gators hail mary

Gators Hail Mary: Florida's 63-Yard Miracle vs Tennessee

By Anthony Garcia
AD

The phrase "Gators Hail Mary" instantly conjures one specific image for college football fans: a tall quarterback rolling to his right, a football arcing through the humid Gainesville night, and a receiver in orange and blue rising above a crowd of defenders in the end zone. That single snap on September 16, 2017, transformed a grinding, mistake-filled game into one of the most replayed finishes in Florida football history and handed the Tennessee Volunteers yet another gut-punch in a rivalry full of them.

Yet the play fans call the "Heave to Cleve" is far more than a lucky bounce. It is a snapshot of rivalry tension, of a program searching for an identity, and of the strange physics and psychology that make a Hail Mary work at all. Digging into what actually happened that night — the players, the circumstances, the design, and the aftermath — reveals why one 63-yard throw still carries so much weight in Gainesville.

September 16, 2017: The Night the Swamp Erupted

Ben Hill Griffin Stadium has hosted plenty of dramatic finishes, but few arrived with the emotional backdrop of this one. Hurricane Irma had torn through Florida just days earlier, forcing the cancellation of the Gators' scheduled home opener and leaving much of the state without power. The Tennessee game became the team's first true home appearance of the season, and the crowd arrived carrying more than the usual rivalry adrenaline.

AD
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary

What made the moment sharper was the context of the season itself. Florida would finish 2017 with a 4-7 record, one of the worst campaigns in modern program history, and head coach Jim McElwain would be dismissed before the year ended. Against that backdrop, the Hail Mary against Tennessee stands as the brightest flash of an otherwise grim autumn — a reminder of how quickly a single play can define a season's memory.

How the Final Drive Unfolded

The game had been a slog of penalties, stalled drives, and missed opportunities on both sides. Tennessee grabbed a fourth-quarter lead, and Florida answered with a field goal to pull even, leaving the outcome hanging on one final possession. When the Volunteers' punt team jogged onto the field, the Gators took over deep in their own territory with only a handful of seconds remaining and no timeouts to burn.

gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary

Feleipe Franks took the snap, felt pressure collapsing the pocket, and escaped to his right. Rather than stepping out of bounds or throwing the ball away, he planted and launched a pass nearly 63 yards downfield. Tyrie Cleveland had drifted into the end zone behind the Tennessee secondary, and he adjusted to the ball, hauled it in, and landed with it pinned to his chest as the clock hit zero. Final score: Florida 26, Tennessee 20.

Franks, Cleveland, and the Names Behind the Heave

Feleipe Franks was a redshirt freshman in 2017, a former four-star recruit with a cannon for an arm and a habit of making both spectacular and baffling decisions. His career in Gainesville would ultimately be a roller coaster, ending with a transfer to Arkansas, but the Hail Mary against Tennessee crystallized exactly why coaches kept believing in him. The arm talent needed to throw a football that far, that accurately, under duress is not something that can be taught.

AD

Tyrie Cleveland was the other half of the equation — a sophomore from Houston with track speed and a knack for winning contested catches. His job on the play was the hardest one: track a ball thrown from nearly 60 yards away, locate it against the lights, and outmuscle defenders who had every incentive to knock it down. He did all three, and the image of him emerging from that pile with the ball became the defining photograph of his college career.

gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary

Why One Play Still Echoes Through Gators Football

College football is a sport built on moments, and few programs have as rich a catalog of them as Florida. Still, the 2017 Hail Mary occupies a peculiar place in that catalog. It did not win a championship, it did not cap an undefeated season, and it came during a year the Gators would rather forget. What it did was deliver the purest possible emotional payoff to a fan base that had spent the week cleaning up after a hurricane.

The play also produced its own nickname, "Heave to Cleve," which spread quickly across message boards and social media. Nicknames matter in this sport because they signal that a play has crossed from highlight into folklore. Once a fan base names a moment, it stops being a footnote in a box score and becomes part of the program's shared vocabulary, replayed every September when the Volunteers come to town.

