crisco soap recipe

Crisco Soap Recipe: Easy Homemade Soap for Beginners

By Emily Lopez
AD

If you have a tub of Crisco in the pantry and a curiosity about old-fashioned soap making, a Crisco soap recipe is one of the most accessible ways to start. Unlike specialty oils that can be expensive or hard to find, shortening is affordable, shelf-stable, and widely available. That makes it a forgiving first oil for cold-process soap, though it still demands respect for lye safety and accurate measurements.

This guide walks through the practical side of making soap with Crisco: what the ingredient contributes, how to calculate lye, a dependable starter recipe, and how to cure and troubleshoot the final bars. You will also learn where Crisco shines and where it can disappoint, so you can decide whether a pure shortening soap or a blend is right for your next batch.

Understanding the Crisco Soap Recipe Before You Begin

Crisco is not a single, unchanging oil. Modern tubs typically contain a blend of soybean oil, fully hydrogenated palm oil, palm oil, and mono- and diglycerides. Older versions had different fat profiles, which means a recipe from a 1990s soap forum may not match the shortening you buy today. That variation affects the saponification value, the hardness of the bar, and how much lye you need.

AD
Simple Shortening Soap
Simple Shortening Soap
the ingredients to make cheesecakes are on the counter
the ingredients to make cheesecakes are on the counter
Homemade Lard or Crisco Soap
Homemade Lard or Crisco Soap

A Crisco soap recipe can be as simple as 100 percent shortening, or it can use Crisco as the base with smaller amounts of coconut oil, olive oil, castor oil, or beeswax. The pure version is inexpensive and gentle, but it can produce soft bars with modest lather. Blending Crisco with other fats gives you more control over hardness, bubbles, and shelf life without losing the budget-friendly appeal.

What Crisco Brings to Cold Process Soap

Crisco contributes conditioning properties and a creamy, low-cleanse lather. Because it is high in unsaturated fats, it is mild on the skin and makes a good soap for people who find coconut-heavy recipes too stripping. It also saponifies reliably, behaves well with fragrance oils, and creates a pale, neutral base that accepts color without turning muddy.

a stack of soap bars sitting on top of each other next to a white cup
a stack of soap bars sitting on top of each other next to a white cup
No Weigh 3 Ingredient Crockpot Soap - PreparednessMama
No Weigh 3 Ingredient Crockpot Soap - PreparednessMama
16 DIY Projects to Make Your Own Soap at Home - Pretty Designs
16 DIY Projects to Make Your Own Soap at Home - Pretty Designs

The trade-off is that pure Crisco soap can be softer than tallow or palm soap and may develop orange spots known as DOS, or dreaded orange spots, if stored in warm, humid conditions. Adding a small amount of hard oil, curing the bars for at least six weeks, and keeping them dry between uses will improve the final result. Crisco is best viewed as a dependable base rather than a single ingredient that does everything perfectly.

Why a Lye Calculator Is Non-Negotiable

Every Crisco soap recipe must be run through a lye calculator before you melt a single ounce of shortening. You cannot safely substitute volume measurements like cups, and you cannot assume the lye amount from an old recipe will match today’s Crisco. Too much sodium hydroxide creates harsh, potentially dangerous soap, while too little leaves excess oil that can turn rancid and feel greasy.

AD

Choose a superfat of 5 to 8 percent for a pure Crisco batch. A higher superfat can feel more conditioning, but it also increases the chance of softness and spoilage in a shortening-only bar. Weigh everything in grams, use distilled water, and keep dedicated soap-making tools that never touch food. Goggles, gloves, long sleeves, and good ventilation are not optional when you work with lye.

Simple Shortening Soap
Simple Shortening Soap
Easy Cold-Pressed Soap Recipe
Easy Cold-Pressed Soap Recipe
diy 1 hour natural soap that is easy to make
diy 1 hour natural soap that is easy to make
Cold Process Soap Recipes That Actually Sell
Cold Process Soap Recipes That Actually Sell
How to Make Soap at Home (Vegan Homemade Soap)
How to Make Soap at Home (Vegan Homemade Soap)
Beginner Soap Recipe
Beginner Soap Recipe

A Reliable Crisco Soap Recipe and Step-by-Step Method

A solid starter recipe for a 1,000-gram batch of pure Crisco soap is 1,000 grams Crisco, 330 grams distilled water, and approximately 129 grams sodium hydroxide for a 5 percent superfat. Add 30 grams of fragrance oil if you want scent, and 1 teaspoon of sodium lactate per 1,000 grams of oils if you want firmer bars that unmold faster. The lye figure is only a ballpark because Crisco’s blend varies, so confirm the exact amount with a reputable lye calculator.

Gather a digital scale, a stainless steel or enamel pot, a heat-safe pitcher for the lye solution, a stick blender, a thermometer, a silicone mold, and protective gear. Line your mold, pre-measure the fragrance, and clear your workspace of children and pets. Melt the Crisco gently until it is completely liquid, then let it cool to roughly 110 to 120 degrees Fahrenheit while you carefully prepare the lye water.

AD

Mixing, Tracing, and Molding Your Crisco Soap

Slowly pour the lye water into the melted oils, stirring gently as you go. Bring the temperatures within about 10 degrees of each other, then use the stick blender in short pulses. Alternate blending with hand stirring to avoid trapping air. The mixture will thicken from a thin oil slick to a light trace that looks like pudding drizzled from the blender.

homemade baby soap recipe with text overlay
homemade baby soap recipe with text overlay
Four Cold Process Soap recipes every new soap maker must try
Four Cold Process Soap recipes every new soap maker must try
8 3 Ingredient Soap Recipes
8 3 Ingredient Soap Recipes
30 Easy Soap Recipes You Can Make at Home
30 Easy Soap Recipes You Can Make at Home

Add fragrance oil at light trace and stir it in thoroughly, but do not over-blend once the scent is incorporated. Pour the soap into your prepared mold, tap the mold against the counter to release bubbles, and cover it with plastic wrap and a towel. Let it insulate for 24 hours, then check for overheating. If the top cracks, the batch gelled too hot; it is still usable, but the texture may be uneven. Unmold after 24 to 48 hours, cut into bars, and wear gloves while handling fresh soap.

Curing, Testing, and Tweaking the Recipe

Cure the bars in a cool, dry, well-ventilated area for at least four to six weeks. Pure Crisco soap often benefits from a full six to eight weeks because it starts soft and gains hardness as water evaporates. Turn the bars once a week so all sides dry evenly. After four weeks, test a bar in the shower. If it feels slimy or disappears quickly, give it more time.

AD

To improve the recipe, try replacing 20 percent of the Crisco with coconut oil for bigger bubbles, or add 5 to 10 percent castor oil for a denser lather. A little beeswax or stearic acid can increase hardness, while olive oil can make the bar more gentle. Keep detailed notes for every batch, including the exact Crisco brand, lye calculator used, temperatures, and cure time. Small changes add up, and your best Crisco soap recipe will likely be the one you refine over several batches.

With a tub of shortening, a reliable scale, and a healthy respect for lye, you can turn a pantry staple into practical homemade soap. Start with a small batch, record every change, and let the cure do its quiet work. Your future shower, and your skin, will tell you whether the recipe deserves a permanent spot in your soap-making notebook.

AD