alignment chart meme hema

Alignment Chart Meme HEMA: The Ultimate Historical European Martial Arts Morality Guide

By Joshua Wilson
AD

If you have spent any time in a HEMA (Historical European Martial Arts) club, you have probably seen the alignment chart meme make the rounds. The 3x3 grid borrowed from Dungeons & Dragons sorts everyone from Lawful Good to Chaotic Evil, and HEMA practitioners have applied it to longsword fencers, rapier duelists, gear hoarders, and the person who treats every sparring bout like a judicial duel. It is a simple format, but it says a lot about how we see ourselves and each other.

What makes the alignment chart meme HEMA-specific is the way it mixes source tradition with modern club culture. You can be lawful about Fiore's plays and chaotic about tournament rules. You can be good about helping beginners and evil about hogging the piste. The meme works because HEMA is equal parts historical study, martial art, sport, and social experiment.

What the Alignment Chart Meme Means in HEMA

The original alignment chart comes from D&D, where characters are rated on two axes: lawful versus chaotic, and good versus evil. Lawful characters follow codes, traditions, and structures. Chaotic characters prioritize freedom, improvisation, and personal judgment. Good characters act for others, while evil characters act for themselves. In HEMA, those axes are not about moral absolutes. They are about how someone approaches fencing, training, and community.

AD
"Decime nya"
"Decime nya"
Alignment chart
Alignment chart
four squares that have different words in them
four squares that have different words in them

When HEMA fencers make an alignment chart, they usually map behaviors rather than actual ethics. A Lawful Good longsword instructor might insist on safe gear, correct technique, and helping every new student. A Chaotic Evil rapier fencer might ignore safety calls, argue with directors, and still somehow win the bout. The joke lands because most of us know exactly which square we occupy, even if we would never admit it publicly.

Lawful vs Chaotic in the Salle

The lawful-chaotic axis in HEMA often revolves around sources and rules. Lawful fencers love the manual. They can quote Liechtenauer, Fiore, Meyer, or Silver the way other people quote movie lines. They follow the drill, respect the instructor, and treat sparring as a structured lesson. Chaotic fencers love the experiment. They might blend sources, try a weird guard from a forgotten treatise, or turn a standard drill into a free-form wrestling match.

credit to original creator
credit to original creator
an image of some sort of words that are in the form of letters and numbers
an image of some sort of words that are in the form of letters and numbers
Character chart
Character chart

Neither approach is automatically better. A lawful fencer can become rigid, refusing to adapt when a technique fails under pressure. A chaotic fencer can become undisciplined, throwing away structure before understanding why it exists. The best HEMA training usually borrows from both: use the source as a foundation, then test it with creative, resistant sparring. The alignment chart meme simply exaggerates those tendencies for laughs.

Good vs Evil as Community Impact

In HEMA memes, good and evil rarely mean someone is a villain. They describe how a person affects the club. Good HEMA behavior looks like sharing water, checking masks, giving constructive feedback, and acknowledging a clean hit. Evil HEMA behavior looks like unsafe sparring, constant excuse-making, gatekeeping, or treating beginners as targets. The axis is about whether someone leaves the room better or worse after training.

AD

This is why the alignment chart meme HEMA version can be surprisingly accurate. The person who volunteers to run warm-ups and the person who complains about every director decision may both be skilled fencers, but they create different club cultures. The meme gives people a playful way to talk about those differences without starting a formal argument. It is social commentary wrapped in a pixelated grid.

some sort of words that are in the same language, and one has an image on it
some sort of words that are in the same language, and one has an image on it
Cursed image | Alignment Charts
Cursed image | Alignment Charts
a sheet with writing on it that says, finish the heart and then draw hearts
a sheet with writing on it that says, finish the heart and then draw hearts
𝓓𝓸 𝓲𝓽... 𝓝𝓸𝔀...
𝓓𝓸 𝓲𝓽... 𝓝𝓸𝔀...
the alignment chart for an argument
the alignment chart for an argument
Funny Social Media Posts, Funny Mental Health Meme, How To Assess Mental Stability, Mental Health Self-assessment Chart, Self-assessment Humor Chart, 3x3 Alignment Chart, Character Charts, Character Ranking Template, Friend Group Alignment Chart
Funny Social Media Posts, Funny Mental Health Meme, How To Assess Mental Stability, Mental Health Self-assessment Chart, Self-assessment Humor Chart, 3x3 Alignment Chart, Character Charts, Character Ranking Template, Friend Group Alignment Chart

