book club recommendations 2017

20 Best Book Club Recommendations 2017: Must-Read Picks for Your Next Meeting

By Richard Hernandez
AD

Ask anyone who belonged to a book club in 2017 and they will probably tell you it was an unusually good year for reading. Between a tense political climate, a surge in memoir publishing, and a wave of debut novels that seemed to arrive almost monthly, groups had no shortage of material worth arguing about over coffee and crackers. The titles that dominated that year were not just entertaining; they gave friends, neighbors, and coworkers a reason to sit down together and work through difficult ideas about race, class, grief, and identity.

What follows is a practical, curated look back at the books that made 2017 such a memorable year for reading groups, along with guidance on how to build a stronger club around them. Whether you are reviving a dormant group, starting a new one from scratch, or simply looking for a title that will spark real discussion, these recommendations still hold up remarkably well years later.

Unforgettable Fiction That Kept Book Clubs Talking

Fiction in 2017 covered an enormous range, from quiet domestic dramas to sprawling historical epics and genre-bending experiments. That variety was a gift to book clubs, because it meant groups could rotate through very different moods without ever feeling like they were repeating themselves. A single calendar year could take a club from a small Ohio suburb to a Korean immigrant community in Japan to a graveyard full of restless ghosts.

AD
The Most Popular Book Club Books of the Past Decade
The Most Popular Book Club Books of the Past Decade
Delicious Reads
Delicious Reads
21 Novels for the Book Club That Can Never Agree
21 Novels for the Book Club That Can Never Agree

The best book club novels tend to share a few qualities: morally complicated characters, unresolved questions, and enough narrative momentum to keep slower readers engaged. The 2017 releases that stood out did exactly that, giving groups plenty of room to disagree while still feeling like they had read something substantial.

Domestic Dramas and Family Sagas

Celeste Ng's Little Fires Everywhere arrived in September 2017 and quickly became one of the most discussed novels of the year. Set in the carefully planned community of Shaker Heights, Ohio, the story follows two very different families whose lives become entangled through motherhood, adoption, race, and class. It is a book built for argument, since almost every character makes at least one decision a reader will want to defend or condemn.

The Most Anticipated Book Club Reads of 2017
The Most Anticipated Book Club Reads of 2017
16 Books Everyone in Your Book Club Will Enjoy
16 Books Everyone in Your Book Club Will Enjoy
books to read in 2020 with the title 26 great book club books to read in
books to read in 2020 with the title 26 great book club books to read in

Groups looking for something equally rich but with a different flavor could turn to Min Jin Lee's Pachinko, a multi-generational saga about a Korean family surviving in Japan, or Jesmyn Ward's Sing, Unburied, Sing, which blends Southern gothic atmosphere with a road trip narrative. Gail Honeyman's Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine offered a lighter counterpoint, with a quirky narrator whose gradual healing invites genuinely tender conversation about loneliness and social awkwardness.

Historical Fiction and Bold Literary Experiments

George Saunders won the Man Booker Prize for Lincoln in the Bardo, a novel composed of more than a hundred distinct voices speaking from a graveyard where Willie Lincoln has just been laid to rest. It is a challenging read, but that challenge is precisely what makes it such a rewarding book club selection. Groups that work through the unusual structure together often find that the book opens up questions about grief, memory, and collective storytelling that a conventional novel could never reach.

AD

For readers who prefer a more traditional narrative, Jennifer Egan's Manhattan Beach delivered a richly researched portrait of Brooklyn during the Depression and World War II, complete with a female diver, a missing father, and a naval mystery. Mohsin Hamid's Exit West used magical realism to explore migration and displacement, while Colson Whitehead's The Underground Railroad, which won the Pulitzer Prize in 2017, gave groups a searing alternative history worth revisiting. Taylor Jenkins Reid's The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo rounded out the year with glamour, ambition, and a twist that readers love to debate.

some books that are stacked together with the words, 12 great book club picks on them
some books that are stacked together with the words, 12 great book club picks on them
bookshelves with text overlay reading we've fantastic book club reads
bookshelves with text overlay reading we've fantastic book club reads
the complete reesee witherspoon book club list on top of bookshelves
the complete reesee witherspoon book club list on top of bookshelves
books stacked on top of each other with text overlay that reads the most popular book club books of the past decade
books stacked on top of each other with text overlay that reads the most popular book club books of the past decade
23 Books That Will Have Your Book Club Talking All Summer Long
23 Books That Will Have Your Book Club Talking All Summer Long
MomAdvice 2018 Book Club Selections
MomAdvice 2018 Book Club Selections

Nonfiction That Fueled Real Conversations

Nonfiction had an exceptional year in 2017, and much of it landed directly in the middle of the cultural debates that were reshaping the country. Memoirs about identity and survival sat alongside investigative journalism that exposed overlooked chapters of American history, giving book clubs a way to move beyond opinion and into evidence-backed discussion. Groups that usually stuck to fiction found themselves reaching for essays and reportage.

