MyAnimeList Summer 2017: Best Anime, Rankings & Must-Watch Picks
When anime fans dig through the archives of MyAnimeList summer 2017, they usually stumble onto the same discovery: a season that looked modest on paper but quietly delivered some of the most memorable titles of the decade. The seasonal chart that year was packed with short comedies, ambitious originals, long-awaited sequels, and one dark fantasy adventure that would go on to define an entire era of online anime discussion. For anyone who tracked episodes week by week through MAL's episode threads, that summer felt less like a casual viewing schedule and more like a full-time hobby.
Understanding why Summer 2017 matters requires more than a simple list of titles. The season sits at a fascinating intersection of streaming expansion, forum culture, and shifting viewer habits. MyAnimeList was still the default hub for seasonal planning in 2017, and the way users rated, ranked, and argued about that lineup says a lot about how the community operated before algorithmic feeds took over.
Why MyAnimeList Was the Heart of the Summer 2017 Season
By mid-2017, MyAnimeList had established itself as the primary organizational tool for English-speaking anime viewers. Seasonal pages broke the lineup into categories such as new TV series, continuing TV series, ONAs, OVAs, and films, which made it easy to see that the summer slate relied heavily on brand-new productions rather than carryovers. Users built their watch lists in advance, added titles to "Plan to Watch," and used member counts as a rough popularity forecast before a single episode aired.
The site also served as an archive of community reaction. Every episode page carried a dedicated discussion thread, and those threads became the de facto town square for weekly opinions, manga comparisons, and heated debates about adaptation quality. Even people who never posted anything still read those threads, which gave the season a shared rhythm that is harder to find in today's fragmented social media landscape.
How Seasonal Charts and Streaming Schedules Shaped the Season
The Summer 2017 chart was noticeably dense, with dozens of new television series competing for attention alongside a handful of continuing shows that had started in spring. Broadcast dates, studios, and source material were all listed on each entry, so viewers could quickly spot patterns such as the heavy concentration of light novel adaptations and the surprising number of short-format comedies. That structural clarity encouraged people to sample widely rather than commit to a single genre.
Streaming access was another major factor. Crunchyroll carried a large share of the simulcasts, while Amazon's Anime Strike held exclusive rights to several notable titles behind a double paywall, and Funimation handled dubs and home video releases. That fragmented licensing landscape shaped which shows climbed the MAL popularity rankings fastest, because a series locked behind an extra subscription often struggled to build the same momentum as one available on a widely used platform.
Episode Discussion Threads and the Score Wars
MAL's scoring system turned the season into an ongoing competition. Each anime displayed a weighted score that shifted daily, and users watched those numbers the way sports fans watch standings. A strong premiere could push a show into the high eights within hours, while a controversial finale could knock half a point off overnight, sparking arguments about review bombing and score inflation that still echo in community discussions today.
Beyond scores, the platform tracked watching, completed, on-hold, dropped, and plan-to-watch counts, which offered an unusually transparent look at viewer retention. A series with a high score but an enormous drop rate told a very different story than one with a modest score and steady completion numbers. Those statistics gave armchair analysts plenty of material, and Summer 2017 provided several perfect case studies.
The Anime That Defined Summer 2017 on MAL
No single show monopolized the conversation that season, which is part of what makes it so interesting in retrospect. Instead, the lineup split into distinct camps: a prestige dark fantasy, a handful of punchy short comedies, several crowd-pleasing sequels, and a cluster of originals that punched well above their production budgets. That variety kept the seasonal chart lively from July through September.
The table below highlights several titles that dominated MyAnimeList's summer 2017 rankings, along with approximate scores recorded around the end of the season. Keep in mind that MAL scores drift over time as new viewers add their ratings, so these figures are best read as a snapshot of contemporary reception rather than permanent verdicts.
| Title | Studio | Approximate MAL Score | Format |
|---|---|---|---|
| Made in Abyss | Kinema Citrus | 8.7 | TV, 13 episodes |
| My Hero Academia Season 2 (continuing) | Bones | 8.6 | TV, 25 episodes |
| Welcome to the Ballroom | Production I.G | 8.2 | TV, 24 episodes |
| Princess Principal | Studio 3Hz / Actas | 8.0 | TV, 12 episodes |
| Tsuredure Children | Studio Gokumi | 8.0 | TV, 12 short episodes |
| Classroom of the Elite | Lerche | 7.9 | TV, 12 episodes |
| Gamers! | Pine Jam | 7.6 | TV, 12 episodes |
| Kakegurui | MAPPA | 7.6 | TV, 12 episodes |
Made in Abyss and the Dark Fantasy Phenomenon
Made in Abyss arrived with almost no advance hype and left as the highest-rated title of the season. Adapted from Akihito Tsukushi's manga, the series followed Riko and the robot boy Reg as they descended into a massive, mysterious pit filled with beautiful landscapes and genuinely terrifying creatures. Kinema Citrus paired lush background art with a haunting score from composer Kevin Penkin, creating a contrast between childlike wonder and visceral horror that viewers could not stop talking about.
