boothbay gray

Boothbay Gray Paint Color: The Ultimate Guide to This Timeless Blue-Gray Shade

By Jessica Jackson
AD

Boothbay Gray is one of those paint colors that seems to have a quiet fan club wherever it appears. At first glance, it reads as a refined gray, but as the light changes, it reveals soft blue-green undertones that keep it from feeling flat or chilly. Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray HC-165 has become a go-to choice for homeowners, designers, and builders who want a neutral with a little more personality than beige or builder-grade greige.

Whether you are considering it for a living room, kitchen cabinets, an exterior door, or a whole-house palette, Boothbay Gray rewards a closer look. Its complexity is exactly what makes it beautiful—and exactly why it can look different from one room to the next. Understanding its undertones, lighting behavior, and best pairings will help you decide if this popular shade belongs in your home.

What Makes Boothbay Gray So Appealing?

Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray sits in the brand’s Historical Collection, and that pedigree shows. It is a muted, sophisticated gray with a subtle blue-green cast. It does not shout “blue” like a nautical paint, and it does not disappear into the background like a plain cool gray. Instead, it occupies that sought-after middle ground: a neutral with depth.

AD
a white sheet of paper on top of a gray wall with the word goodbye gray ic - 103
a white sheet of paper on top of a gray wall with the word goodbye gray ic - 103
The Best Blue-Gray Paint Colors for Any Space
The Best Blue-Gray Paint Colors for Any Space
Boothbay Gray (HC-165)
Boothbay Gray (HC-165)

Its Light Reflectance Value, or LRV, is often cited in the mid-to-high 40s, which means it reflects a moderate amount of light. That mid-range quality gives it versatility. It can feel airy in a bright room, moody in a dim hallway, and almost like a soft green-gray in a space filled with warm wood tones.

The Undertones and Light Reflectance Value

The magic of Boothbay Gray lies in its undertones. Depending on the light, you may notice cool blue, gentle green, or a balanced slate gray. In north-facing rooms, the blue note tends to step forward and the color can feel cooler and more stormy. In south-facing rooms, sunlight warms it up and pulls out a softer, almost sage-like gray-green.

a living room filled with furniture and a fire place under a painting on the wall
a living room filled with furniture and a fire place under a painting on the wall
The Best Blue Gray Paint Color
The Best Blue Gray Paint Color
BM Boothbay Gray is a that perfect in-between blue and gray paint color.
BM Boothbay Gray is a that perfect in-between blue and gray paint color.

Because its LRV is moderate rather than very high or very low, Boothbay Gray offers noticeable contrast against white trim without making a room feel dark. It is light enough for large open spaces but has enough pigment to create definition on cabinetry, wainscoting, or an accent wall. That balance is why it works in both traditional and contemporary interiors.

How Lighting Changes Boothbay Gray

No paint color exists in a vacuum, and Boothbay Gray is especially responsive to its environment. Warm incandescent or soft-white LED bulbs can bring out its green-gray side, making it feel earthier and more relaxed. Cooler daylight bulbs, on the other hand, emphasize the blue and can make the color read as a crisp, slightly icy gray.

AD

Time of day matters just as much. Morning light may make it look fresh and silvery, while evening lamplight can deepen it into a richer slate tone. That is why painting a small swatch on the wall and calling it done is risky. Instead, paint a large sample board, move it around the room, and observe it at different hours before committing.

Complimentary Colors for Boothbay Gray HC-165 Paint Color by Benjamin Moore
Complimentary Colors for Boothbay Gray HC-165 Paint Color by Benjamin Moore
Meet Boothbay Gray HC-165 from Benjamin Moore
Meet Boothbay Gray HC-165 from Benjamin Moore
Benjamin Moore's Boothbay Gray May Be 50 Years Old
Benjamin Moore's Boothbay Gray May Be 50 Years Old
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray HC-165: Everything You Need To Know - NISH
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray HC-165: Everything You Need To Know - NISH
a white paint color with an oval shape on the top and bottom, it is light gray
a white paint color with an oval shape on the top and bottom, it is light gray
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray HC-165 Review: A Soft Blue-Gray You'll Love
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray HC-165 Review: A Soft Blue-Gray You'll Love

Where to Use Boothbay Gray in Your Home

Boothbay Gray is versatile enough for almost any room, but it shines brightest when its subtle color shift is allowed to play against complementary textures and finishes. It works beautifully as a wall color, a cabinet color, and even an exterior siding or door color. The key is to consider the mood you want each space to evoke.

In living areas, it creates a calm backdrop for furniture and art. In kitchens and baths, it adds a hint of coastal coolness without becoming themed. On exteriors, it pairs naturally with white trim, natural wood, and stone. Because it is neither strictly warm nor strictly cool, it can bridge different design styles in an open floor plan.

AD

Living Rooms, Bedrooms, and Open Concepts

In a living room, Boothbay Gray provides a serene foundation that lets furniture, textiles, and artwork take center stage. It pairs especially well with warm wood floors, linen sofas, brass or bronze hardware, and black metal accents. The result is sophisticated but not stuffy—a space that feels collected rather than decorated in one afternoon.

a gray background with the words boothby gray hfc - 156 benjamin moore
a gray background with the words boothby gray hfc - 156 benjamin moore
Boothbay Gray HC-165 by Benjamin Moore
Boothbay Gray HC-165 by Benjamin Moore
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray Design Board
Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray Design Board
a gray background with the words boot bay gray on it
a gray background with the words boot bay gray on it

In bedrooms, the color’s muted quality can make the room feel restful and cocooning. Use it with crisp white trim, soft gray or oatmeal bedding, and perhaps a deeper navy or charcoal accent. In open-concept homes, repeated use of Boothbay Gray can unify the kitchen, dining, and living areas, though you should expect it to shift slightly as lighting changes from zone to zone.

