mccoys fence pickets

McCoys Fence Pickets: Durable, Affordable Picks for a Beautiful Fence

By Daniel Garcia
AD

If you are planning a new fence or repairing an aging one, the pickets you choose will determine how the finished project looks, how long it lasts, and how much maintenance it demands down the road. McCoy's fence pickets are a staple for homeowners, ranchers, and contractors across Texas and the surrounding region, largely because McCoy's Building Supply carries a practical, job-ready selection rather than a boutique assortment. Whether you need a few boards to patch a wind-damaged section or a full pallet for a quarter-mile of ranch fencing, knowing what the stores actually stock saves you a wasted trip.

This guide breaks down the wood species, dimensions, grades, and profiles you are most likely to find on the racks, along with realistic advice on cost, longevity, and installation. By the end, you should be able to walk into a McCoy's location with a clear plan, a materials list, and the confidence that the pickets you load onto your trailer are the right ones for the job.

What to Expect From McCoy's Fence Picket Selection

McCoy's Building Supply has been a family-owned operation since 1927, headquartered in San Marcos, Texas, with locations spread across Texas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Fence materials are a core category for the company, and pickets are among the highest-volume items in that department. Because the stores serve both retail homeowners and professional fencing crews, the inventory tends to lean toward proven, high-turnover products rather than specialty imports that sit on the shelf for months.

AD
Mccoy Picket fences mixing bowl
Mccoy Picket fences mixing bowl
a wooden deck with metal railings in the middle of trees and grass around it
a wooden deck with metal railings in the middle of trees and grass around it
a close up of a wooden fence near a brick wall with holes in the boards
a close up of a wooden fence near a brick wall with holes in the boards

It is worth setting expectations up front: selection varies by store and by season. A location in the Hill Country may stock deeper quantities of cedar, while a store serving East Texas pine country might emphasize pressure-treated southern yellow pine. Spring and early summer are peak fencing months, so that is when you will see the widest variety and the freshest restocks. If you need a large, uniform run of pickets for a single project, calling ahead to confirm quantity and grade is a smart first step rather than arriving and hoping.

Wood Species Commonly Stocked

Western red cedar is the premium option in most McCoy's fence aisles. It is naturally resistant to rot and insect damage without chemical treatment, it is lightweight and easy to handle, and it holds stain and paint well. Cedar also moves less than many alternatives as it dries, which means fewer cracked pickets and fewer gaps opening up after the first summer. The trade-off is cost, and cedar pricing fluctuates with mill supply and freight, so the same picket can look meaningfully more expensive from one quarter to the next.

5/8
5/8
Pinterest
Pinterest
Wooden Fence Embroidery Design Set - Wooden Fence Stitch Pattern - Farm, Garden Fence Machine Embroidery - Fence Pattern- 33 Designs 6 Sizes
Wooden Fence Embroidery Design Set - Wooden Fence Stitch Pattern - Farm, Garden Fence Machine Embroidery - Fence Pattern- 33 Designs 6 Sizes

Pressure-treated southern yellow pine is the workhorse alternative. It is heavier, denser, and considerably cheaper per linear foot, and modern treatment methods give it decades of ground-contact-rated protection when properly installed. The catch is that treated pine arrives wet and will shrink, twist, and check as it dries, so buying extra and letting boards acclimate before installation pays off. Many buyers also note that treated pickets need to be sealed or stained after a drying period of several months if they want to avoid that silver-gray weathering.

Standard Sizes, Profiles, and Grades

Fence pickets are sold by nominal dimension, meaning a "1x6" is actually about 5/8 inch thick and 5-1/2 inches wide. The most common widths in stock are 1x4, 1x6, and occasionally 1x8, with 6-foot lengths dominating the rack for standard privacy fencing. You will also see 8-foot pickets for taller fences and shorter 4-foot or 5-foot options for garden borders, pet enclosures, and decorative runs. Thickness matters more than most shoppers realize: the 5/8-inch actual thickness of a nominal 1x board is what gives a picket its rigidity and wind resistance.

AD

Profile is the other variable. Dog-eared pickets with the rounded top corners remain the default for residential privacy fences because they soften the silhouette and reduce snagging. Flat-top and square-top pickets suit modern, geometric designs. Pointed or French Gothic tops show up on ranch and garden fencing, and scalloped or lattice-topped pickets appear in decorative applications. Grades typically run from #1 for clear, nearly knot-free stock down to #2 and utility grades that carry visible knots, wane, and occasional splits. Utility grade costs less, but expect to cull a higher percentage of boards and budget for more waste.

