Best Electric Tankless Water Heater 2019: Top 5 Picks & Buying Guide
If you were shopping for the best electric tankless water heater in 2019, you had plenty of options—but not every unit lived up to the marketing. Electric tankless heaters promised endless hot water, a smaller footprint, and lower standby losses than tank-style models. The catch was that performance depended heavily on your climate, household flow rate, and electrical panel capacity.
This guide revisits the electric tankless water heaters that stood out in 2019, including whole-house and point-of-use favorites from EcoSmart, Rheem, Stiebel Eltron, and Eemax. It also explains how to judge those models today, whether you are buying new old stock, a refurbished unit, or simply comparing an older design against a modern replacement.
What Made the Best Electric Tankless Water Heater 2019 Stand Out
In 2019, the best electric tankless water heaters balanced three things: enough kilowatts to handle cold incoming water, a flow rate that matched real household demand, and an electrical load that a home could realistically support. A 27 kW unit might look impressive on paper, but it could require a 200-amp service and several dedicated breakers. A smaller 18 kW model was often a better fit for apartments, cabins, or warmer regions.
Unlike gas tankless heaters, electric models do not vent combustion gases, so they can be installed near a point of use or in a utility closet. That flexibility made them attractive for additions, tiny homes, and retrofits. However, electric resistance heating is power-hungry, so the installation cost often came down to wiring, breakers, and panel upgrades rather than the heater itself.
Whole-House Capacity and GPM Ratings
Whole-house electric tankless water heaters were rated by flow rate, usually in gallons per minute, or GPM. That rating was not a fixed number because it changed with the temperature rise. In warm climates, where incoming groundwater might be 60°F or higher, a 24 kW unit could supply a comfortable shower and a sink at the same time. In colder climates, where incoming water might be 40°F, the same heater could struggle to maintain a single hot shower at full flow.
For 2019 shoppers, the practical target was usually 4 to 6 GPM for a small household in a mild climate and 6 to 8 GPM for larger homes or colder regions. Models like the EcoSmart ECO 27 and Stiebel Eltron Tempra 29 Plus were aimed at those higher-demand situations. Smaller units such as the EcoSmart ECO 18 and Rheem RTEX-24 were better for one or two fixtures at a time.
Electrical Requirements and Installation Costs
Electric tankless water heaters in 2019 typically required 240 volts and dedicated double-pole breakers. A modest point-of-use unit might need a single 30-amp circuit, while a whole-house 27 kW model could require three 40-amp breakers and a 200-amp electrical service. That is why many homeowners discovered that the heater price was only part of the equation.
Installation costs varied widely. If the panel had spare capacity and the water lines were nearby, a licensed electrician and plumber might finish the job for several hundred dollars. If the home needed a service upgrade from 100 amps to 200 amps, the project could easily add $1,500 to $3,000 or more. In 2019, many buyers chose a smaller heater or a point-of-use model specifically to avoid that expense.
Standout Electric Tankless Models from 2019
Several names dominated the electric tankless conversation in 2019: EcoSmart, Rheem, Stiebel Eltron, Eemax, and Bosch. Each brand had a different strength. EcoSmart appealed to budget-conscious buyers who wanted digital temperature control. Rheem offered broad availability and straightforward replacement parts. Stiebel Eltron focused on thermostatic temperature stability and premium build quality.
The "best" model depended on the job. A whole-house heater for a family of four in Florida had different needs than a point-of-use unit for a remote bathroom sink. Reviewing the standout models by use case is more useful than pretending one heater won every category.
EcoSmart ECO 27 and ECO 18
The EcoSmart ECO 27 was one of the most talked-about whole-house electric tankless heaters of 2019. Its 27 kW element and self-modulating technology let it adjust power output based on flow and temperature rise, which helped avoid sharp temperature swings. It was a strong candidate for larger homes in warm or moderate climates, especially where a 200-amp panel was already available. The ECO 18 was the smaller sibling, often chosen for apartments, cabins, and smaller homes with lower simultaneous demand.
Both models used digital temperature settings and a compact wall-mounted design. The main drawbacks were the electrical requirements and the need for careful sizing. The ECO 27 could overwhelm a 100-amp service, and even the ECO 18 needed a serious dedicated circuit. For buyers who could meet those requirements, the EcoSmart line offered a lot of heating capacity for the money in 2019.
Rheem RTEX-24 and Stiebel Eltron Tempra Series
The Rheem RTEX-24 was a popular 24 kW whole-house option with a compact footprint and simple installation. It was often stocked at home improvement stores, which made replacement and service easier for DIY-minded homeowners. Rheem positioned it for mild climates and smaller households, where it could handle a shower and a low-flow fixture without much trouble.
Stiebel Eltron's Tempra 24 Plus and Tempra 29 Plus were premium alternatives. They used thermostatic control to hold output temperature more precisely, and many users reported steadier shower temperatures than with basic modulating units. The trade-off was a higher purchase price and similarly demanding electrical needs. In 2019, the Tempra series was often recommended for homeowners who prioritized comfort over the lowest upfront cost.
How to Choose a 2019 Electric Tankless Water Heater Today
If you are considering a 2019 electric tankless water heater now, the calculation has changed slightly. You may find new old stock, refurbished units, or used models at a discount, but parts availability and warranty coverage matter more as the years pass. A heater that was excellent in 2019 can still be a smart buy if it fits your electrical system and has a clean service history.
At the same time, modern tankless electric models have added features such as Wi-Fi diagnostics, leak detection, and lower activation flow rates. A 2019 unit will not have those extras, but it can still deliver reliable hot water if it is sized correctly and maintained. The key is to compare the old model's specifications against your current household demand rather than against its original marketing claims.
Climate, Flow Rate, and Household Size
Start by measuring your incoming water temperature. In northern states, winter groundwater can be close to 40°F, while in southern states it may be 60°F or higher. The colder the incoming water, the more kilowatts you need to reach a comfortable output temperature. A 24 kW heater that feels powerful in July may feel weak in January if it was only sized for mild conditions.
Next, add up the flow rates of the fixtures you might use at the same time. A standard showerhead uses about 1.5 to 2.5 GPM, a bathroom sink about 0.5 to 1.5 GPM, a dishwasher about 1 to 2 GPM, and a washing machine about 1 to 2 GPM. If two people shower back-to-back while the dishwasher runs, a small tankless unit may not keep up. Matching the heater to those real routines is more important than chasing the highest kW rating.
Warranty, Maintenance, and Long-Term Value
Warranty terms varied in 2019, but many quality electric tankless heaters offered a limited lifetime warranty on the heat exchanger and a shorter warranty on parts and labor. If you buy a used or clearance model, confirm whether the warranty is transferable and whether the serial number has been registered. A low purchase price can disappear quickly if a failed heating element or control board is no longer covered.
Maintenance is another long-term factor. In hard water areas, scale can build up inside the heating chamber and reduce performance. Descaling with vinegar or a commercial cleaner, plus an inline filter, can extend the life of the unit. Before buying any 2019 model, read recent owner reviews for temperature fluctuations, premature failures, and customer support. The best electric tankless water heater from 2019 is the one that still has a reasonable path to parts and service in your area.
Before you commit to any specific model or year, measure your incoming water temperature, confirm your electrical panel capacity, and match the unit's GPM to your real morning routine. The best electric tankless water heater from 2019 is the one that fits your home's plumbing and power supply without constant temperature swings—and if a used or clearance unit saves money today, make sure it will not cost more in upgrades tomorrow.