Off Color Brewery: Bold Beers, Wild Flavors & Chicago Craft Culture
Off Color Brewing is a Chicago craft brewery that has built a reputation for making beers that feel both ancient and entirely new. Founded in 2013 by John Laffler and Dave Bleitner, it has become a favorite among drinkers who crave saisons, goses, wild ales, and lagers with a distinctive point of view. The name says it all: this is beer that refuses to stay inside the lines.
From its flagship Apex Predator farmhouse ale to the tart, salty Troublesome gose, Off Color Brewing blends old-world techniques with a modern Chicago sensibility. The brewery’s taproom, The Mousetrap, gives visitors a chance to taste experimental batches, rare releases, and core beers in a relaxed setting. For locals and beer travelers alike, it is a destination that rewards curiosity.
Off Color Brewing: A Chicago Original with Old-World Soul
Off Color Brewing occupies a special place in the Chicago beer scene. While many breweries chase trends, Off Color has stayed committed to styles that almost disappeared, such as gose, Berliner Weisse, bière de garde, and rustic saison. The result is a portfolio that feels both educational and deeply drinkable.
That old-world focus does not mean the brewery is stuck in the past. Off Color’s beers often include unexpected ingredients, playful names, and a dry sense of humor. The brewery treats tradition as a starting point, not a rulebook, which is exactly why its beers stand out on crowded shelves.
History and Founding Philosophy
Off Color Brewing was founded in 2013 by John Laffler and Dave Bleitner, two brewers with serious craft beer pedigrees. Laffler had worked at Goose Island, including on its barrel-aging program, while Bleitner brought experience from Two Brothers Brewing. Their shared interest in forgotten European styles and mixed fermentation laid the groundwork for Off Color’s identity.
The founding philosophy was simple: brew what they wanted to drink, even if those styles were not fashionable. That meant saisons with peppery yeast character, goses with real salinity, and wild ales that could age gracefully. Over time, that philosophy helped Off Color build a loyal following that appreciates nuance over hype.
What Makes Their Beer “Off Color”?
“Off Color” is more than a catchy name. It reflects a willingness to be unconventional, whether that means adding mango to a Berliner Weisse, brewing a dark honey ale, or releasing a stout inspired by campfire desserts. The brewery’s sense of humor shows up in beer names and label art, but the liquid itself is treated with serious precision.
Drinkers can expect balance, drinkability, and a point of view. A beer like Apex Predator is dry and peppery rather than sweet and heavy. Troublesome is bright and tart with a saline snap. Even Off Color’s darker beers tend to avoid cloying sweetness, favoring complexity and a clean finish instead.
Signature Beers and the Taproom Experience
Off Color Brewing’s lineup includes year-round beers, seasonal releases, and small-batch experiments. The core beers are widely distributed in Chicago and beyond, while taproom-only offerings give locals a reason to return often. For many drinkers, the first taste of Apex Predator or Troublesome is what turns them into regulars.
The brewery’s taproom, The Mousetrap, has become a gathering place for beer lovers who want to explore without pretense. It is the kind of place where you can ask questions, try a flight, and discover a style you did not know you liked. That approachable education is a big part of the Off Color appeal.
Apex Predator, Troublesome, and Other Standouts
Apex Predator is Off Color’s flagship farmhouse ale and arguably its most famous beer. It pours with a rustic golden hue and offers notes of black pepper, citrus, and earthy yeast. Despite its complexity, it is remarkably easy to drink, which is why it has become a staple in many Chicago bars and bottle shops.
Troublesome is a gose-style ale that delivers tartness, coriander, and a gentle saltiness. Fierce, a Berliner Weisse often brewed with mango, adds a fruity, sour twist. Other notables include Scurry, a dark honey ale, and Dino S’mores, a rich stout that tastes like a campfire treat without becoming overly sweet. Together, these beers show the range of Off Color’s creativity.
The Mousetrap Taproom and Visitor Tips
The Mousetrap is Off Color’s taproom in Chicago, and it is designed for exploration. The tap list typically includes core beers, seasonal specialties, and experimental one-offs that never leave the building. Because the space is intimate, it is a good idea to check hours and current offerings before you go, especially on weekends.
Visitors should also consider taking home a few bottles or cans, since some releases are limited. The taproom staff are generally happy to guide you toward a style that matches your taste, whether you prefer sour, funky, roasty, or crisp. If you are new to Off Color, a flight is a smart way to sample several beers side by side.
Whether you are a Chicago local or just passing through, Off Color Brewing offers a reminder that craft beer can be both thoughtful and fun. Start with Apex Predator, branch out to Troublesome or Fierce, and let your curiosity lead from there. The best way to understand what makes this brewery special is to visit The Mousetrap, order a pour, and see where the conversation goes.