old martha stewart paint colors

Old Martha Stewart Paint Colors: Rediscover Timeless Vintage Shades

By Nicole Young
AD

Old Martha Stewart paint colors occupy a peculiar place in the hearts of DIYers and designers. They are discontinued, often difficult to find, and yet the names—Araucana, Plume, Pencil, Tailor’s Chalk—still pop up in decorating forums and paint-matching requests. If you’ve ever tried to repaint a room to its original Martha Stewart hue or tried to capture that soft, collected look, you already know the challenge.

The original Martha Stewart paint collections were never about loud trends. They were edited, muted, and named after things in a well-run home: chalk, sisal, cement, thyme, eggs. That specificity is why old Martha Stewart paint colors remain so compelling today. They offered a shortcut to a layered, lived-in palette before curated color became a marketing buzzword.

The Enduring Appeal of Old Martha Stewart Paint Colors

Martha Stewart’s paint lines arrived in several eras, including Martha Stewart Everyday at Kmart, Martha Stewart Colors through Sherwin-Williams, and Martha Stewart Living Paint at The Home Depot. Each collection had a slightly different formula and color library. The through-line was a preference for complex neutrals and botanical shades that looked historic without feeling dusty.

AD
Martha Stewart’s New “Nature Inspired” Paint Collection Is About to Spark a Home Makeover FRENZY
Martha Stewart’s New “Nature Inspired” Paint Collection Is About to Spark a Home Makeover FRENZY
an open book with many different colors on the pages and numbers in each section,
an open book with many different colors on the pages and numbers in each section,
Remembering: Martha Stewart Paint
Remembering: Martha Stewart Paint

What makes these old shades different from many current palettes is their restraint. They rarely shout. A blue might be grayed with a hint of green; a white might lean toward warm parchment instead of stark bright. That nuance helps rooms feel layered, calm, and intentional.

Why Discontinued Martha Stewart Colors Still Inspire Designers

Discontinued colors create both frustration and mystique. When a shade disappears from shelves, it becomes a secret handshake among designers who saved their fan decks. The fact that you cannot simply walk into a store and buy it makes the color feel more special—and more personal.

Martha Stewart Paint Colors
Martha Stewart Paint Colors
2025 Martha Stewart Paint Finishes.
2025 Martha Stewart Paint Finishes.
Martha Stewart's 20-year-old kitchen looks like 'it was made yesterday' – and it's all thanks to her timeless cabinet color choice
Martha Stewart's 20-year-old kitchen looks like 'it was made yesterday' – and it's all thanks to her timeless cabinet color choice

Designers also return to these old Martha Stewart paint colors because they bridge traditional and modern styles. A grayed green or soft cream can sit comfortably with antique furniture, modern art, and natural textures. They do not fight the room; they give it a quiet foundation.

Where Old Martha Stewart Paint Lines Came From

The Martha Stewart paint story spans multiple retailers and manufacturers. Early Martha Stewart Everyday paint was tied to Kmart, while Martha Stewart Colors appeared through Sherwin-Williams. Later, Martha Stewart Living Paint launched at The Home Depot with an expansive palette and a strong lifestyle identity.

AD

Because each line had its own base and tinting system, two colors with the same name may not be identical across collections. That is important for matching. An old Kmart chip, a Sherwin-Williams fan deck, and a Home Depot sample can all tell a slightly different story about the same hue.

Paint Colors, Martha Stewart Living May 2009
Paint Colors, Martha Stewart Living May 2009
Martha Stewart Living Color Coordination System
Martha Stewart Living Color Coordination System
the words interior designers share their all - time favorite paint colors in martha stewart's website
the words interior designers share their all - time favorite paint colors in martha stewart's website
the website for mad about color is shown in blue, green and gray colors with white accents
the website for mad about color is shown in blue, green and gray colors with white accents
Martha Stewart
Martha Stewart
several shades of paint with different colors
several shades of paint with different colors

How to Identify and Recreate Old Martha Stewart Paint Colors

If you have an old can, a paint chip, or even a blurry photo of a room, you can still get close to the original color. The process starts with identification: gather every clue you have, including the color name, collection, sheen, and any product codes printed on the label.

