a wrinkle in time review

A Wrinkle in Time Review: A Timeless Journey or Missed Opportunity?

By Melissa Allen
AD

A Wrinkle in Time review often begins with a confession: this is not just a children's book. Madeleine L'Engle's 1962 novel is a genre-defying blend of science fiction, fantasy, and spiritual allegory that has captivated millions of readers across generations. It won the Newbery Medal in 1963 and has never gone out of print, a testament to its timeless themes of love, individuality, and the battle between light and darkness. Whether you are revisiting it as an adult or discovering it for the first time, this review will explore why the book remains a cornerstone of young adult literature.

The story follows Meg Murry, a brilliant but insecure teenager, her extraordinary younger brother Charles Wallace, and their new friend Calvin O'Keefe as they travel through space and time to rescue Meg's missing father. Guided by three celestial beings—Mrs. Whatsit, Mrs. Who, and Mrs. Which—they confront a dark force that threatens to consume the universe. What makes this A Wrinkle in Time review essential is how it balances cosmic stakes with deeply personal struggles, creating a narrative that feels both epic and intimate. Let's dive into the elements that make this novel a lasting masterpiece.

The Enduring Legacy of Madeleine L'Engle's Classic

When A Wrinkle in Time was first published, it faced numerous rejections. Publishers found its mix of science and religion too unconventional for children's literature. L'Engle persevered, and the book eventually found a home at Farrar, Straus and Giroux. Its initial success was modest, but word-of-mouth and classroom adoption turned it into a phenomenon. Today, it is celebrated as a groundbreaking work that proved young readers could handle complex philosophical ideas.

AD
A Wrinkle in Time Summary and Key Themes
A Wrinkle in Time Summary and Key Themes
Free Wrinkle in Time Reading Comprehension Worksheets | Woo! Jr. Kids Activities : Children's Publishing
Free Wrinkle in Time Reading Comprehension Worksheets | Woo! Jr. Kids Activities : Children's Publishing
the movie wrinkle in time is on dvd
the movie wrinkle in time is on dvd

The novel's legacy extends beyond its sales figures. It paved the way for science fantasy hybrids and inspired authors like Rebecca Stead and Kate DiCamillo. L'Engle wrote four sequels and a companion novel, expanding the Murry family's universe. The book also sparked conversations about the intersection of faith and science, a topic L'Engle explored throughout her career. Its Newbery Medal win cemented its place in the canon, and its frequent appearance on banned book lists only underscores its cultural impact.

Plot Overview and Core Premise

The plot kicks off on a dark and stormy night when Meg, feeling like a misfit, encounters Mrs. Whatsit, a peculiar old woman who lives in a haunted house. Soon Meg, Charles Wallace, and Calvin learn about the tesseract—a wrinkle in time that allows instantaneous travel across the universe. Their mission: find Meg's father, a scientist who disappeared while working on a secret government project involving faster-than-light travel. The journey takes them to the planet Camazotz, where a giant brain called IT controls everyone's thoughts, enforcing absolute conformity.

A Wrinkle In Time
A Wrinkle In Time
A Wrinkle in Time - Book Review
A Wrinkle in Time - Book Review
a page from the wrinkle in time discussion guide, which includes questions for each topic
a page from the wrinkle in time discussion guide, which includes questions for each topic

As the children navigate alien landscapes and terrifying encounters, they must rely on their unique strengths to survive. Charles Wallace's genius makes him a target for IT, while Meg's stubbornness and love become their greatest weapons. The climax is not a physical battle but an emotional one, where Meg must confront her own flaws and use them to save her brother. This A Wrinkle in Time review highlights that the plot is deceptively simple, but its layers of meaning reward repeated readings.

Themes of Good Versus Evil and the Power of Individuality

At its heart, the novel is a classic tale of light versus darkness. The Black Thing, a shadowy evil force, threatens to engulf entire planets. On Camazotz, IT represents the ultimate loss of self—a hive mind where everyone thinks, acts, and lives identically. L'Engle paints conformity as a form of death, arguing that true freedom lies in embracing one's quirks and imperfections. This theme resonates powerfully in an era of social media echo chambers and algorithmic homogenization.

AD

Meg's journey is particularly poignant because she learns that her greatest weaknesses—impatience, anger, and insecurity—are actually her strengths. Her ability to love fiercely and think independently allows her to defeat IT. The novel also explores the idea that faith and science are not mutually exclusive. L'Engle, a devout Christian, wove biblical references and quantum physics into a seamless tapestry, suggesting that the universe is both mysterious and knowable. This spiritual dimension adds depth without becoming preachy.