Reading nonfiction together has a particular advantage: it gives members something concrete to react to, whether that is a statistic, a court record, or a personal recollection. The 2017 titles below are especially well suited to that dynamic, because each one combines rigorous research with a strong narrative voice that keeps the pages turning.

AD

Memoirs and Personal Narratives

Roxane Gay's Hunger is one of the most honest and uncomfortable memoirs of the decade, examining the author's relationship with her body, trauma, and food. It is not an easy read, but it is the kind of book that changes the temperature in a room and prompts members to share things they might not otherwise say out loud. Trevor Noah's Born a Crime, published in paperback in 2017, offered a very different tone, using humor and sharp observation to describe growing up in apartheid South Africa.

Book Club Books 2026
Book Club Books 2026
the book club flyer is shown in blue and white with an image of books on it
the book club flyer is shown in blue and white with an image of books on it
the 25 must read book club books
the 25 must read book club books
the best book club books for 2019 by various authors, including one with a woman's face
the best book club books for 2019 by various authors, including one with a woman's face

Patricia Lockwood's Priestdaddy brought a wild, poetic energy to the memoir genre, recounting the author's move back into her parents' rectory with wit and startling honesty. Hillary Clinton's What Happened and Sheryl Sandberg and Adam Grant's Option B, about resilience after loss, rounded out a year in which personal stories carried obvious public weight. Each of these books gives a group a chance to talk about memory, honesty, and how much of ourselves we are willing to share.

Investigative Journalism and Social Commentary

David Grann's Killers of the Flower Moon told the harrowing story of the Osage murders in 1920s Oklahoma and the birth of the FBI, blending true crime pacing with serious historical research. Kate Moore's The Radium Girls gave voice to the young factory workers who were poisoned by radium paint and later fought for justice in court. Both books work beautifully in a group setting because they combine narrative tension with real-world stakes that invite follow-up research.

AD

Ta-Nehisi Coates's We Were Eight Years in Power collected essays written during the Obama presidency and framed them with new commentary, making it an ideal choice for groups willing to engage with political analysis. J.D. Vance's Hillbilly Elegy, though published in 2016, remained one of the most debated titles on book club lists throughout 2017. When a club chooses books like these, it helps to set a few ground rules for respectful disagreement, since conversations can become personal quickly.

Building a Better Book Club Experience

Choosing great books is only half the work. The other half is making sure your group actually enjoys meeting, which depends far more on logistics and tone than most people expect. A club that matches the right titles to the right personalities will keep members coming back for years, while one that ignores those dynamics tends to fade after a handful of meetings.

It also helps to remember that book clubs serve a social function as much as a literary one. The reading is the excuse, but the conversation, the snacks, and the sense of belonging are what people actually remember. Designing your meetings with that in mind makes everything else easier.

Matching Titles to Your Group's Personality

Start by asking members what they actually want, rather than assuming everyone shares your taste. A short survey about favorite genres, preferred book length, and tolerance for difficult subject matter can reveal more than a year of guessing. Groups with busy parents and commuters often do better with books in the 300-page range, while retired members may welcome a 600-page epic.

Rotating who selects the book is another reliable strategy, since it spreads the labor and exposes everyone to new perspectives. It also helps to check availability early, because a title that is only available in hardcover can price out part of the group. Paperback releases, library hold lists, and audiobook options are all worth considering before you announce the next pick.

Leading a Discussion That Everyone Enjoys

A good discussion leader prepares a handful of open-ended questions but resists the urge to steer every answer. Questions that begin with why or how tend to generate far more conversation than ones that can be answered with a simple yes or no. For a book like Little Fires Everywhere, for example, asking members which character they most related to, and why, opens up more than asking whether they liked the ending.

Disagreement is a feature, not a bug, and the best groups learn to sit with it comfortably. If a conversation becomes heated, a gentle reminder that everyone is describing their own reading experience usually restores balance. Mixing formats occasionally, such as pairing a book with its film adaptation or inviting a guest facilitator, can also refresh a group that has started to feel predictable.

If you are planning your next round of selections, there is real value in returning to 2017, a year whose books still generate lively, relevant conversation. Pick one title from the list above, put it on the calendar, and see where the discussion takes your group. The right book has a way of turning an ordinary Tuesday evening into something people talk about for months.

AD