nl only auction values 2018

NL Only Auction Values 2018: Top Draft Targets & Sleepers

By Nicole Jackson
AD

NL-only auction values 2018 were more than a historical footnote for fantasy baseball managers. They were a real-time stress test of how to build a roster from half the player pool, where every dollar carried more weight and every position scarcity was magnified. In a National League-only format, you cannot fall back on American League stars to patch holes, so the prices from that season reveal exactly how the market handled a limited supply of impact bats, aces, and closers.

Reviewing those values is useful whether you are digging through old draft boards, preparing for a similar NL-only league, or trying to understand why certain players commanded $40 while others lingered at $8. The 2018 season had its own quirks: a deep but risky starting pitching tier, a catcher pool that thinned out quickly, and a group of young outfielders who changed the shape of auctions. That mix made NL-only auction values 2018 a fascinating snapshot of supply, demand, and inflation.

What Drove NL-Only Auction Values in 2018

The foundation of any auction value is league structure. In a standard 12-team NL-only league with a $260 budget and 23 active roster spots, managers collectively spend $3,120, but not all of that money goes to stars. A large chunk is reserved for $1 endgame picks and bench depth. The real battle happens in the middle and top tiers, where inflation pushes prices above mixed-league norms because the replacement level is so much lower.

AD
Global Wine Auction Market Exceeds $479 Million in 2018
Global Wine Auction Market Exceeds $479 Million in 2018
a large number of numbers are displayed on the page, and there is no image to describe
a large number of numbers are displayed on the page, and there is no image to describe
Sales at World's Top Three Auction Houses Fell 18.3% in 2024’s First Quarter - Auction Daily
Sales at World's Top Three Auction Houses Fell 18.3% in 2024’s First Quarter - Auction Daily

In 2018, that inflation was especially noticeable at the top. The NL lacked the same depth of five-category superstars that the AL offered, so managers who wanted an anchor had to pay a premium. A player projected for 30 home runs, 100 RBI, and a strong average could easily go for $35 to $45 in an NL-only auction, even if the same stat line would cost $28 in a mixed league. That gap is the heartbeat of NL-only auction values 2018.

The National League Player Pool

NL-only managers in 2018 could not bid on Mike Trout, Mookie Betts, Jose Altuve, Aaron Judge, or J.D. Martinez. That limitation forced attention onto National League standouts like Nolan Arenado, Paul Goldschmidt, Freddie Freeman, Joey Votto, Charlie Blackmon, Trea Turner, Bryce Harper, and Kris Bryant. Each offered a different category profile, and each carried a price tag that reflected not just talent but also the scarcity of comparable production.

The Online Marketplace with Weekly Auctions
The Online Marketplace with Weekly Auctions
Trophy Collections and Luxury Spending Powered Christie’s and Sotheby’s Record Half-Year Results
Trophy Collections and Luxury Spending Powered Christie’s and Sotheby’s Record Half-Year Results
CF Art Auction Catalog 2018
CF Art Auction Catalog 2018

The pool also included breakout and rebound candidates who shaped the middle rounds. Christian Yelich was rising, Lorenzo Cain offered speed and average, Tommy Pham had just delivered a late-career surge, and Rhys Hoskins brought massive power upside. Behind the plate, Buster Posey, Yadier Molina, Willson Contreras, and J.T. Realmuto formed a small elite group before the position fell off a cliff. Those names explain why catcher values in NL-only auctions often looked strange compared to mixed formats.

Inflation and League Settings

Inflation in NL-only auctions happens when keepers are undervalued. If several stars are kept at below-market salaries, the remaining managers have more dollars chasing fewer elite players. In 2018, leagues with 15 teams, two catchers, or deep benches saw even sharper inflation. A $40 bid that looked reckless in a shallow mixed league could be perfectly reasonable when the alternative was a replacement-level player hitting .240 with 12 home runs.

AD

League settings also changed how managers valued pitching. Some leagues used quality starts instead of wins, which boosted pitchers on strong teams and hurt volatile arms. Others counted saves plus holds, which flattened the closer market. The best managers did not treat NL-only auction values 2018 as universal constants. They adjusted for their own categories, roster rules, and keeper inflation before setting a single dollar value.

