all halloween candy tier list

All Halloween Candy Ranked: The Ultimate Tier List

By Kevin White
AD

Halloween, a time of tricks, treats, and unforgettable memories, is just around the corner. With it comes the annual tradition of dressed-up kids (and adults, too!) going door-to-door, exchanging innocent demands for candy with cheerful laughter and festive spirit. But not all Halloween candies are created equal. We've ranked them from best to worst, ensuring your trick-or-treating experience is nothing but treats.

Before we dive into the ultimate candy tier list, let's briefly revisit the criteria we'll use for our rankings: taste, presentation, fun factor, and childhood memories.зьWith these in mind, let's embark on this sweet, nostalgic journey.

Tier S: The Legends of Halloween

These are the creme de la creme of Halloween candy, the ones that always make the cut, no matter how full your pillowcase gets.

AD
BEST HALLOWEEN CANDIES OF ALL TIME Tier List (Community Rankings)
BEST HALLOWEEN CANDIES OF ALL TIME Tier List (Community Rankings)
a table with different types of candy on it and the names of each type of candies
a table with different types of candy on it and the names of each type of candies
the most popular halloween candy according to instacary info from @ admink com
the most popular halloween candy according to instacary info from @ admink com

Reigning supreme in this tier are the Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. Their perfect combination of chocolate and peanut butter makes them an all-time favorite. Their miniature-sized Halloween versions only enhance their already admirable qualities.

Honorable Mentions

Another fan favorite, the Snickers, makes an appearance with its savory blend of nougat, peanuts, and caramel coated in chocolate.

10 Most Popular Halloween Candies (& 5 Least Popular) | LoveToKnow
10 Most Popular Halloween Candies (& 5 Least Popular) | LoveToKnow
A Big Guide to Halloween Candy Trading | Cup of Jo
A Big Guide to Halloween Candy Trading | Cup of Jo
Top 3 Halloween Candies?
Top 3 Halloween Candies?

And how can we forget the Kit Kat, a candy bar beloved for its fingers of waffer chocolate covered in milk chocolate? Its Halloween-sized pieces are just as delightful.

Tier A: The Classic Choices

Next up, we have the classic candies that, while not the best, still make the holiday what it is.

AD

Appearing under this tier are the traditional Tootsie Pops. Their hard candy shell encasing a soft, chewy center makes them a timeless favorite, even if they inevitably end up leaving you with a mouth full of sticky sugar.

a halloween candy bar chart with the names and numbers for each item in front of it
a halloween candy bar chart with the names and numbers for each item in front of it
New Study: This Is the Most Popular Halloween Candy in Your State
New Study: This Is the Most Popular Halloween Candy in Your State
several different types of candy are shown with the words, 2 sweets and two bags
several different types of candy are shown with the words, 2 sweets and two bags
the halloween candy info sheet is shown in this graphic diagram, which shows different types of candy
the halloween candy info sheet is shown in this graphic diagram, which shows different types of candy
MOST POPULAR HALLOWEEN CANDIES
MOST POPULAR HALLOWEEN CANDIES
My honest tier list
My honest tier list

More Popular Picks

Also in this tier, we find the M&Ms. Available in a wide range of flavors, M&Ms are great for sharing, and their bright colors provide a fun twist on the typical chocolate treat.

The Milky Way also earns a spot here, with its chewy caramel and nougat covered in thick, smooth milk chocolate. It might not be the most creative option, but it's a solid choice nonetheless.

AD

Tier B: Fun, But Not Mondelez-Worthy

Moving on, we find ourselves in the realm of candies that, while enjoyable, might not be the first (or even second) choice on your treat bucket.

The most popular Halloween candy in every state
The most popular Halloween candy in every state

A candy that lands here is the Twix. With its crumbly shortbread and unique texture, it's an interesting choice. However, its main drawback is the way the edges crumble into a unsatisfying mess post-bite.

Flavorful, But Falling Short

The Lifesavers Gummies, with their fruit-flavored, brain-invoking design, are a fun option. But they lack the lasting power of some of the other candies, making them a one-note treat.

AD

The Airheads also earn a spot here, with their mouthwatering flavors and chewy texture. However, their firm consistency can be somewhat unappealing when overworked, adding them to our list of peculiar treats.

Tier C: Savory and Sweet Combos

Now, we venture into the realm of mixed-ingredient candies - those that try to win you over with their savory-sweet fusion.

The PayDay, with its ooey-gooey caramel and protein-filled peanuts, is one such attempt. While it may have good intentions, the peanut-heavy flavor and texture can be a turn-off for those looking for a purely sweet treat.

The Savory Experiment

The Crunch Bar also lands in this tier with its combination of peanut butter, crispy rice cereal, and milk chocolate. While the texture is appealing, the candy can be a little heavy on the peanut flavor, deterring non-fans.

The Take 5 also appears on this list, with its peculiar mix of caramel, crisped rice, peanut butter, and pretzels. While some may enjoy the added crunch, others might not be thrilled about the unexpected medley of flavors.

Tier D: The Controversial Choices

Next up, we encounter the controversial candies, those that spark debate and raised eyebrows every Halloween.

The Necco Wafers are a polarizing choice, with their slightly chalky texture and overwhelmingly interchangeable flavors. Many forget what they disliked so much about them in the first place, only to be reminded by their annual reappearance.

Unconventional Picks

The Chick-O-Stick, with its milky, peanut butter exterior and crunchy peanut interior, is another candy that splits the crowd. Those who hate peanut butter will have no love for this treat, while peanut butter lovers may be left craving more.

Lastly, the Mary Janes - a burnt peanut sorts flavor, encased in a hard, sugar exterior. This candy is divisive at best, with its unique flavor and texture leaving some candy connoisseurs wondering if they've been tricked rather than treated.

Tier F: The Sour Grapes

Finally, we arrive at the tier that every candy eventuality should avoid. These are the candies that, for one reason or another, leave a bad taste in your mouth - literally.

Taking the crown for worst Halloween candy is the Lemon Drop. While many enjoy the pop of sourness, the candy's reluctance to hold its flavor for more than a couple of seconds makes it a disappointment, leaving a lackluster aftertaste.

The Straight-Up Duds

The Candy Corn, with its notoriously polarizing flavor, is a constant presence on worst candy lists. Those who dislike its waxy texture and substitution of as many spices as sugar to mask its neutral flavor can enjoy the candy sight unseen.

Lastly, we have the Wax Coke Bottles. With their unappealing texture and uninspired flavor, these candies are an insult to all candy lovers. They're the perfect embodiment of a disappointing trick-or-treat.

There you have it - the ultimate Halloween candy tier list. Whether you're a Reese's aficionado or a Milky Way maximalist, there's a treat out there for everyone. So, as you prepare for All Hallows' Eve, remember to enjoy the variety that the holiday offers, and make the most of each candy-filled moment. Here's to a happy and sweet Halloween!

AD