A Wrinkle in Time Movie Review | Should I take my kids to see it?
A Wrinkle in Time Movie Review | Should I take my kids to see it?
Inspiration gets lost in “A Wrinkle in Time”
Inspiration gets lost in “A Wrinkle in Time”
A Wrinkle In Time PDF Activity Sheets and Parent Movie Review
A Wrinkle In Time PDF Activity Sheets and Parent Movie Review
a poster for the movie x - men days of future past
a poster for the movie x - men days of future past
Should Small Kids See A Wrinkle In Time – A No Spoiler Review
Should Small Kids See A Wrinkle In Time – A No Spoiler Review
A Wrinkle in Time Activities and Free Resources for the Classroom! – Student Savvy
A Wrinkle in Time Activities and Free Resources for the Classroom! – Student Savvy

Characters and Their Emotional Depth

L'Engle's characters are not archetypes; they are messy, real, and deeply relatable. Meg is a far cry from the perfect heroines of many children's books. She gets into fights, talks back to teachers, and feels like a failure. Her emotional arc is the engine of the story, and readers root for her because she embodies the awkwardness and self-doubt we all experience. The supporting cast is equally memorable, each serving a specific purpose in the narrative while feeling like fully realized individuals.

What sets the novel apart is how L'Engle uses her characters to explore abstract concepts. Charles Wallace is a genius but also vulnerable, a reminder that intelligence without empathy can be dangerous. Calvin is the popular kid who feels like an outsider, showing that belonging is not about fitting in. The three Mrs. W's are whimsical guides who provide cryptic wisdom and comic relief. Their interactions reveal that heroism is not about being fearless but about acting despite fear.

AD

Meg Murry's Journey of Self-Acceptance

Meg's internal conflict is the emotional core of the book. She compares herself unfavorably to her beautiful mother and brilliant father, feeling like the "odd one out." Her anger often gets her into trouble, and she struggles to control her emotions. Yet these very traits make her immune to IT's mind control, because she refuses to conform. Her transformation is gradual—she doesn't become perfect; she simply learns to value what makes her different. This is a powerful message for young readers navigating their own insecurities.

Novel Study: A Wrinkle in Time: Dare to Be Different | Worksheet | Education.com
Novel Study: A Wrinkle in Time: Dare to Be Different | Worksheet | Education.com
Review: A Wrinkle in Time - Old Ain't Dead
Review: A Wrinkle in Time - Old Ain't Dead
A Wrinkle In Time Page 34
A Wrinkle In Time Page 34
some thought you have when reading a wrinkle in time as an adult quote
some thought you have when reading a wrinkle in time as an adult quote

By the end, Meg realizes that love is not a weakness but a weapon. When she faces IT, she doesn't use logic or force; she uses her deep affection for Charles Wallace to pull him back from the brink. This climax is a masterclass in emotional payoff. It shows that heroism can be quiet, personal, and driven by connection rather than conquest. Meg's story continues in later books, but this first arc remains the most satisfying and transformative.

Supporting Cast: Charles Wallace, Calvin, and the Mrs. W's

Charles Wallace is one of the most intriguing child characters in literature. He is a telepath, a prodigy, and an old soul in a five-year-old body. His vulnerability becomes apparent when IT tempts him with promises of power and belonging. His possession by IT is terrifying because it shows how even the brightest minds can be corrupted. Calvin, on the other hand, is the emotional anchor. He comes from a dysfunctional family and finds solace in the Murrys. His empathy and loyalty balance Meg's impulsiveness.

AD

The three Mrs. W's—Whatsit, Who, and Which—are delightful enigmas. Mrs. Whatsit is the youngest and most impetuous, often speaking in riddles. Mrs. Who quotes famous thinkers in multiple languages, adding literary depth. Mrs. Which is the oldest and most powerful, appearing as a shimmering light. They are not just plot devices; they represent different facets of wisdom. Their eccentricities make them memorable, and their ultimate purpose—to guide Meg toward her own strength—reinforces the novel's theme of self-discovery.

Adaptations and Their Reception

Bringing A Wrinkle in Time to the screen is notoriously difficult. The novel's abstract concepts—tesseracts, the Black Thing, IT—resist literal visualization. The first attempt was a 2003 Disney television film, followed by a big-budget 2018 adaptation directed by Ava DuVernay. Each took significant liberties with the source material, and each received mixed reviews. A thorough A Wrinkle in Time review must consider these adaptations, as they introduce the story to new audiences while also highlighting why the book remains superior.

