best water softeners 2019

Best Water Softeners 2019: Top Picks for Hard Water Relief

By Nicole Allen
AD

Hard water is one of those household problems that rarely gets dramatic attention, but it quietly costs you money every month. It leaves white scale on faucets, makes soap less effective, dulls laundry, and shortens the life of water heaters and dishwashers. If you searched for the best water softeners 2019, you are likely looking for a practical way to protect your plumbing and improve daily comfort without overspending on a system that does not fit your home.

The 2019 water softener market offered a strong mix of workhorse salt-based units, compact salt-free conditioners, and smart metered systems that only regenerate when needed. That variety is helpful, but it also makes the decision harder. This guide walks through the features that mattered most, highlights a few standout models from that year, and explains how to match a softener to your water hardness, household size, and installation setup.

What to Look for in a Water Softener in 2019

Before comparing brands, it helps to understand the numbers behind the label. Water hardness is measured in grains per gallon, and a softener must be sized to remove those minerals over a realistic period between regenerations. A unit that is too small will regenerate constantly and waste salt, while an oversized system may cost more upfront and run inefficiently if it is not configured correctly.

AD
Water Systems Whole House Salt-Free Water Softener with UV
Water Systems Whole House Salt-Free Water Softener with UV
Water Filter and Salt-Free FutureSoft® System
Water Filter and Salt-Free FutureSoft® System
Aqua-Tech Well Series Whole House Water Filtration and Softening System
Aqua-Tech Well Series Whole House Water Filtration and Softening System

Beyond grain capacity, shoppers in 2019 paid close attention to flow rate, salt efficiency, warranty coverage, and whether the system used a timer or a meter. Metered demand-initiated regeneration was becoming the standard for value-focused buyers because it tracks actual water use instead of regenerating on a fixed schedule. That single feature often separates a frustrating purchase from a dependable one.

Understanding Grain Capacity and Household Size

Grain capacity tells you how much hardness the resin can remove before it needs to recharge. A common rule of thumb is to add one person for every 75 gallons of daily water use, then multiply by your water hardness. For example, a family of four with 10 grains per gallon hardness needs a system sized well above the bare minimum to handle laundry, showers, and dishwashing without constant cycling.

Best Water Softeners: Buyer's Guide
Best Water Softeners: Buyer's Guide
This is How Water Softeners Work
This is How Water Softeners Work
The Best Water Softener Salt in 2019
The Best Water Softener Salt in 2019

In 2019, 32,000-grain units were popular for one- to three-person homes with moderate hardness, while 40,000- to 48,000-grain models suited larger families or wells with higher mineral content. If your water tested above 15 grains per gallon, a single-tank softener could still work, but it needed careful sizing and more frequent salt checks. Testing first prevented the most common mistake: guessing at capacity and paying for it later.

Salt-Based vs. Salt-Free Systems

Salt-based softeners use ion exchange to remove calcium and magnesium, replacing them with sodium or potassium. They are the only systems that truly soften water in the traditional sense, and they remain the most effective choice for severe scale problems. Salt-free systems, by contrast, condition water by changing how minerals behave, which can reduce scale adhesion but does not remove hardness minerals.

AD

For 2019 buyers, the choice often came down to lifestyle. Salt-based units require bags of salt, a drain line, and periodic maintenance, but they deliver slippery-soft water and protect appliances aggressively. Salt-free conditioners appeal to people who want no salt and no brine discharge, yet they may not solve spotting or soap scum as completely. Reading the fine print matters, because some products marketed as softeners are actually conditioners.

8 Best Water Softeners for Your Home 2026
8 Best Water Softeners for Your Home 2026
The Best Water Softener for Well Water
The Best Water Softener for Well Water
5 Best Water Softeners for Well Water
5 Best Water Softeners for Well Water
Best RV Water Softener in 2019 (Top 5 Reviews with Comparison)
Best RV Water Softener in 2019 (Top 5 Reviews with Comparison)
a man is holding up his water softeners and cell phone in front of him
a man is holding up his water softeners and cell phone in front of him
Explained: The Difference Between Salt-Based and Salt-Free Water Softeners
Explained: The Difference Between Salt-Based and Salt-Free Water Softeners

Top Water Softener Picks for 2019

The best water softener for one home may be overkill for another, so the top picks from 2019 should be judged by fit rather than a single ranking. Reliability, parts availability, and ease of service mattered just as much as headline capacity. Brands like Fleck, Whirlpool, Morton, and GE dominated many conversations because they offered proven designs and accessible support.

