does removing master bathtub hurt resale

Does Removing Master Bathtub Harm Home Resale?

By James Thompson
AD

When it comes to home improvements, many homeowners wonder, "Does removing a master bathtub hurt resale?" The truth is, it depends on several factors, including your home's current market value, the local real estate trends, and the costs associated with replacing or updating the bathtub. Let's explore this topic in detail to help you make an informed decision.

Homeowners often consider removing a master bathtub to create a more spacious and luxurious en-suite bathroom. However, before you pick up that sledgehammer, it's essential to understand how this change might impact your home's resale value. This article aims to provide guidance on whether removing a master bathtub hurts resale, along with some useful insights to help you maximize your property's value.

Understanding Your Home's Current Value

Before making any significant changes to your bathroom, it's crucial to understand your home's current worth in the market. Conduct a comparative market analysis (CMA) to learn how much similar homes in your area are selling for. This will give you a good idea of what buyers expect and help you determine if removing a master bathtub hurts resale potential.

AD
Will Removing a Bathtub Hurt Home Value? (2026 Seattle Guide)
Will Removing a Bathtub Hurt Home Value? (2026 Seattle Guide)
Replacing That Large Tub Nobody Uses Anymore | SCD: Construction & Interior Designer for Mt Juliet, Lebanon, Wilson Co, TN
Replacing That Large Tub Nobody Uses Anymore | SCD: Construction & Interior Designer for Mt Juliet, Lebanon, Wilson Co, TN
13 Common Bathtub Remodeling Mistakes, Tub Problems – Innovate Building Solutions - Innovate Building Solutions Blog - Home Remodeling, Design Ideas & Advice
13 Common Bathtub Remodeling Mistakes, Tub Problems – Innovate Building Solutions - Innovate Building Solutions Blog - Home Remodeling, Design Ideas & Advice

Hire a professional appraiser or contact a local real estate agent to assist you in this process. They can provide valuable insights into the local real estate market and help you evaluate the potential impact of removing a bathtub on your home's resale value.

Considering Local Real Estate Trends

Real estate trends can significantly influence the perception of your home's value. In some neighborhoods, a modern, walk-in shower might be more desirable than a traditional bathtub. Research local trends and consult with a real estate expert to determine if removing a master bathtub would be beneficial in your specific area.

a man working on a shower wall in a bathroom that is being remodeled and remodeled
a man working on a shower wall in a bathroom that is being remodeled and remodeled
How to Remove a Bathtub | dummies
How to Remove a Bathtub | dummies
Removing a Tub? It May Not Require a Full Remodel
Removing a Tub? It May Not Require a Full Remodel

On the other hand, if bathtubs are highly desired in your neighborhood (for example, in a community with many families), removing them could potentially decrease your home's appeal to a larger pool of buyers. Consider these factors before making a decision that could negatively impact resale value.

Balance Functional Space and Aesthetics

Although some homeowners may prefer a sleek, modern shower, others might appreciate the functionality of a bathtub. When deciding whether to remove a master bathtub, consider the trade-offs in terms of functionality and aesthetics. A spacious walk-in shower may look gorgeous but might not cater to the needs of families with young children or those who enjoy occasional bubbles.

AD

Moreover, local building codes might require you to replace the removed bathtub with a shower, potentially increasing the project's total cost. Always check with your city's building department before making any significant changes to ensure you're not inadvertently reducing the ease of reselling your home.

How to Remove a Bathtub
How to Remove a Bathtub
Top 5 Bathroom Renovation Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Top 5 Bathroom Renovation Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
How to Remove a Bathtub 🧐
How to Remove a Bathtub 🧐
How to remove a Jaccuzi tub
How to remove a Jaccuzi tub
Master Bathroom Remodel: Will Removing Jetted Tub Hurt Resale? by HighCraft Builders
Master Bathroom Remodel: Will Removing Jetted Tub Hurt Resale? by HighCraft Builders
We are considering a masterbath remodel and removing the jetted tub that only collects dust and is rarely used.
We are considering a masterbath remodel and removing the jetted tub that only collects dust and is rarely used.

Weighing the Costs and Benefits

If you've decided to proceed with removing a master bathtub, it's essential to weigh the costs and benefits carefully. Determine the budget for this project, including demolition, waterproofing, tiling, and any plumbing work needed. Keep in mind that luxurious upgrades like glass showers or heated floors can significantly increase the price tag.

To get an accurate estimate, consult with professional contractors and obtain multiple quotes. Compare the project's total cost with the potential increase in your home's value to ensure it's a financially sound decision.

AD

Determining the Return on Investment (ROI)

To determine if removing a master bathtub hurts resale, calculate the potential return on investment (ROI) for this project. According to Remodeling Magazine's 2021 Cost vs. Value Report, a bathroom renovation recovers about 60.2% of its cost upon resale, with minor upswings or downs for specific upgrades like a new shower.

Master Bathroom Without a Tub: Good Idea or Dealbreaker?
Master Bathroom Without a Tub: Good Idea or Dealbreaker?

However, keep in mind that these figures are national averages and may not accurately reflect your local real estate market. To better understand the potential ROI in your area, consult with a real estate agent or local expert who can provide tailored insights and advice based on your specific situation.

Considering Alternatives and Compromises

Before you finalize your decision to remove a master bathtub, explore alternative solutions that might better cater to both your immediate needs and the potential resale value. For instance, you could convert a standard bathtub into a shower or install a shower-tub combination that appeals to a broader range of buyers.

AD

Alternatively, consider compromising and keeping the bathtub while updating other aspects of the bathroom, such as fixtures, tilework, and vanities. This approach can give you an updated, modern look without the risk of removing a bathtub that potential buyers might desire.

Ultimately, the decision to remove a master bathtub should be based on careful consideration of your specific needs and the local real estate market's idiosyncrasies. By understanding the potential impact on resale value and weighing the costs and benefits, you can make an informed choice that maximizes your home's value and caters to your lifestyle. If you're unsure, consult with real estate professionals or a qualified designer to help you make the best decision for your circumstances.

AD