The 2003 version, starring Katie Stuart as Meg and Alfre Woodard as Mrs. Which, was a modest production that aired on ABC. It condensed the plot and softened some of the darker elements, making it more palatable for younger children. The 2018 film, however, was a major event. With a diverse cast including Storm Reid, Oprah Winfrey, Reese Witherspoon, and Mindy Kaling, it aimed to be a visual spectacle. Unfortunately, critical response was polarized, with many complaining that the emotional core was lost in a sea of CGI.

The 2003 Disney Television Film

The 2003 adaptation is often forgotten, but it has its charms. It stays relatively faithful to the book's structure, including the trip to Camazotz and the confrontation with IT. The acting is earnest, and the low-budget effects give it a nostalgic, almost stage-play quality. However, it rushes through key moments and fails to capture the novel's philosophical depth. Meg's internal monologue, so crucial in the book, is largely absent, making her character feel flatter.

Critics at the time found it mediocre, and L'Engle herself reportedly disliked it. Yet for a generation of children who saw it on television, it served as an introduction to the story. It remains a curiosity for completists, but it lacks the emotional resonance and imaginative scope of the novel. If you are seeking a faithful adaptation, this is not it, but it is an interesting artifact of early 2000s children's television.

The 2018 Ava DuVernay Adaptation

The 2018 film was a bold, visually stunning reinterpretation. DuVernay brought her signature style, using vibrant colors and diverse casting to create a world that felt inclusive and magical. Storm Reid delivered a strong performance as Meg, and the chemistry between the young leads was genuine. The film also expanded the role of Mrs. Which, giving Oprah Winfrey a commanding presence. It tackled themes of bullying, self-worth, and the power of love with sincerity.

Despite these strengths, the film received mixed to negative reviews. Critics argued that the pacing was uneven, the explanations of tesseracts and the Black Thing were clumsy, and the climax felt unearned. Many fans of the book felt that the adaptation prioritized spectacle over substance. However, it found a devoted audience among younger viewers and families, and it sparked renewed interest in the novel. As a companion piece, it offers a different perspective, but the book remains the definitive experience.

Is A Wrinkle in Time Worth Reading Today?

Absolutely. In a world saturated with dystopian YA novels and fast-paced fantasy series, A Wrinkle in Time stands out for its quiet radicalism. It asks big questions about the nature of evil, the value of individuality, and the power of love without resorting to cynicism. Its prose is lyrical but accessible, making it suitable for readers aged nine and up. Adults will find new layers of meaning with each reread, particularly its reflections on faith, science, and the courage to be different.

The novel's relevance has only grown. Its critique of conformity and groupthink feels prescient in the age of viral trends and political polarization. Meg's struggle with self-worth mirrors the mental health challenges many young people face today. The book does not offer easy answers; instead, it invites readers to embrace mystery and complexity. That is why it continues to be taught in schools, recommended by librarians, and cherished by families.

Who Will Love This Book (and Who Might Not)

This book is ideal for readers who enjoy science fantasy, philosophical puzzles, and strong female protagonists. Fans of His Dark Materials or The Giver will appreciate its intellectual ambition. Teachers and parents looking for a story that sparks discussions about good and evil, free will, and faith will find it invaluable. It is also a wonderful read-aloud for families, as the chapters are short and the cliffhangers are compelling.

However, readers who prefer action-packed plots with clear explanations may find the novel slow or confusing. L'Engle does not spoon-feed her audience; she expects them to ponder the tesseract and the Black Thing. Some may also find the religious undertones off-putting, though they are woven subtly into the narrative. If you prefer hard science fiction or realistic fiction, this might not be your cup of tea. But if you are open to a genre-bending journey, it is deeply rewarding.

Final Verdict and Recommendation

A Wrinkle in Time is not a perfect novel—its pacing stumbles in the middle, and some of its scientific explanations are hand-wavy. Yet its imperfections are part of its charm. It is a book that trusts young readers to grapple with big ideas, and that trust is repaid with lifelong loyalty. The characters feel like old friends, and the themes resonate long after the last page. For anyone seeking a story about love conquering fear, this is essential reading.

My recommendation is simple: pick up a copy, preferably a worn paperback with a classic cover. Read it alone on a rainy afternoon, or share it with a child. Let yourself be swept away by the tesseract and the Mrs. W's. Then ask yourself: what would you do if you had to face IT? The answer might surprise you. This A Wrinkle in Time review concludes that the book is not just a classic—it is a necessity.

So many books fade into obscurity, but L'Engle's masterpiece continues to find new readers because it speaks to something universal: the longing to belong without losing oneself. Whether you are a longtime fan or a curious newcomer, there is always something new to discover in its pages. The next time you feel like a misfit, remember Meg Murry. Her journey reminds us that our flaws are not liabilities; they are the very things that make us capable of love, courage, and change. Go ahead and wrinkle your own time.

AD