Favorite Piqua Ware 9: Why This Vintage Cast Iron Is a Collectors Dream
If you have spent any time hunting vintage cast iron, the phrase Favorite Piqua Ware 9 probably brings to mind a specific kind of treasure: an American-made skillet with a smooth cooking surface, graceful curves, and a history that stretches back to early twentieth-century Ohio. The No. 9 size is especially beloved because it hits a sweet spot between a small daily egg pan and a heavy family-sized skillet. It is large enough for searing chops, frying chicken, and baking cornbread, yet still manageable for most cooks.
That blend of practicality and old-school character is why the Favorite Piqua Ware 9 remains a sought-after piece among collectors and everyday cooks alike. This guide walks through what makes the pan distinctive, how to identify a genuine example, what to inspect before buying, and how to bring a tired skillet back to useful life without damaging its legacy.
Why the Favorite Piqua Ware No. 9 Stands Out
The Favorite Piqua Ware No. 9 occupies a special place in the vintage cast iron world because it was produced by the Favorite Stove & Range Company of Piqua, Ohio, a manufacturer better known for stoves but equally capable of turning out excellent hollowware. Pieces from this line were made during the early decades of the 1900s, and they carry the visual hallmarks of an era when foundries took pride in clean casting and hand-finished cooking surfaces.
Size 9 skillets are often described as the Goldilocks pan of vintage iron. They are wider than a No. 8 but not as unwieldy as a No. 10, which makes them flexible for everyday cooking. In a Favorite Piqua Ware 9, that versatility is paired with a relatively light feel and a cooking surface that can become glassy with proper seasoning.
A Short History of Favorite Piqua Ware
Favorite Stove & Range Company operated in Piqua, Ohio, and its cast iron cookware line became known as Favorite Piqua Ware. The brand is generally associated with the 1910s through the 1930s, a period when American foundries were competing to produce durable, attractive cookware for home kitchens. The name itself signals both the company and the town, which helps collectors separate it from other “Favorite” brands and generic Piqua-marked iron.
Because production ended many decades ago, every Favorite Piqua Ware 9 is a finite piece of history. The foundry era that produced it relied on pattern makers, molders, grinders, and polishers, and the subtle variations between examples reflect that human process. That is part of the reason two skillets of the same size can feel slightly different in weight, handle shape, or surface texture.
Design Details That Matter
Most Favorite Piqua Ware skillets feature a heat ring on the bottom, a raised rim that helps the pan sit securely on a stove eye and can improve stability on modern gas grates. The cooking surface is typically smooth rather than pebbled, and the sidewalls curve gently up to pour spouts that are useful without being oversized. The handle often has a comfortable, slightly arched profile with a teardrop or eye-shaped opening.
These details are not just cosmetic. A heat ring can affect how the pan transfers heat, especially on gas and induction, while a smooth interior encourages a durable layer of seasoning. The pour spouts make it easier to drain fat or pan sauce, and the handle shape matters when you are lifting a hot skillet with a towel or leather mitt. Together, they make the Favorite Piqua Ware 9 a thoughtfully designed tool rather than a decorative antique.
Buying, Restoring, and Using a Favorite Piqua Ware 9
Finding a Favorite Piqua Ware 9 can be exciting, but the buying process rewards patience and a sharp eye. These skillets show up at estate sales, antique malls, farm auctions, and online marketplaces, often covered in rust or decades of carbon. The best candidates are not necessarily the prettiest; they are the ones with sound metal, minimal pitting, and no cracks or repairs.
Before you commit, decide whether you want a collector-grade piece with crisp markings or a user-grade skillet that you can cook on without worry. Both have value. A pristine Favorite Piqua Ware 9 may belong on a display shelf, while a well-worn example with a slightly faded logo can become the most useful pan in your kitchen.
Identifying Authentic Pieces and Assessing Value
Authentic Favorite Piqua Ware pieces usually carry raised lettering on the bottom, often reading “FAVORITE PIQUA WARE” along with a size number. You may also see pattern numbers, molder marks, or a small gate mark on older examples. The No. 9 should have a corresponding size indication, and the overall casting should look clean rather than crude or overly thick. Beware of pans with fuzzy lettering, suspicious grinding, or markings that do not match known Favorite Piqua Ware patterns.
Value depends on condition, rarity, and desirability. Cracks, warping, deep pitting, and heavy grinding reduce value significantly, while a flat bottom, intact heat ring, clear markings, and a smooth cooking surface push it higher. A Favorite Piqua Ware 9 in excellent original condition can command a strong price among collectors, but a restore-and-use example is often a better deal for someone who actually plans to cook.
Cleaning, Seasoning, and Day-to-Day Cooking
Restoring a vintage skillet should be gentle. For heavy carbon, a lye bath or electrolysis setup is the safest way to strip the pan without harming the iron. Short vinegar soaks can help with rust, but the pan should be neutralized with baking soda and water afterward. Avoid sandblasting, wire wheels on power drills, and aggressive sandpaper, because these can erase the original surface and reduce the pan’s value.
Once the iron is bare, season it with a thin layer of a high-smoke-point oil such as grapeseed, canola, or flaxseed, then bake it according to a reliable method. Repeat the process a few times before cooking acidic foods. The Favorite Piqua Ware 9 will handle bacon, cornbread, roasted chicken, sautéed vegetables, and pan-seared steak beautifully once the seasoning builds. After each use, clean it with warm water and a stiff brush, dry it thoroughly, and apply a whisper-thin oil layer to protect the surface.
If you spot a Favorite Piqua Ware 9 with a straight bottom and no cracks, it is worth a closer look even if the seasoning is ugly. These pans were built to be used, and the best ones often reveal their quality only after a good cleaning and a few honest meals. Whether you keep it as a collectible or make it your go-to skillet, a well-cared-for Favorite Piqua Ware 9 can serve another generation of cooks who appreciate iron with a story.