best incinerating toilet 2017

Best Incinerating Toilet 2017: Top Picks, Reviews & Buying Guide

By Nicole Allen
AD

If you were researching the best incinerating toilet 2017 had to offer, you were likely solving a problem that a traditional flush toilet could not touch: no plumbing, no septic, no water, or no easy way to haul waste. Incinerating toilets turned that problem into ash, using electricity or propane to burn waste at high temperatures. The market in 2017 was smaller than today's, but it had a few standout names and a clear set of trade-offs that separated a reliable unit from a frustrating one.

This guide revisits the best incinerating toilet options of 2017 with the benefit of hindsight. It covers how these units worked, which brands were most trusted, what buyers needed to check before ordering, and why some models held up better than others in cabins, workshops, tiny homes, and off-grid retreats.

What Defined the Best Incinerating Toilet in 2017

In 2017, the best incinerating toilet was not simply the one with the largest tank or the lowest price. It was the model that matched the user's power source, climate, usage frequency, and tolerance for maintenance. A unit that excelled in a weekend cabin might fail in a full-time household, and a propane model that worked beautifully off-grid could be overkill for a garage with reliable electricity.

AD
a white toilet with the lid open and black seat cover on it's side
a white toilet with the lid open and black seat cover on it's side
Buying a Tiny House Incinerator Toilet in 2026
Buying a Tiny House Incinerator Toilet in 2026
Incinerating Toilet: How it Works, Pros, Cons & Types Incinerating Toilet Diagram, Electric Composting Toilet, Incinolet Electric Toilet System, Cinderella Incineration Toilet Manual, Cinderella Incinerating Toilet, Incinerating Toilet Cost, Composting And Incinerating Toilets, Electric Incinerating Toilet, Water-saving Toilet Modifications
Incinerating Toilet: How it Works, Pros, Cons & Types Incinerating Toilet Diagram, Electric Composting Toilet, Incinolet Electric Toilet System, Cinderella Incineration Toilet Manual, Cinderella Incinerating Toilet, Incinerating Toilet Cost, Composting And Incinerating Toilets, Electric Incinerating Toilet, Water-saving Toilet Modifications

Buyers also had to think about venting, burn cycles, ash removal, and the realities of living with a toilet that makes noise and heat. Reviews from that era often focused on whether a model actually completed a full burn without odor, how often it needed to be emptied, and whether replacement parts were easy to find.

How Incinerating Toilets Worked in 2017

Most incinerating toilets from 2017 used a similar process. After use, the toilet moved waste into a burn chamber, where an electric element or gas flame raised the temperature high enough to reduce solids to a small amount of sterile ash. An exhaust vent carried smoke, odor, and moisture outside, while a fan helped manage airflow and cooling.

Incinerating Toilets Inc. - The Best Waterless, Eco Toilet - Cinderella
Incinerating Toilets Inc. - The Best Waterless, Eco Toilet - Cinderella
Incinerating Toilets - Pros and Cons
Incinerating Toilets - Pros and Cons
Incinerating Waterless Toilets
Incinerating Waterless Toilets

The differences came down to fuel, chamber design, and controls. Electric models such as Incinolet were popular because they needed no propane tank, but they drew significant power during a cycle. Propane models like Storburn and Cinderella appealed to off-grid users who already had gas on site and wanted to avoid heavy electrical loads.

Electric, Propane, and Off-Grid Trade-Offs

Electric incinerating toilets were generally simpler to install where 120V or 240V power was available. They produced no open flame and often had a familiar toilet-like appearance, but they could consume a lot of electricity in a short period. That made them a poor fit for small solar systems unless the battery bank and inverter were sized generously.

AD

Propane incinerating toilets were better suited to remote cabins, boats, and tiny houses with limited electrical capacity. They burned gas to create intense heat, which meant they needed proper venting, a safe gas supply, and more attention to carbon monoxide risks. In 2017, the choice between electric and propane was often the single biggest decision in finding the best incinerating toilet for a specific site.