Artprice News: ahead of Frieze London and Art Basel Paris, Artprice by Artmarket releases its 2025 Contemporary Art Market Report. Annual record number of auction transactions, substantial market paradigm shift, AI influences | UseTheBitcoin
Artprice News: ahead of Frieze London and Art Basel Paris, Artprice by Artmarket releases its 2025 Contemporary Art Market Report. Annual record number of auction transactions, substantial market paradigm shift, AI influences | UseTheBitcoin
the list of companies that have been awarded for their services
the list of companies that have been awarded for their services
two men holding up signs in front of a room full of people sitting at tables
two men holding up signs in front of a room full of people sitting at tables
World Coins for Sale in Online Auctions - Catawiki
World Coins for Sale in Online Auctions - Catawiki
Dallas’ Côtes du Coeur Raises a Record-Breaking $5.4 Million
Dallas’ Côtes du Coeur Raises a Record-Breaking $5.4 Million
people sitting at tables in a banquet hall holding up signs with the number 85 on them
people sitting at tables in a banquet hall holding up signs with the number 85 on them

How to Use 2018 NL-Only Auction Values in Draft Prep

The smartest way to use historical auction values is not to memorize old prices. It is to study the shape of the market. In 2018 NL-only auctions, the top tier was compact, the middle tier was deep but risky, and the endgame was full of $1 fliers. Managers who understood that structure could plan their spending in waves rather than chasing every name that appeared on the board.

You can also compare those old values to your own projections. If you notice that a certain player type consistently went for less than expected, that might reveal a market inefficiency you can exploit in future drafts. If a position always inflated, you can decide whether to pay the premium or stream replacement-level options. That is how NL-only auction values 2018 become a tool instead of a trivia answer.

AD

Hitting Values and Position Scarcity

In 2018 NL-only auctions, corner infielders and outfielders dominated the top hitting values. Nolan Arenado and Paul Goldschmidt were typically $35 to $42 players because they combined power, run production, and stable playing time. Freddie Freeman and Joey Votto sat just behind, while Anthony Rizzo and Kris Bryant offered multi-category value at slightly lower costs. Managers who needed a foundation often spent heavily here.

an old gold sovereign coin with the image of queen elizabeth on it's face
an old gold sovereign coin with the image of queen elizabeth on it's face
Schulman b.v. - Auction 346 Lot 534
Schulman b.v. - Auction 346 Lot 534
42 Vintage Collectibles That Sold for More Than People Expected - NewsBreak
42 Vintage Collectibles That Sold for More Than People Expected - NewsBreak
Schätze der D-Mark-Zeit Teil 1: Die Ausgaben der Bank deutscher Länder 1948–1949 - MünzenWoche %
Schätze der D-Mark-Zeit Teil 1: Die Ausgaben der Bank deutscher Länder 1948–1949 - MünzenWoche %

Middle infield was thinner, which made Trea Turner’s speed a premium asset. He could go for $35 or more because stolen bases were scarce and his position eligibility was valuable. Javier Baez and Ozzie Albies offered cheaper upside, but they came with more risk. Catcher was the most frustrating position: after Posey, Contreras, Realmuto, and Molina, the drop-off was steep. Paying $15 or more for a catcher was a strategic choice, not an automatic one, and many successful teams waited until the end.

Pitching Values and Risk Management

Pitching values in 2018 NL-only auctions were volatile because so many aces carried health or workload questions. Max Scherzer was a clear $40-plus arm, a rare combination of strikeouts, ratios, and durability. Clayton Kershaw, Noah Syndergaard, Jacob deGrom, and Stephen Strasburg all had elite upside, but each came with enough risk that managers had to decide whether to pay full price or let someone else take the gamble.

AD

Closers were expensive but equally risky. Kenley Jansen, Wade Davis, Corey Knebel, Brad Hand, and Felipe Vazquez all had secure jobs on paper, but saves are volatile and one bad stretch can change a bullpen hierarchy. In NL-only leagues, where replacement closers are hard to find, the top relievers still commanded $15 to $20. The key was not avoiding closers entirely, but knowing which ones were worth the price and which ones were likely to become midseason trade chips or lost jobs.

As you build your own auction board, let the 2018 NL-only market remind you that context is everything. A price tag from one league may be a bargain in another, and a player who looks expensive in isolation can be a bargain when inflation and positional scarcity are factored in. Use those old values to sharpen your tiers, identify the positions where you are willing to spend, and plan your endgame before the bidding starts. The managers who thrive in NL-only auctions are the ones who adapt fastest when the room pushes prices away from the projections.

AD