Big Boy vs Better Boy Tomato: Which Variety Should You Grow?
Choosing the right tomato for your garden often comes down to a showdown between two legendary varieties: Big Boy and Better Boy. Both are beloved by home gardeners for their reliability, robust flavor, and ability to produce a steady stream of slicing tomatoes throughout the season. But while they share a family tree and a reputation for excellence, they are not identical twins. Understanding the subtle and not-so-subtle differences between these two classics can mean the difference between a good harvest and a great one.
Whether you are a seasoned grower looking to diversify your patch or a beginner trying to decide which seedling to buy at the local nursery, this comparison will help you make an informed choice. We will dig into their history, growth habits, disease resistance, and, most importantly, how they perform on the plate. By the end, you will know exactly which of these two heavyweights deserves a spot in your garden beds this summer.
The Origins and Heritage of These Tomato Icons
To truly appreciate the differences between Big Boy and Better Boy, it helps to understand where they came from. Both were developed by the same breeder, the W. Atlee Burpee Company, and both were introduced to the public as improvements on existing varieties. They were designed to solve specific problems that gardeners faced in the mid-20th century, particularly the need for larger fruit and better resistance to soil-borne diseases.
These tomatoes are not heirlooms in the strict sense; they are hybrid varieties, which means their seeds are the result of a deliberate cross between two distinct parent plants. This hybridization gives them what breeders call "hybrid vigor," a phenomenon where the offspring grow stronger and more productively than either parent. That vigor is a key reason why both Big Boy and Better Boy have remained commercially available and popular for decades.
The Story Behind Big Boy
Big Boy was introduced by Burpee in 1949 and quickly became a sensation because of its sheer size. It was one of the first widely available hybrids to consistently produce fruit weighing over a pound, which was a game-changer for home gardeners used to smaller, standard varieties. The original Big Boy was a cross between a large-fruited variety and a smaller, more disease-resistant one, creating a plant that offered both size and improved health.
Over the years, Burpee released several variations on the theme, including the famous "Big Boy" and a later "Big Beef" and "Big Girl" (which is actually a different, though related, variety). The classic Big Boy remains a favorite for its smooth, slightly flattened globe-shaped fruit and its balanced, old-fashioned tomato taste. It is a slice of gardening history that still performs well in modern gardens.
The Development of Better Boy
Better Boy arrived on the scene in 1957, just a few years after Big Boy, and was positioned as an improvement on the original. The goal was to create a tomato that matched Big Boy's size and flavor but offered significantly better resistance to diseases, particularly Fusarium wilt and Verticillium wilt, which were devastating tomato crops at the time. It was a direct response to the needs of farmers and gardeners who were losing plants to soil fungi.
The result was a tomato that was slightly more elongated and uniform than Big Boy, with a deep red color and a classic acidic-sweet balance. Better Boy became the gold standard for reliable production in areas where disease pressure was high. Its ability to thrive in less-than-perfect soil conditions made it a staple for market growers and home gardeners alike, and it remains one of the most widely sold tomato varieties in North America.
Growth Habits, Yield, and Disease Resistance
When you plant a tomato, you are investing months of care, so understanding how each variety grows is crucial. Both Big Boy and Better Boy are indeterminate tomatoes, meaning they grow as vines and continue to produce fruit until frost kills them. This is a major advantage for home gardeners because it ensures a continuous harvest rather than a single, concentrated flush of fruit.
However, their growth patterns differ in subtle ways. Big Boy tends to be a bit more sprawling and open in its habit, while Better Boy is often described as more compact and manageable. Both require staking or caging to keep the fruit off the ground, but the amount of pruning and support needed can vary depending on your climate and growing style.
Fruit Size and Flavor Profile
Big Boy is famous for its large, beefsteak-style fruit, with individual tomatoes often weighing between 10 and 16 ounces, and some reaching over a pound. The flavor is rich, sweet, and slightly acidic, with a meaty texture that makes it ideal for sandwiches and burgers. The fruit tends to be slightly flattened and has a tendency to crack near the stem if watering is inconsistent, so steady irrigation is key.
Better Boy produces fruit that is slightly smaller on average, typically 8 to 12 ounces, but it is more consistent in shape and size. The flavor is often described as more balanced, with a good sugar-to-acid ratio that appeals to a wide range of palates. It is also less prone to cracking and catfacing, making it a more reliable choice for gardeners who want uniform, attractive slicing tomatoes.
Disease Resistance and Productivity
This is where Better Boy truly shines. It was bred specifically to resist Fusarium wilt (races 1 and 2) and Verticillium wilt, two of the most common and lethal soil-borne diseases for tomatoes. It also has some tolerance to nematodes. This genetic armor means it can produce well even in gardens where tomatoes have been grown for years and disease pressure is high.
Big Boy, while not defenseless, lacks the same level of resistance. It is generally susceptible to Fusarium and Verticillium wilts, though it does have some tolerance to tobacco mosaic virus. In terms of yield, Big Boy can produce an impressive number of large fruits, but Better Boy often outproduces it in terms of total weight and consistency, especially in challenging conditions. If you have had trouble with wilting plants in the past, Better Boy is the safer bet.
Which One Should You Grow?
The decision between Big Boy and Better Boy ultimately comes down to your priorities and your garden's specific challenges. If you are growing in a new garden bed with clean soil and you want the biggest, most impressive tomatoes for slicing, Big Boy is an excellent choice. Its flavor is iconic, and the sheer size of the fruit is a point of pride for many gardeners.
On the other hand, if you are growing in an established garden where disease has been an issue, or if you want a plant that produces a steady, reliable crop with less fuss, Better Boy is the smarter investment. Its disease resistance package is superior, and its fruit is more consistent, making it a better choice for canning, selling at market, or simply ensuring you have tomatoes all summer long.
Best Uses in the Kitchen
Big Boy tomatoes are best enjoyed fresh. Their large size and meaty texture make them perfect for thick slices on sandwiches, burgers, and caprese salads. They also have a high water content, which means they are not ideal for making thick sauces unless you are willing to cook them down for a long time. Their flavor is best preserved when eaten raw or lightly cooked.
Better Boy is a more versatile kitchen performer. Its balanced flavor and firmer flesh hold up well to cooking, making it a great choice for sauces, soups, and stews. It also slices beautifully for salads and sandwiches, and its uniform size makes it easy to process for canning or freezing. If you want one tomato that can do it all, Better Boy is the more practical pick.
Tips for Maximizing Your Harvest
Regardless of which variety you choose, proper care will determine your success. Both tomatoes need full sun, at least six to eight hours per day, and well-drained soil rich in organic matter. Consistent watering is critical to prevent blossom end rot and cracking, especially for Big Boy. A deep soak once or twice a week is far better than frequent light sprinklings.
Feed your plants with a balanced fertilizer or compost tea every few weeks, but avoid excessive nitrogen, which encourages leafy growth at the expense of fruit. Pruning suckers can help improve airflow and reduce disease, but it also reduces the number of fruiting branches. For Big Boy, a light pruning is often enough; for Better Boy, you can be more aggressive if you want larger individual fruits. Mulching around the base of the plants will help retain moisture and keep soil-borne diseases from splashing onto the leaves.
Whichever variety you plant, you are choosing a piece of gardening history that has stood the test of time. Big Boy offers the thrill of giant, flavorful fruit, while Better Boy delivers dependable, disease-resistant performance. Consider planting a few of each to enjoy the best of both worlds, and let your taste buds decide which one earns a permanent spot in your garden rotation. Happy growing, and may your vines be heavy with ripe, red fruit all season long.