The Carefree VII Incinerating Toilet, from Incinolet (Part 2)
The Carefree VII Incinerating Toilet, from Incinolet (Part 2)
Cinderella Incineration toilet Ash
Cinderella Incineration toilet Ash
a white toilet sitting on top of a white floor
a white toilet sitting on top of a white floor
Incinerating Toilet vs Dry Flush Toilet: Which is Right for You?
Incinerating Toilet vs Dry Flush Toilet: Which is Right for You?
Cinderella Incineration Toilets
Cinderella Incineration Toilets
Your Quick Guide to Incinerating Toilets: High-Tech Waste Management [#OffGridLiving]
Your Quick Guide to Incinerating Toilets: High-Tech Waste Management [#OffGridLiving]

Top Incinerating Toilet Picks and Buying Guide for 2017

The 2017 market was not crowded, but it had recognizable leaders. Incinolet was the name most buyers encountered when searching for an electric incinerating toilet, while Storburn and Cinderella dominated conversations about propane-powered incineration. EcoJohn also appeared in off-grid and marine discussions, often with larger or more specialized systems.

Because availability and pricing varied by region, the best choice often depended on what a dealer stocked and which replacement parts could be shipped quickly. A model with strong customer support and a proven burn cycle was usually worth more than a slightly cheaper unit with unclear service.

AD

Incinolet Models and Why They Dominated Electric Incineration

Incinolet built its reputation on electric incinerating toilets that used a bowl liner, a powerful heating element, and a forced-air venting system. Models such as the Incinolet AC and AR were widely discussed in 2017 for cabins, workshops, and places where running water was impossible. Users liked that the toilet looked and functioned more like a conventional toilet than many composting alternatives.

Composting vs. Flush vs. Incinerating Toilets in a Tiny House? - #AskTheDreamTeam
Composting vs. Flush vs. Incinerating Toilets in a Tiny House? - #AskTheDreamTeam
Tiny House Incinerating Toilet - The Incinolet Review
Tiny House Incinerating Toilet - The Incinolet Review
Which Cinderella Incinerating Toilet Is Right for You? • 2026 Comparison
Which Cinderella Incinerating Toilet Is Right for You? • 2026 Comparison
DIY Incinerator Toilet: Build a Water-free Waste Solution
DIY Incinerator Toilet: Build a Water-free Waste Solution

The main trade-off was electrical demand. An Incinolet needed a dedicated circuit and enough power to complete a burn cycle, which could be a deal-breaker for small off-grid solar setups. Still, for properties with grid power or a robust generator, it was often considered the most straightforward electric option in 2017.

Storburn, Cinderella, and Propane Incinerating Toilets

Storburn was a propane incinerating toilet brand that gained a following among cabin owners who wanted waterless operation without a heavy electric load. It burned waste with propane and required venting through a wall or roof. In 2017, buyers often compared Storburn to Cinderella, a Scandinavian-style incinerating toilet that used gas and was known for a clean, compact design.

AD

Cinderella models were especially appealing in off-grid homes and recreational properties where propane was already used for heating or cooking. The downside was that propane incinerating toilets needed a safe gas installation, regular vent inspection, and a clear understanding of burn times. For many remote users, though, that trade-off was preferable to relying on a large battery bank.

Installation, Venting, and Real-World Costs

No matter which brand looked best on paper, installation often decided the winner. Incinerating toilets need a vent path to the outside, and the vent must be installed to avoid downdrafts, snow blockage, and code violations. Electric models need a dedicated circuit, while propane models need a gas line, regulator, and sometimes a separate power source for fans or controls.

Operating costs in 2017 varied widely. Electric models could add noticeable kilowatt-hour usage, especially in households with frequent use. Propane models consumed gas with every burn, but the cost per cycle depended on local fuel prices and how often the toilet was used. Buyers also had to budget for bowl liners, ash pans, gaskets, and occasional service.

Capacity, Maintenance, and User Experience

Incinerating toilets are not maintenance-free. Ash must be emptied, burn chambers may need occasional cleaning, and vents should be checked for nests, frost, or obstructions. In 2017, the most satisfied owners were usually those who understood that these toilets are appliances, not magic holes. They followed the manual, used the correct liners, and kept up with preventive care.

User experience also mattered. Some models were noisier than others, and a burn cycle could take anywhere from under an hour to much longer depending on the unit and load. A toilet that was quiet, odor-free, and simple to operate earned better reviews than one with a complicated sequence or unreliable sensors. For a family cabin, that reliability was often the difference between a convenient solution and a constant project.

Looking back at the best incinerating toilet 2017 options, the smartest choice was rarely the most expensive or the most powerful. It was the unit that matched the site's power supply, fuel storage, venting options, and daily rhythm. If you are still using one of these models today, keep the vent clear, follow the burn cycle, and stock a few spare parts before winter arrives. If you are shopping for a used unit, ask for the manual, check the heating element or burner, and confirm that replacement parts are still available. A well-maintained incinerating toilet can keep serving a remote cabin or workshop long after the original 2017 reviews have faded.

AD