EW Review Hummingbird Project: Is It Worth the Hype?
The EW review of The Hummingbird Project has become a reliable reference point for anyone deciding whether Kim Nguyen's 2018 financial thriller is worth their evening. Entertainment Weekly's assessment of the film balanced genuine admiration for its ambition against a fair amount of skepticism about its execution, and that push-and-pull is exactly why the review still circulates years after the movie's festival debut. If you're hunting for a straight answer about what that review actually said, what the film gets right, and where it stumbles, this breakdown covers the ground.
The Hummingbird Project sits in an unusual space: it's a movie about high-frequency trading that spends almost no time in a trading floor, and a movie about obsession that never turns into a conventional thriller. That strangeness is both its selling point and the reason critics split on it. Understanding how EW's reviewer weighed those competing strengths and weaknesses tells you a lot about whether the film matches your taste before you hit play.
What The Hummingbird Project Is Actually About
At its core, the film follows two cousins from the world of high-frequency trading who hatch a scheme that sounds absurd until you realize someone has probably tried it in real life. Vincent Zalesky, played by Jesse Eisenberg, is the salesman with the pitch and the appetite for risk. His cousin Anton, played by Alexander Skarsgård in a remarkable physical transformation, is the technical genius who actually has to build the thing.
Their plan is to construct a perfectly straight fiber optic line from Kansas to New Jersey so their trading data can travel a few milliseconds faster than the competition's. That margin, measured in fractions of a second, translates into hundreds of millions of dollars in a market where being first isn't a metaphor, it's math. The premise sounds like a heist movie, but Nguyen directs it more like a character study about people who have convinced themselves that a millisecond is worth everything they own.
The Plot Mechanics Without the Jargon
You don't need a finance degree to follow the film, and that's one of its real strengths. The screenplay by Kim Nguyen keeps the technical exposition light, focusing instead on the human cost of drilling through bedrock, buying up farmland, and negotiating with skeptical landowners who don't care about latency. The mechanics of the trade stay in the background so the relationships can stay in the foreground.
What complicates the story is Eva Torres, the cousins' former boss, played by Salma Hayek with a sharp, almost predatory energy. She represents the corporate machine they're trying to outrun, and she's not content to let two former employees walk away with an idea that could gut her firm's advantage. The result is a three-way pressure cooker where nobody is entirely a hero and nobody is a clean villain.
Cast and Performances
Alexander Skarsgård's turn as Anton is the performance most critics singled out, and for good reason. He disappears into the role, adopting a bald cap, a stoop, and a nervous intensity that reads as genuinely unwell rather than merely eccentric. It's the kind of transformation that could have tipped into caricature, but the actor keeps it grounded in a specific kind of obsessive intelligence.
Jesse Eisenberg plays a variation on the fast-talking, high-anxiety persona he's known for, though Vincent has more swagger and more desperation than some of his earlier roles. Hayek's Eva brings a welcome jolt of menace whenever the film risks drifting into procedural territory. Together, the three performances give the movie a nervous energy that carries it through some of its slower stretches.
What the EW Review Emphasized
Entertainment Weekly's write-up landed in a familiar place for a film like this: appreciative of the craft, charmed by the oddball tone, and unconvinced that the whole thing holds together from start to finish. The review treated the premise as genuinely intriguing rather than gimmicky, which matters because plenty of financial dramas get dismissed as dry exercises in explaining markets to people who don't care about them.
What the review also did, and what makes it useful to readers, was separate the film's ideas from its momentum. There's a real difference between a movie that has something interesting to say and a movie that says it in a compelling way for two hours. The EW take acknowledged that gap honestly rather than pretending it didn't exist.
Praise for the Film's Ambition and Tone
Reviewers at EW noted that the film refuses the easy route of becoming a straightforward corporate satire. Nguyen isn't interested in lecturing the audience about the evils of high-frequency trading, even though the subject practically invites it. Instead, he treats the scheme as a kind of quixotic quest, and the movie's willingness to take its characters' delusions seriously is part of what elevates it above standard genre fare.
There's also a strain of deadpan humor running through the script that keeps the tone from becoming oppressive. The film understands that drilling a tunnel across several states to shave off a millisecond is, on some level, ridiculous, and it lets the audience in on that joke without winking so hard that the drama collapses. That balance earned the movie real credit with critics who expected something drier.
Criticisms Around Pacing and Third-Act Payoff
The most common complaint, echoed in EW's assessment, involves the film's rhythm. The middle section, where the crew negotiates with landowners and battles logistical nightmares, can feel repetitive. For viewers who expected the tension to escalate steadily toward a climactic confrontation, the film's preference for quiet, character-driven scenes may read as a lack of urgency.
There's also the question of payoff. Without spoiling anything, the ending refuses the catharsis a standard Hollywood structure would deliver. Some critics read that as integrity; others read it as anticlimactic. EW's review sat somewhere in between, respecting the choice while acknowledging that it leaves part of the audience cold. Where you land on that probably depends on whether you watch movies for resolution or for the ride.
How the Film Has Held Up Since Its Release
The Hummingbird Project premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in 2018 before reaching wider audiences the following year. In the years since, it has settled into a comfortable niche as a cult-adjacent title, the kind of movie people discover on a streaming service and then recommend to exactly one friend who shares their taste for slow-burn character studies dressed up as thrillers.
Part of its staying power comes from how the subject matter has only become more relevant. Latency arbitrage, algorithmic trading, and the physical infrastructure that underpins digital markets have all become more visible in public conversation. A film that once seemed like an eccentric curiosity now reads a little more like a docudrama with a strange sense of humor.
Reception Beyond Entertainment Weekly
Other outlets were similarly divided. Some praised the performances and the screenplay's refusal to moralize, while others found the stakes too abstract to generate real tension. The film currently sits in middling territory on aggregate review sites, which is probably fair: it's neither the overlooked masterpiece some viewers claim nor the misfire its harshest critics describe.
Audience reactions tend to split along the same lines as the professional reviews. Viewers who connect with the characters' obsessive drive often describe the movie as quietly devastating. Viewers who came in expecting a fast-paced Wall Street drama often describe it as slow and underwhelming. Both reactions are honest responses to the same film, which says something about how specific its appeal really is.
Where to Watch and Who Should Bother
The film has cycled through various streaming platforms and remains available for digital rental in most regions. If you're the type who enjoys movies like The Big Short for its energy but want something more melancholy and less explainer-heavy, this is a reasonable next stop. If you need constant forward motion and a tidy ending, temper your expectations before pressing play.
It's also worth watching for Skarsgård alone. His performance is the kind of committed, unglamorous work that doesn't usually get awards attention but lingers in your memory longer than flashier turns from the same year. Even viewers who find the pacing frustrating tend to concede that he's doing something special.
Give it a shot on a night when you're in the mood for something patient and slightly odd, and you may find that the EW review's measured ambivalence was pointing you toward exactly the right kind of audience. The film isn't trying to win everyone over, and that stubbornness is arguably the most interesting thing about it.