fake shake shingles

Fake Shake Shingles: The Ultimate Guide to Synthetic Shake Roofing

By Emily Allen
AD

Fake shake shingles are manufactured roofing materials that imitate the look of traditional cedar shakes without the wood’s maintenance demands. They are often called synthetic shake shingles, faux cedar shake roofing, or composite shake roofing. The appeal is simple: you get the texture, shadow lines, and curb appeal of a hand-split wood roof, but with modern materials engineered for weather, fire, and pests.

That said, “fake” does not mean cheap or flimsy. Today’s best fake shake shingles use polyurethane, engineered polymer, fiber cement, or coated metal to replicate cedar’s grain and profile. The category spans budget-friendly asphalt lookalikes and premium synthetic shakes that can cost as much as real cedar. Understanding the differences helps you choose a roof that fits your climate, HOA rules, and long-term budget.

What Are Fake Shake Shingles?

Fake shake shingles are roof coverings designed to mimic the irregular, thick, wood-split appearance of cedar shakes. Traditional cedar shakes are cut from natural wood, which means they can rot, crack, warp, and require periodic staining or sealing. Synthetic versions replace that organic material with engineered compounds that are molded, pressed, or stamped into shake-like shapes.

AD
Synthetic Cedar Shake Tiles | Faux Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles
Synthetic Cedar Shake Tiles | Faux Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles
Consider These 5 Rustic Siding Ideas to Make Your Home Stand Out
Consider These 5 Rustic Siding Ideas to Make Your Home Stand Out
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes

Some products are true synthetic shakes, while others are asphalt shingles, fiber cement shakes, or metal panels styled to look like wood. The term “fake shake shingles” covers all of them, but performance varies dramatically by material. A polyurethane shake from a premium brand behaves very differently from a laminated asphalt shingle with a shake pattern.

Synthetic Polymer and Composite Shakes

Synthetic polymer and composite shakes are the closest thing to realistic fake cedar on the market. Manufacturers often create molds from actual cedar shakes, then cast polyurethane or composite resin into those molds to capture deep grain, knots, and split edges. Many include UV inhibitors, fire retardants, and impact modifiers, so they resist fading, cracking, and hail better than real wood.

an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
Fire-Resistant Synthetic Cedar Wood Shakes | Live Oak
Fire-Resistant Synthetic Cedar Wood Shakes | Live Oak
Composite Roof Shingles Roofscapess Enhances Bellaforté Shake Offering w/ Nature Crafted Collection
Composite Roof Shingles Roofscapess Enhances Bellaforté Shake Offering w/ Nature Crafted Collection

Brands such as DaVinci Roofscapes, Brava Roof Tile, and Enviroshake are commonly cited in this category. These products typically carry long warranties, sometimes 50 years or more, and can be installed on roofs with slopes as low as 3:12 when paired with the right underlayment. They are also popular in wildfire-prone areas because many achieve Class A fire ratings and can earn insurance discounts.

Fiber Cement, Asphalt, and Metal Shake Alternatives

Fiber cement shakes blend cement, sand, and cellulose to create a heavy, dimensionally stable shake look. They are noncombustible, resistant to rot and insects, and often finished with factory-applied color. Asphalt shake-style shingles use laminated tabs and shadow lines to suggest wood shakes at a lower price point. Metal shake panels are stamped steel or aluminum with a wood-grain finish, offering lightweight durability and excellent fire resistance.

AD

Each option has trade-offs. Fiber cement is heavy and can chip if walked on incorrectly. Asphalt shake lookalikes are affordable but less convincing up close. Metal shake can dent and may be noisy in heavy rain without solid sheathing and insulation. The right choice depends on whether you prioritize realism, fire rating, weight, or upfront cost.

Gallery | F Wave Synthetic Shingles | Slate & Shake
Gallery | F Wave Synthetic Shingles | Slate & Shake
How to create dollhouse shingles in 6 different ways!
How to create dollhouse shingles in 6 different ways!
Multi-Width Composite Slate Roof Tile | Timeless Slate Look
Multi-Width Composite Slate Roof Tile | Timeless Slate Look
a black and white photo of a roof
a black and white photo of a roof
Hand-Split Composite Shake Siding
Hand-Split Composite Shake Siding
All the Details on Our New Composite Shake Roof!
All the Details on Our New Composite Shake Roof!

Benefits and Trade-Offs of Fake Shake Shingles

The biggest benefits of fake shake shingles are low maintenance and long service life. Unlike real cedar, synthetic shakes do not need staining, sealing, or treatment for rot and insects. They resist moisture, salt air, and freeze-thaw cycles, and most premium products hold their color far longer than wood. For homeowners tired of sweeping up cedar debris or paying for periodic roof treatments, that alone can justify the investment.

The trade-offs usually come down to cost, installation, and repair. Quality synthetic shake shingles can cost two to four times more than standard asphalt shingles, and not every roofer has experience with them. Improper installation can void the warranty, lead to wind uplift, or create leak points. Some products also have limited profiles, so they may not match every architectural style.

AD

Performance in Weather and Fire

Weather performance is where premium fake shake shingles shine. Many synthetic shakes are tested for high wind, hail impact, and freeze-thaw resistance. Some carry Class 4 impact ratings, the highest available, and Class A fire ratings. In coastal areas, they resist salt corrosion better than metal in some cases and far better than untreated cedar. In wildfire zones, noncombustible fiber cement and metal shakes are often chosen for their ember resistance.

CEDUR Roofing Gallery | Real Projects, Lasting Beauty & Protection
CEDUR Roofing Gallery | Real Projects, Lasting Beauty & Protection
a man is painting the side of a building with shingle siding and window trimming
a man is painting the side of a building with shingle siding and window trimming

Maintenance is minimal but not zero. A gentle rinse with a garden hose removes dirt and pollen, and occasional inspections keep flashing and fasteners in good shape. Avoid pressure washing, which can force water behind the shakes or strip finishes. In hail-prone regions, composite and polymer shakes tend to outperform asphalt and fiber cement, though no roof is invincible against extreme weather.

Cost, Installation, and ROI

Cost varies widely by material and region. Asphalt shake-style shingles might run $150 to $300 per square installed, while fiber cement shakes often land between $400 and $800 per square. Synthetic polymer and composite shakes frequently fall between $500 and $1,000 per square, and premium products can exceed that. Real cedar shakes can cost $600 to $1,500 per square or more, so the gap between fake and real is not always as large as homeowners expect.

AD

Installation matters just as much as the product. Synthetic shakes usually require manufacturer-approved underlayment, fasteners, and flashing details, and some brands require certified installers to validate the warranty. The return on investment comes from curb appeal, durability, and potential insurance savings. A roof that looks like cedar but avoids staining, rot, and insect damage can be a strong selling point when you eventually list your home.

If you’re considering fake shake shingles, start by ordering physical samples and comparing them against your home’s siding, trim, and stone. Ask contractors for manufacturer certifications, written estimates that include tear-off and underlayment, and references from roofs installed at least five years ago. The right synthetic shake roof can deliver the cedar look you want with fewer long-term headaches—provided you choose the material that matches your climate and installation team.

AD