Recreating a discontinued shade is part art, part science. Paint stores can match physical samples, but undertones and lighting can shift the result. The goal is not always a perfect lab match; it is a match that looks right in your home’s specific light.

AD

Using Fan Decks, Labels, and SKUs for Accurate Matching

Old fan decks are the gold standard for matching. If you own a Martha Stewart paint fan deck from Kmart, Sherwin-Williams, or The Home Depot, keep it away from direct sunlight and handle the chips carefully. Faded chips can lead to a faded match.

A Delicious Breakfast and Shopping at The Home Depot - The Martha Stewart Blog
A Delicious Breakfast and Shopping at The Home Depot - The Martha Stewart Blog
the text reads, 5 outdated paint color trends to refire martha stewart
the text reads, 5 outdated paint color trends to refire martha stewart
the color swatches for martha's living room are peachs, pinks and browns
the color swatches for martha's living room are peachs, pinks and browns
8 Paint Colors Designers Never Want to See Again — Martha Stewart
8 Paint Colors Designers Never Want to See Again — Martha Stewart

Paint can labels are equally valuable. Look for the color name, collection, product line, base type, and any SKU or formula numbers. Photograph the label in daylight, and bring the physical can or a removable sample to your paint retailer. A good match technician can use those details to narrow the undertone.

Best Practices for Color Matching Discontinued Shades

Start with a quart, not a gallon. Paint a large sample board and move it around the room at different times of day. Compare it to the original chip or object near the trim, floor, and furniture. A color that looks perfect under store lights can turn too pink, too green, or too gray at home.

AD

Sheen matters more than many people expect. A discontinued shade in flat may look velvety and deep, while the same formula in satin can appear lighter and more reflective. If you are matching an old wall, consider whether the original paint has yellowed or chalked, which can also alter the perceived color.

Most Beloved Old Martha Stewart Paint Colors and Their Modern Matches

The most requested old Martha Stewart paint colors tend to be the quiet ones: soft whites, grayed blues, herbal greens, and earthy neutrals. These shades were designed to work together, which is why an entire house could feel cohesive with only a handful of colors.

Modern paint brands have released countless shades that echo the Martha Stewart aesthetic. While no match is guaranteed, the following comparisons can help you start your search. Always test before committing, because regional light and existing finishes change everything.

Iconic Neutrals and Whites

Names like Tailor’s Chalk, Pencil, Sisal, Bedford Grey, and Cement Grey still come up in color conversations. Tailor’s Chalk reads as a soft, slightly warm white; Pencil has a pale, muted yellow-beige quality; Sisal feels like dry grass or linen. Bedford Grey and Cement Grey are grounded mid-tone grays with subtle green or blue undertones.

For modern approximations, look at Benjamin Moore White Dove or Sherwin-Williams Alabaster for a warm white; Benjamin Moore Shaker Beige or Sherwin-Williams Kilim Beige for sisal-like tan; and Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter or Sherwin-Williams Repose Gray for grayed neutrals. Compare them against an old chip if you have one, because the Martha versions often have a softer, dustier quality.

Signature Blues, Greens, and Naturals

Martha Stewart’s blues and greens were rarely primary or saturated. Shades such as Araucana, Blue Hubbard, Winter Thyme, and Plumage leaned into gray, mist, and botanical depth. They could make a kitchen feel like a garden room or a bedroom feel like a coastal cottage without resorting to nautical clichés.

To approximate these old favorites, explore Benjamin Moore Wythe Blue or Sherwin-Williams Rainwashed for a soft blue-green; Benjamin Moore Quiet Moments or Sherwin-Williams Sea Salt for pale, airy blues; and Benjamin Moore Sage Green or Sherwin-Williams Clary Sage for herbal greens. Bring in natural textures like linen, aged wood, and unglazed pottery to complete the mood.

If you have an old Martha Stewart fan deck tucked in a drawer or a paint can in the basement, treat it as a working archive. Pull a few chips, test them in your own light, and let that disciplined, nature-inspired palette shape your next project. The colors may be discontinued, but the way they make a room feel is anything but outdated.

AD