already know which camp you fall into. The Memphis Ultimate rewards cooks who enjoy variety and do not mind a little maintenance in exchange for four ways to make dinner. Take a hard look at your patio space and how often you actually smoke versus grill, then let that answer decide it. A grill this capable tends to become the centerpiece of a backyard once it finds the right home, and the right home is usually one where somebody genuinely enjoys standing over the fire.

AD