Picket Fences: Salvaged & Repurposed
Picket Fences: Salvaged & Repurposed
a row of wooden planters filled with flowers next to a green fence and brick building
a row of wooden planters filled with flowers next to a green fence and brick building
a diagram showing the different types of train tracks
a diagram showing the different types of train tracks
a wooden fence surrounded by lush green grass and flowers
a wooden fence surrounded by lush green grass and flowers
a vase filled with white flowers sitting on top of a wooden fence next to a shelf
a vase filled with white flowers sitting on top of a wooden fence next to a shelf
Picket art
Picket art

Matching Pickets to Your Project and Budget

The right picket is not simply the cheapest one on the rack or the one your neighbor used. Climate is a genuine factor. In West Texas and the Panhandle, relentless sun and dry wind cause wood to shrink and check faster, which favors cedar or a well-sealed treated pine. Along the Gulf Coast, humidity and termite pressure push buyers toward naturally resistant species or properly rated ground-contact treatment. In hail-prone regions, a thicker picket survives impact better and is less likely to shatter or split.

Budget should be measured over the life of the fence, not just the day of purchase. A cedar fence may cost forty to sixty percent more up front than treated pine, but it often requires less refinishing and holds its color longer with minimal attention. Treated pine is the better choice when you need maximum linear footage for a fixed dollar amount, when the fence will be painted, or when you are fencing acreage where appearance is secondary to function. Wind load, HOA rules, and local building codes can also narrow your options before cost ever enters the conversation.

AD

Cedar Versus Pressure-Treated Pine in Practice

Cedar shines on visible, high-traffic fences. A front-yard privacy fence built from cedar pickets on cedar rails and posts looks sharp immediately and ages into an attractive gray if left unfinished. It is also roughly thirty percent lighter than treated pine, which matters when you are hand-carrying hundreds of pickets down a fence line. Stain absorbs evenly, and because cedar has fewer pitch pockets, finishes do not blister the way they sometimes do on pine. For homeowners who plan to live with the fence for fifteen years or more and want low chemical input, cedar is usually the sensible answer.

two rows of white picket fences with the top one in black and the other in white
two rows of white picket fences with the top one in black and the other in white
Classic Wooden Picket Garden Fence
Classic Wooden Picket Garden Fence
15 Lovely Picket Fence Ideas
15 Lovely Picket Fence Ideas
The Pickety Fence
The Pickety Fence

Treated pine wins on volume and structural forgiveness. It takes nails and screws without pre-drilling, it resists impact well, and it is the standard choice for board-on-board privacy fences where pickets overlap and appearance is less critical. It is also the practical pick for agricultural and perimeter fencing where you may be installing thousands of linear feet. If you go this route, buy pickets from the same treatment batch when possible so color and shrinkage behave consistently, and plan on a penetrating oil stain rather than a film-forming paint, which can peel as the wood moves.

Picket Styles, Spacing, and Quantity Planning

Spacing determines both privacy and appearance, and it is where most do-it-yourself projects go wrong. A stockade fence butts pickets tightly with no gap, giving full privacy. A shadowbox design alternates pickets on both sides of the rails for equal privacy from either direction. Board-on-board overlaps pickets to eliminate see-through gaps entirely. Semi-privacy designs use consistent gaps, typically a quarter inch to two inches, which looks intentional and dramatically reduces material cost and wind load on the fence.

AD

Running the math is straightforward once you fix your spacing. For a six-foot-tall panel using 5-1/2-inch-wide pickets with a half-inch gap, each picket occupies six inches of linear run, so an eight-foot section needs sixteen pickets. Tight-butted installation at the same dimensions needs roughly eighteen per section to account for the actual width plus a small allowance for shrinkage. Add ten percent for cuts, culls, and damage. When you order from McCoy's, ask about bulk or contractor pricing on full units, and confirm whether the store can load pallets with a forklift so you are not hand-stacking five hundred boards in the parking lot.

Take a moment before you buy to measure twice, decide on spacing, and write down your total count with a waste allowance built in. McCoy's fence pickets are a solid, dependable choice for everything from a small backyard repair to a full property perimeter, and the staff at most locations know the local market well enough to steer you toward the right species and grade. Load up, let the wood acclimate if it is freshly treated, and set your posts with the same care you put into choosing the pickets. A fence built that way will still be standing square and holding its line long after the project stops being a weekend chore.

AD