On MyAnimeList, the show's score climbed steadily with each episode, eventually placing it among the highest-rated single-cour series on the entire site. Episode discussion threads ballooned into hundreds of replies, and characters like Nanachi became instant community favorites. The season finale left viewers desperate for more, fueling years of speculation about a continuation long before any sequel was officially confirmed.
Short-Form Comedy and Romance Domination
Summer 2017 was an exceptional season for viewers with limited time. Tsuredure Children delivered a dozen twelve-minute episodes that juggled multiple couples and somehow gave each romance a satisfying arc. Aho-Girl leaned into pure absurdity with similarly brief episodes, while Netsuzou Trap explored far more mature territory in a compact runtime. These shorter formats made binge-watching and weekly catch-ups equally convenient.
The MAL data reflected that accessibility. Short series tend to accumulate completions quickly, and several of these titles posted completion rates that full-length shows could only envy. Tsuredure Children in particular developed a devoted following in the discussion threads, where users debated which couple deserved more screen time and celebrated the show's refusal to drag out obvious romantic tension.
Princess Principal and the Original Anime Renaissance
Original anime without a manga or light novel safety net always carry extra risk, and Summer 2017 offered several of them. Princess Principal stood out immediately with its steampunk spy setting, a cast of girls attending a prestigious academy by day and running espionage operations by night, and an intentionally shuffled episode order that encouraged viewers to piece the timeline together themselves. The writing rewarded attentive watching.
MAL users responded with detailed theory threads, timeline charts, and episode-by-episode analysis that turned the series into a puzzle-solving community event. That enthusiasm had real staying power: the franchise later expanded with a series of sequel films, proving that a well-executed original can build a dedicated audience even without a pre-existing fanbase to lean on.
Welcome to the Ballroom and the Sports Drama Revival
Competitive ballroom dancing is not an obvious subject for a sports drama, but Welcome to the Ballroom made it feel as intense as any tournament arc. Production I.G translated Tomo Takeuchi's dynamic manga artwork into fluid dance sequences, and the show's focus on posture, footwork, and partner chemistry gave viewers something genuinely new to cheer for. The competitive structure gave every episode a clear emotional stake.
Reception on MAL was enthusiastic but not uncritical. Viewers praised the choreography and character development while complaining about pacing slowdowns and a recap episode that interrupted momentum mid-season. Even so, the series maintained one of the strongest scores in the season's lineup, and its discussion threads regularly featured real-world dance commentary from users with ballroom experience.
The Lasting Legacy of Summer 2017 on MyAnimeList
Seasons fade quickly in the anime community, but Summer 2017 left visible marks on MyAnimeList's culture. The success of Made in Abyss proved that a relatively small studio could produce a title that dominated the site's all-time rankings. The popularity of short-format comedies reminded viewers that episode length has little to do with impact. Meanwhile, the divided reception of several high-profile adaptations kept debates about source fidelity and pacing alive well into the following year.
The season also serves as a useful benchmark for anyone studying how audience behavior has changed. In 2017, discovery happened largely through seasonal charts, forum threads, and recommendations from friends. Today, clips, short-form video, and recommendation algorithms play a much bigger role, yet the underlying question remains identical: which shows are actually worth your time?
What Modern MAL Users Can Still Learn From the Season
The best way to revisit Summer 2017 is through MyAnimeList's own seasonal archive, which preserves the original lineup complete with airing dates, studios, and member statistics. Sorting that list by score reveals the obvious heavyweights, but filtering by members or favorites often surfaces titles that were overshadowed at the time. Restaurant to Another World, for example, never cracked the top of the charts but quietly built a loyal following with its relaxed fantasy cooking premise.
Digging into the comments and discussion threads attached to each entry adds another layer. Reading reactions written in 2017 gives an honest picture of how a show landed in the moment, free from later retrospective hype. It is a reminder that seasonal rankings are snapshots, not verdicts, and that some of the most enjoyable titles from any given year are the ones nobody argued about.
How Summer 2017 Shaped Later Trends
Several threads from that season extended far beyond September. Made in Abyss continued with compilation films, the Dawn of the Deep Soul movie, and eventually a full second season, while Princess Principal expanded into a multi-film series. Classroom of the Elite and Kakegurui both earned follow-up seasons years later, and My Hero Academia's second season cemented the franchise as a long-term pillar of the industry.
Equally important was the cultural shift in how fans discuss a season while it airs. The habit of checking a MAL score before deciding whether to start a show, comparing completion rates, and treating episode threads as appointment viewing all intensified around this period. Summer 2017 was not the beginning of that behavior, but it was one of the clearest demonstrations of how central MyAnimeList had become to the viewing experience.
If you have never explored the Summer 2017 archive, treat it like a treasure hunt rather than a checklist. Start with the obvious standout, then wander into the short comedies, the ambitious originals, and the mid-tier titles that never got their moment. Add a few to your list, leave a score once you finish them, and you will be participating in the same ritual that made that season so memorable for everyone who followed it live.