MLB DFS 9/3/19: Top DraftKings & FanDuel Picks, Lineups & Sleepers
On September 3, 2019, the MLB DFS 9/3/19 slate delivered a full night of baseball with playoff races tightening, aces taking the mound, and several offenses in prime spots. For DFS players, it was the kind of slate that rewarded both careful pitching research and a willingness to chase high totals in tournaments. The date may be in the past, but studying how that slate unfolded can still sharpen your approach to modern lineup building.
What made MLB DFS 9/3/19 so memorable was the collision of elite pitching and explosive offense. Gerrit Cole turned in a dominant strikeout performance, Jack Flaherty continued his second-half surge, and the Washington Nationals completed a stunning comeback against the New York Mets that altered the outcome of thousands of contests. The slate was not simply about picking the best players; it was about understanding roles, game scripts, and how quickly a DFS score can swing in one inning.
MLB DFS 9/3/19 Slate Overview: Pitching, Parks, and Playoff Stakes
The September 3, 2019 schedule arrived with meaningful games across both leagues. Teams like the Astros, Yankees, Dodgers, Braves, Nationals, Cardinals, and Indians were fighting for positioning, while others were already evaluating young talent for the following season. That blend of motivation and roster variation created real DFS value, especially when lineups were released and September call-ups entered the mix.
Pitchers dominated the early conversation. Gerrit Cole was the headline arm, but Jack Flaherty, Mike Clevinger, Sonny Gray, Stephen Strasburg, Lance Lynn, Jose Berrios, and Madison Bumgarner all offered appealing cases. Hitters had to be chosen carefully because paying up for two aces often meant sacrificing the kind of star-studded stacks that win large-field tournaments.
Pitching Options and Strikeout Upside
Gerrit Cole was the premier tournament and cash-game option on this slate. He entered the game in the middle of a historic strikeout stretch, and his matchup against Milwaukee gave him both a high floor and a ceiling that few other pitchers could match. DFS players who rostered Cole were often able to pair him with mid-range bats and still compete for first place.
Behind Cole, Jack Flaherty was another elite play. His second half in 2019 was brilliant, and a matchup with the Giants gave him a favorable park and opponent. Mike Clevinger also stood out against the White Sox, while Sonny Gray’s strikeout form made him a popular tournament pivot. Stephen Strasburg, Lance Lynn, and Jose Berrios rounded out a deep group of arms, giving players multiple paths to a strong pitching score.
Ballparks and Weather to Monitor
Coors Field was again impossible to ignore whenever the Rockies hosted the Dodgers. The altitude inflated run expectations, and DFS players knew that stacking there could either separate them from the field or sink their lineups if the game turned into a pitcher’s duel. Fenway Park, Great American Ball Park, and Miller Park also offered above-average run environments that deserved attention.
Weather was another factor. Early September can bring rain delays and wind shifts that change how a game plays, especially in the Midwest and along the East Coast. Checking lineup cards, projected starters, and late scratches was essential because a single replacement in the middle of a stack could mean the difference between a min-cash and a tournament takedown.
Top Stacks and Offensive Matchups on 9/3/19
Stacking was the engine of most winning lineups on MLB DFS 9/3/19. The highest implied totals included Nationals-Mets, Rockies-Dodgers at Coors Field, Twins-Red Sox at Fenway, and Braves-Blue Jays. Each game offered different types of leverage, from chalky Coors bats to lower-owned stacks in less obvious spots.
The Nationals-Mets game quickly became the story of the night. New York built a 10-4 lead and appeared to be in control, but Washington stormed back with seven runs in the ninth inning to win 11-10. That single game produced massive fantasy totals and reminded DFS players why late-game correlation is so important in baseball tournaments.
Nationals and Mets: The Game That Broke the Slate
Washington’s lineup featured Trea Turner, Adam Eaton, Anthony Rendon, Juan Soto, Howie Kendrick, and Kurt Suzuki. Several of those hitters delivered key knocks during the comeback, and the Nationals’ stack became one of the highest-scoring combinations on the entire slate. Even players who rostered Washington early in the game were rewarded for staying patient through a slow start.
The Mets also posted ten runs, which meant their stack was far from a failure in DFS terms. Pete Alonso, Jeff McNeil, Michael Conforto, Wilson Ramos, and Amed Rosario all had chances to produce. The game became a perfect example of how two opposing stacks can both smash value, especially when bullpens falter and extra-base hits pile up late.