Building a HEMA Alignment Chart for Your Club

Creating your own HEMA alignment chart is easier than memorizing the Zwerchhau. Start with the nine alignment boxes, then fill each one with a familiar club archetype. You can base the chart on weapons, tournament habits, gear choices, or source preferences. The best charts feel specific enough to be true and broad enough that everyone can laugh at themselves.

The key is to avoid turning it into a personal attack. An alignment chart works when it targets shared experiences: the fencer who brings three swords to practice, the one who only trains winden, the one who argues about feder versus blunt, or the one who has never met a rule they could not interpret creatively. Keep the jokes affectionate and the examples recognizable.

AD

Classic HEMA Archetypes by Alignment

Most HEMA alignment charts include a few predictable archetypes. The Lawful Good fencer is the safety-conscious mentor who remembers everyone's name and still drills fundamentals. The Neutral Good fencer is the reliable sparring partner who adjusts intensity for every opponent. The Chaotic Good fencer is the creative technician who invents weird plays but always helps you understand what happened.

Oc prompt 5
Oc prompt 5
another alignment chart yay πŸ₯Ή
another alignment chart yay πŸ₯Ή
restaurant gets ordered wrong
restaurant gets ordered wrong

On the other side, Lawful Neutral might be the rule-following tournament official who knows the rulebook better than the organizers. True Neutral might be the fencer who just loves swords and has no strong opinion on any manual. Chaotic Neutral might be the gear-obsessed tinkerer who modifies hilts and guards between rounds. Then come the evil boxes, usually played for humor: Lawful Evil is the rules lawyer, Neutral Evil is the sandbagger, and Chaotic Evil is the person who ignores safety calls and calls it intensity.

  • Lawful Good: The patient instructor who checks masks and teaches footwork without sighing.
  • Neutral Good: The dependable sparring partner who matches your level and gives useful tips.
  • Chaotic Good: The creative fencer who tries strange techniques but never leaves you unsafe.
  • Lawful Neutral: The rules expert who can cite tournament policy from memory.
  • True Neutral: The sword lover who shows up, trains hard, and avoids drama.
  • Chaotic Neutral: The gear tinkerer who owns six feder variants and no two matching gloves.
  • Lawful Evil: The rules lawyer who finds loopholes in every sparring agreement.
  • Neutral Evil: The sandbagger who pretends to be a beginner until the bracket starts.
  • Chaotic Evil: The unsafe hothead who treats every bout like a duel to the death.

How to Use the Meme Without Being a Jerk

Like any internet meme, the HEMA alignment chart can go wrong if it becomes a way to bully people. The humor should punch at shared habits, not at someone's identity, skill level, or body. If a club member would not laugh at their square, it is probably not a good joke. Use the meme to build camaraderie, not to create a secret ranking system.

AD

You can also use the chart as a lightweight self-assessment. Ask yourself where you land on source fidelity, safety, sportsmanship, and adaptability. Maybe you are Lawful Good in drills but Chaotic Neutral in open sparring. That kind of self-awareness is more useful than any meme. The chart is a mirror, not a verdict.

Whether you fence longsword, rapier, sabre, or sword and buckler, the alignment chart meme HEMA style will keep evolving as the community grows. New weapons, new rule sets, and new inside jokes will fill fresh squares. So the next time someone posts a grid in your club chat, do not just scroll past it. Claim your square, defend it with a treatise quote, and maybe bring snacks for the Chaotic Good fencer who forgot to eat before practice.

AD