AD

Rivalry Context: Florida vs. Tennessee

The Florida-Tennessee series has never been short on heartbreak, and most of it has landed on the Volunteers' side of the ledger. From Steve Spurrier's dominance in the 1990s through long winning streaks in the 2000s, the Gators built a reputation for finding ways to win this specific game in the most painful manner imaginable. The 2017 finish fit that pattern so perfectly that Tennessee fans could only laugh, groan, and turn off the television.

gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary
gators hail mary

Consider the 2015 meeting as the closest cousin to the Heave to Cleve. Trailing late, Florida faced fourth-and-14 and converted on a 63-yard touchdown pass from Will Grier to Antonio Callaway with just over a minute left, stealing a 28-27 win. Two absurd late daggers, both covering 63 yards, both against the same opponent — that is not a coincidence so much as a tradition at this point.

The Anatomy of a Hail Mary

A successful Hail Mary requires more than a strong arm. The offensive line has to hold up just long enough, the quarterback has to buy time without drifting so far that the throw becomes impossible, and the receivers have to run disciplined vertical routes that create a crowd at the catch point. Coaches often instruct receivers to tip the ball backward or sideways if they cannot catch it cleanly, turning chaos into a second chance.

AD

On the 2017 play, Franks's scramble bought the extra half-second that made the throw possible, and Cleveland's route kept him behind the deepest defenders. The ball traveled roughly 63 yards from the line of scrimmage, which is a genuinely rare throw at any level of the sport. Most Hail Mary attempts fall incomplete or get intercepted; the ones that connect require arm strength, timing, and a receiver willing to absorb a hit.

The Gators' Hail Mary in the Broader History of Desperation Passes

Desperation passes have been part of football since the forward pass was legalized, but only a handful have become permanently embedded in the sport's collective memory. Doug Flutie's 1984 heave for Boston College against Miami turned a small Catholic school's quarterback into a Heisman winner. Kordell Stewart's 1994 bomb for Colorado at Michigan became the "Miracle at Michigan." In 2015, Aaron Rodgers escaped a collapsing pocket and found Richard Rodgers in the end zone in Detroit for another instant classic.

More recently, the 2024 NFL season delivered the "Madhouse in Maryland," a last-second deflection caught in the end zone that reminded everyone how unpredictable these plays remain. The Gators' version belongs in that conversation, not because it decided a title but because of the circumstances surrounding it and the sheer improbability of the throw. It is the kind of play that gets replayed on the jumbotron during a rain delay twenty years later.

Other Late-Game Gators Heroics Worth Remembering

Florida's history with the late dagger extends well beyond a single night in 2017. The 2015 fourth-and-14 conversion against Tennessee remains arguably the more improbable play from a situational standpoint, since the Gators needed a first down just to keep the drive alive and instead got a touchdown. That game swung the entire trajectory of a season that ended in the SEC Championship Game.

Earlier eras produced their own versions of the same drama. Florida's rivalry games against Florida State and Georgia have generated tipped passes, blocked kicks, and fourth-quarter comebacks that older fans still argue about at tailgates. The common thread is a program that has rarely gone quietly, even in seasons where the final record suggested otherwise.

How Modern Hail Marys Have Evolved

Coaches now practice the Hail Mary as a defined situational package rather than an improvised prayer. Offenses will often align three or four receivers in a tight cluster to create traffic, and analytics departments have convinced some staffs to attempt the throw in situations where older coaches would have simply taken a knee. Rule changes favoring receivers on contested catches have also tilted the odds slightly toward the offense.

That evolution makes plays like the Heave to Cleve easier to appreciate in hindsight. Franks was not executing a carefully choreographed design so much as surviving a broken pocket and trusting his arm. Modern schemes try to engineer the chaos; in 2017, the chaos engineered itself, and a redshirt freshman and a sophomore from Texas happened to be standing in exactly the right place when it did.

Every September, when Tennessee appears on the schedule, the clip resurfaces — the scramble, the launch, the catch, the silent stadium in Knoxville the following morning. That is the quiet power of a play like this one: it does not need a trophy attached to it to keep living. As long as there are seconds ticking down and a receiver willing to go up and get it, Gainesville will keep believing the ball has a chance to land in orange and blue.

AD