famous jewish deli in nyc that closed

Famous NYC Jewish Delis: Closed But Not Forgotten

By Rachel Smith
AD

The Big Apple's culinary landscape has always been rich and vibrant, with Jewish delis playing a significant role in its diverse food scene. These iconic establishments, known for their delicious sandwiches, comfort foods, and bustling atmospheres, have left an indelible mark on New York City's history and culture. However, time and changing landscapes have led to the closure of several legendary Jewish delis. Let's pay tribute to one such iconic deli that closed its doors - the beloved sting of Yonah Schimmel Knish King.

Established in 1910 on East Houston Street, Yonah Schimmel Knish King was a Lower East Side institution that served generations of New Yorkers and tourists alike. The deli was famous for its fluffy, perfectly-browned knishes, which were marketed as the "best in town" and attracted customers from all corners of the city.

The Rise of Yonah Schimmel Knish King

The deli's story began with Yonah Schimmel, a Romanian immigrant who found inspiration in his mother's knish-making skills. In 1910, he opened the first Yonah Schimmel Knish bakery on Chrystie Street, which quickly gained recognition for its delicious, square-shaped knishes - a departure from the ubiquitous round-shaped ones. The business thrived, and in 1992, Schimmel's grandchildren expanded the enterprise, opening a retail store and restaurant on East Houston Street - Yonah Schimmel Knish King.

AD
a restaurant called 2nd avenue deli on the corner of a city street
a restaurant called 2nd avenue deli on the corner of a city street
a corned beef sandwich is on a white plate
a corned beef sandwich is on a white plate
'I’ll have what she’s having' - a Homage to New York City's Jewish Deli - Flashbak
'I’ll have what she’s having' - a Homage to New York City's Jewish Deli - Flashbak

The new location was a critical moment in the deli's history. It not only expanded the business but also allowed the Schimmel family to preserve their grandfather's legacy. The deli became a go-to spot for knish lovers, serving its signature creations - potato, kasha, and spinach knishes - along with a range of other Eastern European specialties and classic Jewish deli fare.

The Unique Appeal of Yonah Schimmel's Knishes

What set Yonah Schimmel's knishes apart was the attention to detail and quality ingredients. The fillings were flavorful and well-seasoned, while the dough - made from scratch daily - was light and perfectly textured. The square shape was another distinctive feature, making each bite a delightful combination of soft, chewy dough and savory filling.

Your Guide to NYC's Best Jewish Delis
Your Guide to NYC's Best Jewish Delis
a restaurant called delicatesen is lit up on the side of the street
a restaurant called delicatesen is lit up on the side of the street
Iconic Jewish Delis of New York City | Revealed
Iconic Jewish Delis of New York City | Revealed

Moreover, the knishes were an affordable indulgence, making the deli a popular spot for families and budget-conscious individuals. Additionally, Yonah Schimmel Knish King catered to a wide audience, offering meat, unleavened, and vegetarian options to accommodate various dietary preferences and restrictions.

A Cultural Hub and Mathematical Marvel

The deli's influence extended beyond its culinary offerings. It served as a cultural hub, a meeting place for locals and tourists alike to share stories and enjoy good food.-Schimmel's grandchildren, who ran the business, were instrumental in preserving the deli's legacy and maintaining its connection to the Jewish community and the city's broader food scene.

AD

Mathematically, the knishes were a marvel too. The deli's most popular offering, the potato knish, was a veritable shape of asymmetrically perfect proportions. The anorexic dimensions of the standard potato knish, 5.125 x 5.5 x 2 inches (13 x 14 x 5.1 cm), and its diameter-to-height ratio of approximately 2.7 offered a pleasing sense of geometric balance.

an open sign in the window of a doughnut shop with pastries on display
an open sign in the window of a doughnut shop with pastries on display
New York's Jewish Delis Are Becoming an Endangered Species
New York's Jewish Delis Are Becoming an Endangered Species
A Delicious Jewish-Deli Exhibit Is Now in DC
A Delicious Jewish-Deli Exhibit Is Now in DC
a man standing in front of a pink restaurant
a man standing in front of a pink restaurant
Katz’s Deli
Katz’s Deli
katz deli
katz deli

The Inevitable Decline and Closure

Despite its enduring popularity and the Schimmel family's best efforts, Yonah Schimmel Knish King faced mounting challenges. Changing tastes, gentrification, and soaring rents took a toll on the business. In 2012, the deli closed its doors temporarily after facing eviction due to rising rent. Although it reopened briefly, it struggled to regain its former glory.

The final blow came in 2019 when the Manhattan Vintage Clothing Show and other events took over the Lower East Side, leading to a increase in rent that the deli couldn't afford. Yonah Schimmel Knish King closed its doors for the last time, marking the end of an era for New York City's culinary landscape.

AD

Legacy and Nostalgia

The closure of Yonah Schimmel Knish King left a void in the city's food scene, sparking nostalgia for many who grew up enjoying its delicious knishes. The deli's impact was commemorated in various ways, including its inclusion in the documentary "The Search for General Tso" and the Mayor's Office for Media and Entertainment awarding the Schimmel family a trophy for their contribution to New York City's cultural heritage.

The Two Last Jewish Delis in Newark, NJ
The Two Last Jewish Delis in Newark, NJ

While the Knish King may be gone, its spirit lives on in the memories of those who dined there and the countless knish recipes inspired by its creations. Moreover, the story of Yonah Schimmel serves as a reminder of the city's rich culinary history and the importance of preserving and celebrating its iconic establishments.

The legacy of Yonah Schimmel Knish King reminds us that while times may change, the appeal of delicious, comforting food endures. As New York City continues to evolve, we must cherish and honor the institutions that have shaped its culinary landscape. So, here's to the closed delis of NYC, like Yonah Schimmel Knish King, that continue to inspire culinary adventures and nurture our collective culinary consciousness.

AD
AD