halloween themed bars long island

Scariest Halloween-Themed Bars on Long Island

By James Johnson
AD

As the crisp autumn air sets in and the leaves begin to change color, Long Island transforms into a spooktacular playground for adults. Halloween-themed bars and pubs pop up across the island, offering a frightfully good time for locals and visitors alike. This guide will lead you through some of the most enchanting and chilling establishments, sure to make your Halloween season unforgettable.

Long Island, with its rich history and diverse communities, is home to a vast array of Halloween-inspired watering holes. From ferocious cocktails in Sayville to ghostly brews in Port Jefferson, these bars and pubs guarantee a spirited experience that's light on the wallet and heavy on the fun.

Haunted Taverns of the North Shore

The North Shore of Long Island, with its historic villages and beautiful coastline, provides a stunning backdrop for Halloween revelry.

AD
a man standing at a bar filled with wine glasses and pumpkins in front of him
a man standing at a bar filled with wine glasses and pumpkins in front of him
23 Spooky Halloween Room Decor Ideas for a Festive Glow
23 Spooky Halloween Room Decor Ideas for a Festive Glow
Discover a Stylish Halloween-Themed Real Wedding
Discover a Stylish Halloween-Themed Real Wedding

These northern haunts serve up more than just spirits, offering a mix of food, drinks, and entertainment that's sure to please even the most discerning zombie.

Crazy Halloween Nights in Port Jefferson

Each year, Port Jefferson's historic downtown area is converted into a block-party })) bershamble of ghouls, goblins, and ghosts. Establishments like Port Jeff Brewing Company and The Orient continue a longstanding tradition of hosting free outdoor Halloween concerts, complete with costume contests and pumpkin-carving stations.

a skeleton bartender is pouring some drinks into the glasses in front of neon colored lights
a skeleton bartender is pouring some drinks into the glasses in front of neon colored lights
a bar decorated for halloween with pumpkins and candles
a bar decorated for halloween with pumpkins and candles
people sitting at a bar with halloween decorations on the walls and lights hanging from the ceiling
people sitting at a bar with halloween decorations on the walls and lights hanging from the ceiling

Further down Main Street, you'll find the aptly named Tap Room, which transforms into a spooky den of debauchery. Their enormous selection of craft beers and cocktails ensures there's something for every palate, while their annual Halloween bash is not to be missed.

Bone-Chilling Brews in Huntington Station

In Huntington Station, Tap & Barrel Sports Bar & Restaurant is a favorite among locals for its expansive selection of craft beers on tap. Come Halloween, they roll out their spooky carpet and host a thrilling costume contest along with special ghoulish cocktails.

AD

Bonus: Alewife Brewing Company, a nearby craft brewery, often joins in the spooky fun with themed offerings like their talde Belgrade Imperial Stout and The Other Black IPA – perfect for raising a glass to the season.

the bar is decorated with red lights and decorations
the bar is decorated with red lights and decorations
Halloween bar
Halloween bar
@kcidydesign #ideogram
@kcidydesign #ideogram
a bar with skeletons hanging from the ceiling
a bar with skeletons hanging from the ceiling
Halloween themed restaurant
Halloween themed restaurant
Lucas - Spooky season is in full swing, island-style! 🎃🌴 Grab a seat, order up your favorite island cocktail, and enjoy the glow of pumpkin faces as the night settles in. Who’s ready for a Halloween sunset like this? 🧉🌅 #IslandHalloween #TikiTwilight #BeachBarVibes #SpookyParadise | Facebook
Lucas - Spooky season is in full swing, island-style! 🎃🌴 Grab a seat, order up your favorite island cocktail, and enjoy the glow of pumpkin faces as the night settles in. Who’s ready for a Halloween sunset like this? 🧉🌅 #IslandHalloween #TikiTwilight #BeachBarVibes #SpookyParadise | Facebook

Spooky Suds of the South Shore

The South Shore brings its own flavor of Halloween cheer, with lots of parties, dressed-up drinks, and frightfully creative decor.

Take a trip down Long Island's southern coast, and you'll discover a treasure trove of bars eager to indulge your eerie cravings.

AD

Frightful Cocktails in Sayville

Hush Comb Bar & Restaurant in Sayville is known for its frightfully ferocious cocktails. Sample their seasonal menu, complete with potions like the Graveyard Smash and Hex on the Beach, while enjoying the ambiance of their velvet-draped, candlelit lounge.

Halloween Bar Decor Ideas: 7 Spooky Ways to Create a Frighteningly Fun Atmosphere - DesignerAffair
Halloween Bar Decor Ideas: 7 Spooky Ways to Create a Frighteningly Fun Atmosphere - DesignerAffair

Every Halloween, they throw a costume bash that's talked about for months afterward, with live music, dancing, and a frightfully fun atmosphere.

Ghostly Gatherings in Bay Shore

Bay Shore's shipwrecked-themed Oar Steak & Seafood Grill is a perennial favorite among Halloween revelers. They pour creative cocktails fit for sea monsters and ghouls year-round, but the fun really ramps up come October.

AD

Keep an eye out for their seasonal events, like zombie crawls and candy-apple tastings. And don't miss their annual Halloween party, where inhibitions go from zero to sixty in a hurry.

Whichever haunted watering hole you choose, raise a glass and celebrate this frightfully delightful season on Long Island. Happy Halloween!

AD