When reviewing models from that year, we looked at regeneration type, grain capacity, flow rate, warranty length, and real-world installation requirements. We also considered whether replacement parts and consumables were easy to find. A softener is a long-term appliance, so a strong 2019 model is one that still makes sense when you factor in service, salt, and the cost of protecting your plumbing.

AD

Fleck 5600SXT and Similar High-Efficiency Units

The Fleck 5600SXT became a favorite among DIYers and value hunters because it paired a proven mechanical valve with a digital meter. It was available in multiple grain capacities, often 48,000 grains, and its demand-initiated regeneration helped reduce salt use. For homeowners with medium to hard water, it offered a customizable setup that could be tuned after a water test.

Best Salt-Free Water Softeners: Do They Actually Work?
Best Salt-Free Water Softeners: Do They Actually Work?

Similar high-efficiency units from that era used the same principle: measure water use, regenerate only when necessary, and make service simple. The main trade-off was that Fleck-style systems often required more hands-on installation and programming than big-box all-in-one units. For someone comfortable with basic plumbing, that trade-off translated into better long-term value and easier repairs.

Whirlpool WHES40 and Big-Box Favorites

The Whirlpool WHES40 was one of the most recognizable water softeners of 2019, largely because it was widely available at major retailers. It offered a 40,000-grain capacity, demand-initiated regeneration, and a user-friendly control panel. Many shoppers liked that they could buy it locally, schedule installation, and find replacement filters or parts without hunting online.

AD

Its strengths were convenience and approachability, not custom tuning. For average homes with moderate hardness, it handled daily demand well and reduced scale in appliances. The trade-off was that some users found it less efficient than premium metered units, and hard water above a certain level could require a larger or more configurable system. Still, as a mainstream 2019 option, it was a solid entry point.

Installation, Maintenance, and Long-Term Value

A water softener only performs well when it is installed correctly. The unit needs a suitable location near a drain, a power source, and the main water line, plus a bypass valve for maintenance. Poor installation can create pressure drops, leaks, or regeneration problems that make even a top-rated softener feel like a bad purchase.

Long-term value also depends on maintenance. Salt levels, resin condition, and brine tank cleanliness all affect performance. A system that is efficient on paper can become expensive if it regenerates too often, bridges salt, or sits unused during vacations. Planning for service from day one keeps the unit running closer to its rated efficiency.

DIY Installation vs. Professional Setup

DIY installation appealed to 2019 shoppers who wanted to save money and had basic plumbing skills. The job typically involves cutting into the main water line, soldering or using push-fit fittings, running a drain line, and programming the valve. It is manageable for a confident homeowner, but mistakes can lead to leaks or warranty issues.

Professional installation costs more, yet it brings code compliance, proper sizing verification, and a professional eye on drainage and bypass setup. For people with older plumbing, tight spaces, or no interest in learning a valve controller, hiring a pro was often the smarter choice. The best approach was to get quotes and compare them with the cost of tools, time, and potential repairs.

Keeping Your Softener Running Efficiently

Routine maintenance starts with checking the salt level every four to six weeks. Do not let the brine tank run empty, but also avoid overfilling it, which can cause salt bridges. If the tank develops a crust or the salt forms a solid layer, break it up gently and clean the tank during a regeneration cycle.

Every few months, inspect the resin tank, bypass valve, and drain line for leaks or mineral buildup. Some systems benefit from resin cleaner if iron is present, because iron can foul the resin and reduce capacity. Testing your water again after installation confirms whether the softener is actually solving the problem, not just running through salt.

Take a few minutes to test your water, measure your household demand, and compare the models above against your plumbing setup and budget. The right water softener from 2019 or any year will pay you back with softer laundry, cleaner fixtures, and less time spent scrubbing hard-water stains. Start with your water test results, and the rest of the decision becomes far easier.

AD