Astros, Braves, and Indians Bats
The Astros were another popular stack because they combined a deep lineup with a strong pitcher on the mound. George Springer, Jose Altuve, Alex Bregman, Yordan Alvarez, and Yuli Gurriel gave Houston multiple ways to score. Pairing Cole with Houston bats was a common correlation play in tournaments, even if it required careful salary management.
Atlanta’s lineup against Toronto featured Ronald Acuna Jr., Freddie Freeman, Josh Donaldson, and Ozzie Albies, a group with power and speed. Cleveland also had an appealing matchup against Chicago, with Francisco Lindor, Carlos Santana, Jose Ramirez, and Yasiel Puig capable of filling the box score. These stacks did not always receive the same attention as Coors or Nationals-Mets, which made them useful leverage options.
Pitcher-by-Pitcher DFS Review for 9/3/19
Pitching decisions shaped the entire slate. The top arms were expensive, and choosing the right one was critical for cash games. In tournaments, however, the winning approach often involved using an elite pitcher and then finding underpriced bats who could take advantage of a weak opposing bullpen or a favorable park.
Gerrit Cole delivered the kind of performance that justified his salary. Jack Flaherty and Mike Clevinger also posted strong lines, while Sonny Gray and Stephen Strasburg provided solid returns in the right formats. The slate was deep enough that players who missed on Cole could still compete if their hitting stacks exploded.
Gerrit Cole: The Ceiling Play
Cole’s start against Milwaukee was the definition of a DFS ceiling game. He missed bats at an elite rate, worked deep into the game, and limited damage. For cash-game players, he was a stable anchor. For GPP players, he offered the strikeout upside needed to separate from lineups that used a cheaper pitcher and spent more on hitting.
The challenge with Cole was his high ownership. When a pitcher is clearly the best option, many entrants flock to him, which can reduce leverage. Still, on a slate where several other aces also performed well, Cole’s raw score kept him relevant in every contest type. He was not a player to fade lightly.
Jack Flaherty and Mike Clevinger: The Other Aces
Jack Flaherty was in the midst of a dominant second half, and his matchup with San Francisco fit his strengths. He attacked the strike zone, generated swings and misses, and gave DFS players a slightly lower-owned alternative to Cole. His performance rewarded anyone who trusted the recent form over name recognition.
Mike Clevinger had a strong case against the White Sox as well. Cleveland was chasing a playoff spot, and Clevinger’s strikeout rate made him a tournament-friendly option. When he was paired with Cleveland’s offense, it created a correlated build that could pay off in multiple ways. Flaherty and Clevinger both proved that this slate was not just a one-pitcher showcase.
Tournament Strategy and Lessons from the Slate
MLB DFS 9/3/19 offered a master class in tournament strategy. The biggest scores came from lineups that combined an elite pitcher with a stack that went overlooked or exploded late. The Nationals’ comeback was the clearest example, but the slate also showed how Coors Field, Fenway Park, and other hitter-friendly venues could produce extreme outcomes.
Cash-game players were generally best served by locking in a top pitcher and building a balanced lineup with high-floor hitters. GPP players needed more risk. They had to decide whether to fade the chalky Coors stack, target a lower-owned offense like Cleveland or Atlanta, or pay down at pitcher to afford multiple star bats.
Ownership Leverage and Late Swaps
Ownership leverage was especially important on a slate with so many obvious plays. Cole, Coors hitters, and the Nationals-Mets game attracted plenty of attention. Finding a way to gain exposure to those spots without simply copying the field was the key to tournament success. Sometimes that meant using a secondary bat from a popular team or a pitcher with a lower projected roster percentage.
Late swaps and injury news also mattered. MLB lineups are not always confirmed early, and a late scratch can change the value of an entire stack. DFS players who stayed active until lock were able to take advantage of batting-order shifts, weather updates, and bullpen news that others missed. That edge remains just as important today.
What Modern DFS Players Can Learn
The first lesson from September 3, 2019, is that baseball DFS is never over until the final out. The Nationals trailed by six runs entering the ninth and still produced enough offense to swing tournaments. Lineups that looked dead through seven innings suddenly became contenders after one wild inning.
The second lesson is that elite pitching and high-total stacking can coexist. Cole, Flaherty, and Clevinger gave lineups a strong foundation, while stacks like Washington and New York supplied the upside. The best builds on MLB DFS 9/3/19 found a way to blend stability with volatility instead of choosing one extreme.
The 9/3/19 MLB DFS slate remains a useful case study for anyone building baseball lineups. It shows how quickly a game can flip, why late-game correlation matters, and how a single stack can turn a good night into a great one. As you prepare for your next slate, keep that balance in mind: trust the process, monitor the news, and stay ready for the kind of late-inning chaos that makes baseball DFS so rewarding.