May 2019 Paper Pumpkin Alternatives: Fresh DIY Craft Kits to Try This Month
If you missed the May 2019 Paper Pumpkin kit—or you used every last piece and want a fresh supply—you are not alone. The Hugs from Shelli kit became a favorite for its warm sentiments, coordinated card designs, and all-in-one convenience. Since Stampin' Up! retires Paper Pumpkin kits, finding the exact May 2019 version can feel like hunting for a limited-edition treasure. The good news is that several alternatives can deliver the same satisfying mix of pre-cut paper, exclusive stamps, and guided creativity.
This guide walks through practical Paper Pumpkin May 2019 alternatives, from monthly card-making subscriptions to one-time kits, retired-kit marketplaces, and build-your-own options. You will learn what made the original kit appealing, how to compare replacements, and how to recreate the experience without chasing sold-out inventory. Whether you want a near-identical card kit or a more flexible craft box, there is an option for your budget and style.
Why Crafters Look for Paper Pumpkin May 2019 Alternatives
Paper Pumpkin is a monthly subscription from Stampin' Up! that delivers an all-inclusive papercrafting project. Each box typically includes an exclusive stamp set, a mini ink pad, pre-cut paper pieces, embellishments, adhesives, and instructions. The May 2019 kit stood out because it combined heartfelt messaging with a polished, coordinated look. Once a kit retires, however, Stampin' Up! does not restock it indefinitely.
Crafters search for alternatives for several reasons: they were not subscribers at the time, they want to make more of the same cards, they prefer a different price point, or they want more creative control. Some also want a kit that ships internationally or includes different project types, such as scrapbooking, journaling, or gift packaging. Alternatives can match the original's convenience while fitting your current needs.
Availability and Collector Demand
The May 2019 Paper Pumpkin kit is long retired, so official channels are unlikely to have it. Remaining kits may appear through demonstrator destashes, online marketplaces, or craft destash groups. Because it was a special release tied to Shelli Gardner, demand can be higher than for a standard monthly kit. That means prices may be above the original subscription cost, especially if the kit is unopened.
If you want the exact kit, set saved searches on eBay, Etsy, and Facebook Marketplace. Join Paper Pumpkin and Stampin' Up! buy/sell/trade groups and ask for May 2019 specifically. Before buying, confirm that the stamp set, ink spot, envelopes, and paper pieces are included. Used kits may be missing adhesive or have stamped images, so read descriptions carefully.
What Made the May 2019 Kit Appealing
The May 2019 kit, often remembered as Hugs from Shelli, appealed because it removed decision fatigue. Crafters opened the box and found a cohesive color palette, matching envelopes, and pre-designed card layouts. The included stamp set offered versatile sentiments for friendship, encouragement, and thinking of you. It was easy to sit down and finish a batch of cards in one session.
That combination of convenience and sentiment is the real target for any alternative. Look for kits with exclusive stamps, pre-cut card bases, coordinating die cuts, and enough adhesive to complete the projects. If you loved the soft, warm style of the original, prioritize alternatives with floral imagery, hand-lettered sentiments, or muted spring colors.
Best Subscription Alternatives to Paper Pumpkin
Monthly subscriptions are the closest match because they recreate the surprise-and-delight model. The best option depends on whether you want cards, scrapbook layouts, mixed media, or a mix of paper projects. Compare the number of projects, whether stamps and inks are included, and how much assembly is required. Also factor in shipping, cancel-anytime policies, and whether back issues are available.
Some subscriptions focus on card making with full-color instructions, while others send supplies you can use across many projects. If you liked Paper Pumpkin's all-inclusive nature, choose a box that includes adhesive and envelopes. If you already have a large stash, a stamp-and-die kit may be enough. Reading recent reviews and watching unboxing videos will help you avoid a poor fit.
Card-Making and Paper Craft Subscriptions
Simon Says Stamp Card Kit offers a monthly mix of stamps, dies, cardstock, patterned paper, envelopes, and embellishments. Spellbinders Card Kit of the Month is known for generous paper packs, die-cut pieces, and card bases. Hero Arts My Monthly Hero typically includes a large stamp set, dies, and sometimes ink or paper. Altenew, Concord & 9th, and Lawn Fawn also release monthly or seasonal kits that appeal to card makers.
These alternatives vary in what is included. Some provide only stamps and dies, leaving you to supply cardstock and adhesive. Others send enough materials for ten or more cards. If you want the Paper Pumpkin feel, look for kits that show finished samples and include step-by-step instructions. Subscribe for one month first, then decide whether the value matches your crafting habits.
General Craft and Mixed Media Boxes
If you are open to crafts beyond cards, adult craft subscriptions can fill the same creative gap. Annie's Creative Woman Kit, We Craft Box, and Maker Crate offer projects in paper, fiber, and mixed media. Cratejoy hosts many niche boxes for journaling, scrapbooking, and bookbinding. These options are ideal if you want to experiment rather than mass-produce greeting cards.
Mixed media boxes often include paints, stencils, embellishments, and specialty paper. They may not include stamps or envelopes, but they can expand your skills and keep your craft table exciting. Before subscribing, check whether the projects require extra tools like a die-cutting machine, heat tool, or watercolor pencils. That way, you can choose a box that fits your existing supplies.
One-Time and DIY Alternatives to Recreate the Experience
Not everyone wants another monthly commitment. One-time kits from Stampin' Up!, Simon Says Stamp, Altenew, and Concord & 9th can deliver a similar guided experience without recurring charges. Seasonal card kits, retired bundles, and online class kits are also worth watching. These options let you test a style or theme before committing to a subscription.
Building your own kit is another powerful alternative. You can choose the occasion, color palette, and sentiment, then prep everything in advance. This approach uses supplies you already own and can be customized for birthdays, thank-you cards, or holiday mailings. It also solves the problem of sold-out retired kits because you are not dependent on a specific release.
Buying Retired Kits and Individual Supplies
If you want the May 2019 kit specifically, the secondary market is your best bet. eBay, Etsy, Mercari, and Facebook destash groups often list retired Paper Pumpkin kits. You can also search for the Hugs from Shelli stamp set alone, which may be enough if you already have cardstock and inks. Demonstrator blogs and Pinterest often share alternate project ideas using the same stamp set.
For a similar look without the exact kit, shop Stampin' Up! retiring lists, clearance racks, and demonstrator inventories. Look for stamp sets with encouraging sentiments, floral dies, and Designer Series Paper in soft greens, pinks, or yellows. Coordinating cardstock and envelopes will help you assemble a polished batch. Buying individual supplies often costs less than a marked-up collector kit.
Creating a Custom Card Kit at Home
To create a custom kit, start with a theme such as friendship, birthday, or encouragement. Choose three coordinating colors and one neutral, then cut card bases and layers to standard sizes. Add a stamp set with several sentiments, a mini ink pad, and embellishments like enamel dots, ribbon, or die cuts. Place everything in a clear box or zippered pouch with a printed instruction sheet.
A homemade kit can be as simple or elaborate as you like. Include envelopes, adhesive, and dimensionals so you can craft anywhere. Store extra pieces in labeled bags and note which stamps pair with which layouts. Making two or three kits at once gives you a ready-to-go creative session for busy weeks. It is a budget-friendly way to keep the Paper Pumpkin spirit alive.
The May 2019 Paper Pumpkin kit may be retired, but the ritual it created—opening a coordinated box, following a design, and sending handmade cards—is easy to reproduce. Start with one subscription box, a retired kit hunt, or a custom kit you assemble this weekend. The right alternative is simply the one that keeps you creating, connecting, and looking forward to the next batch of happy mail.