Bull's Heart Tomato: Giant, Meaty, Juicy Heirloom You Need to Grow
The bull's heart tomato is one of those rare garden treasures that earns its dramatic name the moment you slice into it. Shaped like a giant strawberry or a gently tapered teardrop, this heirloom variety delivers thick, meaty walls, few seeds, and a sweetness that makes supermarket tomatoes taste like pale imitations. Whether you are a seasoned grower looking to expand your heirloom collection or a curious cook searching for the ultimate tomato for sauces and sandwiches, the bull's heart deserves serious attention.
Unlike modern hybrid tomatoes bred for uniform shipping and long shelf life, bull's heart varieties have been passed down through generations, particularly across Italy, Spain, and Eastern Europe, where they are known as cuore di bue and bychye serdtse. Their popularity endures for a simple reason: flavor. This article walks you through what makes these tomatoes special, how to grow them successfully, and how to use them in the kitchen so nothing goes to waste.
What Makes the Bull's Heart Tomato Unique
The bull's heart tomato belongs to the Solanum lycopersicum species and is classified as an heirloom, meaning its seeds have been saved and replanted for decades without crossbreeding. The fruit typically weighs between eight ounces and two pounds, with some enthusiastic growers reporting specimens pushing three pounds under ideal conditions. Its most recognizable trait is the shape: broad and rounded at the shoulders, tapering to a blunt point at the blossom end, much like an actual heart.
Beyond appearance, the interior is where this tomato truly shines. The walls are remarkably thick and fleshy, while the seed cavities are small and concentrated near the center. This structure means very little juice is lost when you cut the fruit, making it ideal for slicing, roasting, and canning. The flavor profile leans sweet and mild with low acidity, which appeals even to people who normally find raw tomatoes too tangy.
The Most Popular Varieties to Grow
Several distinct cultivars fall under the bull's heart umbrella, and each has its own loyal following. The classic red Cuore di Bue from Italy produces large, ribbed fruit with deep scarlet skin and dense flesh. Another favorite is German Red Strawberry, an Amish heirloom with a slightly more pointed shape and a rich, old-fashioned tomato taste. Growers in colder climates often reach for Bull's Heart from Siberian seed collections, prized for its cold tolerance and reliable fruit set.
Color variations have also emerged over time. There is a yellow bull's heart, sometimes sold as Yellow Oxheart, which offers a milder, almost fruity sweetness. Pink and orange strains exist as well, and they tend to be lower in acid than their red counterparts. If you have limited garden space, choosing two varieties with different colors gives you visual variety in salads and a broader range of flavors for cooking.
Why Heirloom Status Matters
Heirloom status is not just a marketing label. It means the variety is open-pollinated, so saved seeds will produce plants nearly identical to the parent. This genetic stability is what allows gardeners to preserve a tomato that has been cultivated for over a century. Buying heirloom seeds also supports biodiversity at a time when commercial agriculture relies on a shockingly narrow gene pool.
There is a practical benefit too. Because heirlooms like the bull's heart have not been bred for mechanical harvesting, they retain traits that industrial tomatoes have lost: aroma, sugar content, and texture. The trade-off is that they can be fussier to grow and more prone to cracking, which is exactly why home gardeners, not factory farms, keep these varieties alive.
How to Grow Bull's Heart Tomatoes Successfully
Growing bull's heart tomatoes is rewarding but demands a bit more planning than dropping a generic seedling into the ground. These are indeterminate plants, meaning they keep growing and producing vines until frost kills them. In most regions, that translates to vines reaching six to eight feet tall, so sturdy stakes or tall cages are non-negotiable. Start seeds indoors six to eight weeks before your last expected frost date.
Soil preparation makes a measurable difference. Bull's heart plants are heavy feeders and respond well to compost-rich, well-drained soil with a pH between 6.0 and 6.8. Work in aged manure or finished compost before transplanting, and consider adding crushed eggshells or a calcium supplement, since large-fruited heirlooms are prone to blossom end rot when calcium is scarce.
Planting, Spacing, and Support
Transplant seedlings only after nighttime temperatures stay reliably above 50 degrees Fahrenheit. Bury the stems deeply, up to the first set of true leaves, because tomatoes root along any buried stem and this produces a stronger plant. Space them at least 24 to 36 inches apart in rows that are three feet apart, giving each plant room for airflow that reduces fungal disease pressure.
Support is critical. A single flimsy stake will not hold a plant loaded with two-pound fruit. Use a heavy-duty tomato cage, a Florida weave with strong posts, or a cattle panel trellis. As the vines grow, tie the main stem loosely with soft cloth strips. Pruning suckers is optional; some growers remove them below the first flower cluster to direct energy into fruit, while others let the plant sprawl for maximum yield.