Kitchens, Bathrooms, and Cabinetry

Kitchens are where Boothbay Gray has earned many of its fans. As a cabinet color, it feels more interesting than white but less commitment-heavy than deep navy or forest green. Pair it with white quartz or marble countertops, a simple subway tile backsplash, and warm metal hardware for a timeless look that still has personality.

AD

In bathrooms, Boothbay Gray can turn a basic powder room into a jewel box or give a primary bath a spa-like softness. It works well with marble, chrome, polished nickel, and white fixtures. For cabinetry, choose a durable finish such as satin or pearl; on walls, matte or eggshell is usually more forgiving. Just be sure the room has enough light, because in a dark bathroom this color can lean moody rather than fresh.

Coordinating Colors and Finishes for Boothbay Gray

Choosing the right companion colors is essential with a chameleon shade like Boothbay Gray. The wrong trim white can make it look dirty or overly blue, while the right one can make the whole room feel intentional and polished. Accent colors and finishes also change how the gray is perceived.

Generally, Boothbay Gray plays well with warm whites, soft creams, charcoal, navy, muted greens, and natural wood tones. It can also handle black accents if you want a more dramatic, modern edge. The finish you choose—matte, eggshell, satin, or semi-gloss—will affect how much light bounces off the surface and how saturated the color appears.

Best Trim, Ceiling, and Accent Colors

For trim, Benjamin Moore White Dove, Simply White, and Chantilly Lace are popular pairings. White Dove is softer and warmer, which helps balance Boothbay Gray’s cool undertones. Chantilly Lace is crisper and brighter, creating a cleaner, more contemporary contrast. A warm white ceiling can keep the room from feeling chilly, especially in north-facing spaces.

Accent colors can be drawn from the landscape or from existing fabrics. Navy blue, deep green, warm black, and even muted terracotta can work when balanced carefully. Brass, copper, and unlacquered bronze hardware add warmth, while polished chrome or nickel keeps the look cooler and more modern. If you want a monochromatic scheme, use lighter and darker versions of gray-blue rather than matching Boothbay Gray exactly.

Paint Finishes That Flatter Boothbay Gray

Finish matters more than many homeowners expect. Matte and eggshell finishes diffuse light and soften Boothbay Gray’s undertones, making walls look velvety and understated. Satin and pearl finishes are more reflective, which can make the color appear richer and slightly more saturated—ideal for cabinets, trim, and doors that need to be scrubbed.

For high-traffic areas, choose a washable finish without going too glossy. Semi-gloss on trim is classic and durable, while a satin or pearl on kitchen cabinets strikes a practical balance. On exteriors, a satin or low-sheen finish often holds up best and prevents the color from looking plasticky. Always test your chosen finish on a sample board, because sheen can shift the color just as much as lighting does.

Practical Tips and Similar Boothbay Gray Shades

Before you buy a gallon, it helps to compare Boothbay Gray with other popular blue-gray and gray-green paints. It also helps to follow a few practical painting tips that prevent costly mistakes. Even a beautiful color can disappoint if it is applied in the wrong light, paired with the wrong white, or rushed without testing.

Boothbay Gray has cousins in the Benjamin Moore lineup, and each one has a slightly different temperature, depth, and undertone. Knowing those differences can help you choose the exact mood you want. If you love the idea of Boothbay Gray but need something lighter, darker, warmer, or cooler, there is likely a close alternative that will suit your space.

Testing and Sampling Like a Pro

Start by painting at least two coats of Boothbay Gray onto a large white poster board or foam board. Do not paint directly onto the existing wall color, because the old paint can influence what you see. Move the sample around the room, hold it next to your flooring, countertops, and fixed furnishings, and view it under both natural and artificial light.

Check the sample in the morning, at midday, at dusk, and at night with the lamps on. If possible, compare it with your intended trim color at the same time. This simple step takes a few days, but it reveals exactly how Boothbay Gray will behave in your home. Paint a second sample in an adjacent room if you are planning a whole-house palette.

Boothbay Gray vs. Gray Owl, Wickham Gray, and Coventry Gray

Gray Owl is lighter and more airy, with a subtle green-gray cast that feels fresh in bright spaces. Wickham Gray is also lighter and often reads as a silvery, cool gray with delicate blue-green notes. Boothbay Gray sits a bit deeper and more complex, so it offers more presence on walls and cabinets without becoming heavy.

Chelsea Gray is darker and warmer, making it a better choice for dramatic rooms or moody exteriors. Coventry Gray is cooler and more straightforwardly gray, with less of the blue-green softness that defines Boothbay Gray. If you are torn between them, sample all four side by side. Your room’s light will make the final decision clearer than any online photo ever could.

If you are drawn to a gray that feels calm, layered, and quietly sophisticated, Boothbay Gray is worth a serious look. It has enough character to keep a room interesting but enough restraint to play well with changing décor for years. Pick up a sample, live with it through a few sunrises and lamplit evenings, and let the color show you what it can do. When it finally clicks, you will understand why this understated shade has become a favorite in so many well-designed homes.

AD