Watering, Feeding, and Pest Management
Consistent moisture is the single most important factor in preventing cracked fruit. Aim for one to two inches of water per week, delivered slowly at the base of the plant rather than overhead. Mulching with straw or shredded leaves helps stabilize soil moisture and keeps soil-borne diseases from splashing onto lower leaves. Feed every three to four weeks with a balanced organic fertilizer once fruit begins to set, but avoid excess nitrogen, which produces lush leaves and few tomatoes.
Common pests include hornworms, aphids, and whiteflies, all of which can be managed with hand-picking, insecticidal soap, or introducing beneficial insects like ladybugs. Watch for early blight and septoria leaf spot, especially in humid climates, and remove affected leaves promptly. Rotating where you plant tomatoes each year breaks disease cycles and keeps your soil healthier over the long term.
Harvesting at Peak Ripeness
Bull's heart tomatoes ripen from the inside out, so color alone is not a perfect indicator. The fruit is ready when it feels slightly soft when gently squeezed and releases easily from the vine with a light tug. Fully ripe fruit will be deeply colored, glossy, and fragrant. Pick in the morning when temperatures are cool for the best flavor and longest shelf life.
Because the fruit is large, it can become top-heavy and drop before you are ready to harvest. Check plants daily once the first tomatoes begin to color. If a late-season frost threatens, pick mature green fruit and let them ripen indoors on a counter away from direct sun; they will continue to develop color and sweetness, though the flavor will not quite match a vine-ripened tomato.
Cooking and Preserving Your Harvest
The bull's heart tomato is widely considered a dual-purpose fruit, and for good reason. Its dense, low-moisture flesh makes it a standout for fresh eating while also reducing the cooking time needed for sauces, since there is less water to evaporate. Chefs in Italy often prize it specifically for passata and slow-roasted dishes where concentrated tomato flavor is the goal.
Storage is straightforward. Keep fresh tomatoes at room temperature, stem side down, and away from direct sunlight. Never refrigerate whole tomatoes, as cold temperatures degrade the volatile compounds responsible for aroma and turn the flesh mealy. If you have more than you can eat in a week, that is the moment to think about preserving rather than letting them spoil.
Best Uses in the Kitchen
Slicing is where the bull's heart truly earns its reputation. A single fruit can cover an entire slice of sourdough, and the thick walls hold up beautifully under olive oil, flaky salt, and fresh basil. Layer slabs in a caprese salad, or grill thick slices briefly to bring out their natural sugars. Because there is so little liquid, they also work exceptionally well on burgers and in hearty sandwiches without turning the bread soggy.
For cooking, the options are broad. Roast halved tomatoes with garlic and herbs for a concentrated side dish, or simmer them into a rich sauce that thickens faster than sauces made from juicier varieties. They also excel in slow-cooked dishes like ratatouille and shakshuka, where their sweetness balances sharper ingredients. Stuffing the hollowed fruit with rice, herbs, and cheese is another classic preparation that shows off its generous size.
Canning, Freezing, and Drying
When canning, remember that heirloom tomatoes vary in acidity, so add bottled lemon juice or citric acid to each jar to ensure safety. Water-bath canning works well for crushed tomatoes, sauce, and salsa, while pressure canning is required for low-acid products that include added vegetables or meats. A single bull's heart harvest can fill several quart jars, making the effort worthwhile.
Freezing is the simplest preservation method of all. Core the tomatoes, cut them into chunks, and freeze them in zip-top bags or rigid containers, skins and all. When thawed, the skins slip off easily and the flesh is ready for soups and stews. For drying, slice fruit into quarter-inch rounds and dehydrate until leathery; the resulting tomato chips are excellent rehydrated in winter cooking or crumbled into pasta dishes for a concentrated burst of flavor.
| Characteristic | Bull's Heart Tomato | Standard Round Tomato |
|---|---|---|
| Average Weight | 8 oz to 2 lbs | 4 to 8 oz |
| Flesh Texture | Thick, meaty, few seeds | Juicy, many seeds |
| Acidity | Low to mild | Moderate to high |
| Best Uses | Slicing, sauces, canning | Salads, sandwiches |
If you have never grown a bull's heart tomato, consider making it the centerpiece of next season's garden. The fruit rewards patience with flavor that genuinely cannot be found on a grocery store shelf, and saving its seeds connects you to a lineage of gardeners stretching back generations. Grab a packet of seeds, prepare a sunny bed, and see for yourself why this oddly shaped heirloom has never fallen out of favor.